Monday, September 24, 2007

Blawg Review #76

It is my honour to host the Blawg Review, a weekly selection of blogs related to the law.

Since I am not a lawyer, and this blog site is meant to appeal to a broad international audience working in a wide variety of professions and industries, I have (as previously announced) restricted my choices to the themes of work and professional life, firm management, marketing, strategy and careers (rather than legal topics per se).

1. Competition v. Collaboration in Firms

Tom "Bald Dog" Varjan has the blog post of the week in my view.

Of Sailors and Mountaineers: The Inherent Dangers of Internal Competition is a compelling piece of analysis, which nevertheless still leaves us wrestling with the mysteries of why our organisations run as they do. Are we all too competitive for our own good? If so, how has civilisation thrived? Don't miss it.

2. Throttling Clients

Ed Wesemann has a terrific blog for law firms called Creating Dominance, and his latest post is about "throttling" clients (no, it doesn't mean what you think it means). It's not glamorous stuff, but it's important.

He discusses how he went about analysing low-profitability clients, and then engaging actions which induced the clients to change their behavior (or leave). A clear exposition of some basic that all firms should be doing – and don't!

3. Work-Life Balance

Stephanie West Allen at idealawg introduces us to Hot Worms and Workaholics: Let the Workers Be! She tells us that some worms live in water so hot that it would kill other worms:

"I have met many hot worm lawyers and I suspect there may be whole firms composed primarily of hot worms. These lawyers thrive on conditions that might prove injurious or even fatal to other lawyers. I am concerned for the hot worm lawyers and the damage that might be done to them if someone decided that these torrid wigglers needed to swim in cooler waters, to achieve life balance as defined by some other worm. In many cases, a cool, balanced worm may be an unhappy or dead worm. Lawyers come in a wide variety of temperaments, each with a unique, individual, ideal allocation of what and how much goes on each scale of life. That uniqueness is best respected for the sake of the lawyer, the firm, and the client."

Fascinating -- a wonderful counter-conventional blog post.

4. Advice for Young Professionals

Bruce MacEwan at Adam Smith, Esq. has a review of "The Curmudgeon's Guide to Practicing Law” (ABA, 2006), a wonderful book from Mark Hermann (of Jones Day). With great humor and deadly accuracy, Mr. Hermann cuts through the cant and provides tough love advice for those on their way up (and a few who have stopped rising).

I have read the book, and "Adam" is right. Managing partners in law firms should buy copies for all their junior lawyers. In addition, I would estimate that at least one-half of the book applies to all young professionals, in any industry.

5. Leadership, Emotions and Performance

Arnie Herz at legal sanity, reporting on a Harvard Working Knowledge forum, explores the role of positive leadership in creating the motivation, creativity, and performance of the knowledge workers.

Arnie reports that, according to the piece, a key discovery the researchers made is that workers' performance is tied to their "emotions, motivations, and perceptions about their work environment". There are lots of other good links in the blog to research in the field of "Positive Organisational Scholarship."

6. Must BigClients have BigFirms?

JD Hull at What About Clients? estimates that "bet the company work" is perhaps 10% of legal corporate work out there, if that. So what about the other 90% of available corporate legal work? Is there any reason why firms ranging in size from 5 to 150 lawyers with the right talent and specialties can't do that work for BigClients?

The questions is raised: when firms large and small can serve your needs, where do you go? Think carefully, and on the back of examination booklet explain why friendly neighbourhood grocery stores no longer exist.

6. Future Earning Potential of Firms

Gerry Riskin of Amazing Firms, Amazing Practices provides a link to an article by his EDGE International colleague, Friedrich Blase, on assessing a firm's future earning potential by examining its human capital, its structural capital, its relational capital and its investment capacity.

It will start your thinking processes -- there's a lot to be done exploring these topics.

7. Advice on the road to L

F/k/a [formerly known as] links to a number of law professors offering advice to first-year law students, and offers the observation that "much of that 'lost' feeling never does go away -- because far too many law school applicants, law students and practicing lawyers never took the time to assess who they really are and what they actually do want from life and from a career."

Like the rest of us.

8. Client Satisfaction

Mark Beese at Leadership for Lawyers continues the (re)announcement of survey company BTI's results that clients' satisfaction with lawyers is going down dramatically, but provides link to other surveys and sources with confirming data.

BTI's findings (which have been extensively reported for a while now) should be the springboard for deeper discussion of the sources and cures of low client satisfaction in the law, but so far the analysis hasn't progressed -- at least in the blogosphere. Let's hope the firms themselves are taking the hint.

9. Recruiting Interviews

Eric Muller at Is That Legal? contributes a memory about being "conned" at an interview by one law firm partner into commenting on someone at another law firm who turned out to be her husband.

Ethical or good recruiting tactic? You be the judge!

10. Spotting the Winners Early

Carolyn Elefant at Law.com Legal Blog Watch reports in A Future Billing Machine is Born about a Washington Post story on a young man, Dravidian, who:

"whipped through college in one year, relying on a combination of 72 AP credits that he collected in high school, followed by 23 credits his first semester in college (instead of the usual 15), a whopping 37 credits the next (he'd complained that he had too much time on his hands the first semester), with the last three, needed for a double major, completed during the summer. The article reports that after finishing up a master's in math, Banh will forego the doctorate and head to law school to become a patent attorney."

As Elefant puts it: law firms, start your recruiting engines.

11. A Harvard Business School Case Study

Nathan Koppel, guest blogging at Larry Bodine's Professional Services Marketing blog, informs us that Harvard Business School has written a 40-page case study on Philadelphia's Duane Morris.

Based on my memory of how MBA students treated the companies offered up to them for dissection, this may not be the privilege that some at Duane Morris think it could be.

12. Diagnosis in Law and Medicine

Jim Belshaw at Managing the Professional Service Firm (what a catchy name!) picks up on a contribution by Prem Chandavarkar to begin an analysis of how diagnosis is performed in law versus medicine.

It doesn't go deep, but it's a useful beginning on an important topic.

13. Branding a Fruit

Dilanchian Lawyers and Consultants caught my attention by telling the history of transforming the humble Kiwi fruit, through wise use of Intellectual Property tactics, into a branded product.

A bit of a diversion from our theme here, but a fun blawg tale.

Next, let's turn to some interesting blogs about blogging.

14. Marketing Yourself and Your Practice

Kevin O'Keefe at Real Lawyers Have Blogs reports on "Blonde attorney gets new clients at MySpace."

No comment. Decide for yourself what you think about it.

15. Profile of a Prominent Blogger

Dennis Kennedy provides a useful link to an interview with (and about) him on the JD Bliss site, entitled Success Story: Dennis Kennedy: "TechnoLawyer of the Year" Bridges the Gap Between Law and Technology.

For the few who don't know his background, it's a good place to start getting to know the well-known lawyer, consultant, speaker and writer who is considered among the most influential experts on the application of technology in the practice of law.

Dennis was very kind and generous with his time when I was trying to understand what a blog was. If you don't know him and his work, you should.

16. Blogging by Trainees

Scott Vine at Information Overlord picks up on a UK Legal week report that Watson Farley & Williams is getting its trainees to write a weekly blog on the firm's web site. Each of the firm's 12 trainees will take it in turns to write the weekly blog, describing the work they have been involved in and the firm's training and social activities. Neat!

17. Blogging During a Court Case

Justin Patten at Human Law has a brief piece speculating on how blogging might influence the practice of law: "I envisage scenarios where lawyers in conjunction with PR Professionals and blogosphere monitoring tools, assess how a case is being seen on the web. Thereafter an assessment will be made whether a legal remedy is the right solution."

18. Regulatory Restrictions on Blogging

Walter Olson at Point of Law collects some links pointing to the emerging concern that new Bar regulations in New York "might make it nearly impossible for attorneys in the state to publish or contribute to blogs about the law. (Each individual post would trigger elaborate compliance obligations of its own.)"

19. Blogging as a Substitute for Law Reviews

Ian Best at 3Lepiphany speculates that blogging by law students and others could create a much more powerful substitute for law review articles.

Seems persuasive, important and powerful to me.


That's it!

Blawg Review has information about next week's host, and instructions how to submit your blawg posts for review in upcoming issues.

Dynamos -- new careers videocast & audiocast

In the 23rd episode of this series, we are going to look at the issues of motivation, excitement and drive over the course of a career. At any given time, professionals can fall into one of three categories: dynamos, cruisers or losers. We will look at the affects that these different mindsets have on an organisation and what managers must do to instill excitement in the workplace.

Audio Timeline

00:39 -- Introduction
00:57 -- Three stages of energy and drive: Dynamos, Cruisers, and losers
04:45 -- The role of the manager in helping underperformers
05:38 -- Mobilising the organisation through excitement
09:18 -- Conclusion

You can download Dynamos or sign up to receive new videos automatically with iTunes or other video players. (Click here for step-by-step instructions on how to subscribe.) My seminars are always available for download at no cost.

Saturday, September 22, 2007

How to Get Ahead: Lie and Cheat?

Steve Shu brought my attention to a fascinating article reporting on a study of 5,000 MBA students from 11 graduate business schools in Canada and 21 schools in the U.S.

The study is entitled "Academic Dishonesty in Graduate Business Programs: The Prevalence, Causes, and Proposed Actions". It was conducted by management professors at Rutgers, Washington State and Pennsylvania State universities, and will appear in the next issue of the Academy of Management Learning & Education journal.

The study found that 56 per cent of graduate business students admitted to cheating in the last year, compared with 47 per cent of non-business students.

Jim Fisher, vice-dean of MBA programs at the University of Toronto's Rotman School of Management, said he wasn't surprised by the results, since MBA students are highly competitive and have a high need for achievement.

To dampen the impulse to cheat, students at Rotman must sign a form every time they submit course work for grading to ensure they comply with academic honesty policies. When MBA students work in teams, they also must sign forms stating that they didn't cheat, nor did their team-mates.

"Those numbers are probably under-reported," said Donald McCabe, lead researcher on the study and business strategy professor at Rutgers. Since the survey was voluntary, more dishonest students were less likely to fill out the survey, and those who did complete it may have under-reported how much they cheated, McCabe said.

The study suggested that MBA students were more likely to cheat than others because they were focused on "getting the job done, versus how they got it done. They will suggest, in the business world the emphasis is on getting the job done at any cost."

"There is also employer pressure to get high marks," Larry Wynant of the University of western Ontario said. "The past few years there has been tremendous pressure to get jobs, because the employment outlook has not been as rosy (for MBA graduates) as in the past."

I read this at the same time that that the "20-something" daughter of some good friends was telling us about her new job as a personal assistant in the world of public relations. She pointed out, with great discomfort, that it was not unusual for her boss to say "I worked on the XYZ account for 4 hours but bill them for 20." There's even a word for this form of lying in PR firms, accounting firms, consulting firms and law firms: "value billing."

I have no problem billing a client BY AGREEMENT on what a project was worth, but the casual acceptance of lies astonishes me.

We have crossed over into dangerous territory. When there is the normal expectation that most other people will cheat (given the opportunity) things WILL rapidly descend into the expectation that everyone will. We then have a distrustful, society based on the expectation of corruption -- and everyone becomes super-defensive.

I won't say I have never, ever sinned, especially when I was young and stupid. But what kept me on the true path was the overwhelming sense of guilt and the consequent vow that I would never lapse again. It is one thing to succumb to temptation. It is another to give up one's very belief in principles and pass that cynicism and scepticism on to those around us and to those who report to us.

What happens if, in school and in the first job, we raise a generation of people who think lying, cheating and stealing are the ways you get ahead?

Friday, September 21, 2007

Some Principles of Presentations and Pitches

When giving a presentation, you can focus on one of three things: your material (we must cover all these slides), yourself (let me impress you), or your audience (let me serve you in some way). Guess which it should be.

Make sure you address the audience's needs, concerns, wants -- not yours. They will give you back what you want if you serve them first.

Nothing is more guaranteed to lose an audience than forcing them to sit in a darkened room watching someone go through a fixed, invariant set of slides, no matter how insightful or attractive. Turn the house lights full up so you can see everyone. Hand out copies of all your slides in advance. Work to EARN your audience's attention. Don't try to control their attention -- they will just resent it.

If you get through all your material, the presentation is a failure. If you cover your all of your material, you obviously did not engage and were not interrupted enough by the audience's questions.

Clear exposition is rare and immensely valuable; get all the help you can get. Rehearse with an audience who have been given permission to critique.

When giving a presentation, write down in advance (just for your own benefit) the major points you want your audience to walk away with. If it doesn’t fit on one small card, your presentation is too unfocused.

Don't underestimate the value of a nicely turned phase: Make it memorable! Try to find the phrase that summarises the paragraph, the slogan that summarises the key thought, the re-statement that reminds them of your theme. Open with it. End with it.

Agreements? Disagreements? Other thoughts?

Thursday, September 20, 2007

The Dream Job?

Thanks to Larry Star, CEO of Harrison and Star, for pointing me to the following excerpt from "Lear's Fool: Coping With Change Beyond Future Shock" by D. Verne Morland

POSITION DESCRIPTION

POSITION: Lear's Fool

JOB CODE: FOOL-Al

INCUMBENT: (Open)

REPORTS TO: Chief Executive Officer

ORGANISATION : Executive Office

LOCATION: Merlin's Parapet, Heath & Moor Road

BASIC FUNCTION: To disturb with glimpses of confounding truths that elude rational formulation. To herald the advent of cosmic shifts and to apprehend their significance. To challenge by jest and conundrum all that is sacred and all that the savants have proven to be true and immutable.

DIMENSIONS:

Budget: None (save for spangles and bells)

Number of employees supervised: None (God forbid!)

Revenue impacted: All (and then some)

NATURE AND SCOPE: The incumbent must not be a recognised expert in any field (they're dangerous). Demonstrable competency in many fields is required and the individuals "track record" should be good but must be not perfect. The incumbent may not have worked previously as a "serious consultant" unless he recants ... ...

PRINCIPAL ACCOUNTABILITIES:

Since for most of us the ability to think creatively about the future is inversely proportional to the weight of today's responsibilities, the incumbent should feel obligated only to:

  • Stir up controversy,
  • Respect no authority,
  • Resist pressures to engage in detailed analyses.

The incumbent must avoid verbs like study, analyse, plan, develop, refine and assure in favour of verbs like observe, identify, associate, explore, synthesise and stimulate. He should neither lead nor follow, but should stand outside the normal chain of command.

He must exploit his intellectual "carte blanche" to ask outrageous questions and to challenge basic assumptions. He must seek accuracy, not precision; originality, not consistency; insight, not completeness; and a focus on the future, not a preoccupation with the present.

REQUIREMENTS:

Candidate for this position must have:

  • Broad temporal horizons -- both past and future -- and a dominant future "zone orientation."
  • A "Renaissance Man" mentality involving some experience in many areas and the conviction that the Dark Ages must be left behind.
  • An ability to work comfortably with nebulous issues in strictly qualitative terms for as Harvard's John Steinbruner has noted: "If quantitative precision is demanded, it is gained in the current state of things, only by so reducing the scope of what is analysed that most of the important problems remain external to the analysis." This thought is echoed by Garber and Oliver who suggest that "once an issue has become a number, it's probably too late to deal with it."

The candidate must not have:

  • Strong preconceptions (e.g., national patriotism, religious parochialism or dogmatism, professional specialisation)
  • Inviolable allegiances (e.g., corporate, national, professional)

Intellectual independence is essential for as Pablo Picasso observed: "Every act of creation is first of all an act of destruction, because the new idea will destroy what a lot of people believe is essential to the survival of their intellectual world."

(Note: Misshapen head, if larger on right side, is OK.)

On a similar theme, Jeremy Raymond points out that the fool is the only one who dares to tell the king what is real, but must expect the odd cuff about the ears when he oversteps the mark (unwittingly). The courtier, on the other hand, is more commercial in that he protects his long term position, but may offer meaningless blandishments and dud advice to do this. His position in the court is secure because he doesn't rock the boat, but passes on information to others.

The Fool is of course the highly paid face to face challenger of senior officers and the courtier is the purveyor of information to large numbers of others with the tacit approval of those officers.

Interesting metaphors!

Since I think the funniest movie ever made was "The Court Jester," (1956, starring Danny Kaye) there are no prizes for guessing which role I think would be more fulfilling. All together now: "The vessel with the pestle has the pellet with the poison, but the chalice from the palace has the brew that is true." Run, don't walk, to rent, download or buy this film, especially if you have any 9-year-olds in the house (or can borrow one)!

Improving Mutual Understanding Between Business Schools and Business

On Friday, the 29th of September, (8 or 9 days from now) I will be giving a speech to 150 faculty members from European business schools on the topic given above.

It just occurred to me that if I blogged about it here, some of you may have some ideas and messages you want me to pass along.

Traditionally, there have been four ways business schools (and other professional schools) interact with business:

  1. Conducting research which helps us understand business better (i.e. an academic, intellectual purpose of contributing to knowledge.)

  2. Producing prepared students, ready for productive work lives

  3. Conducting research that is helpful to practicing business people

  4. Conducting executive education programs for mid-career and senior people

I'm not sure what absolute "grade" I would give to business schools around the world on each of these things, but I don't think it's high on any of them.

I'm least equipped to evaluate the academic scholarly contributions of business school faculty -- I was never a good academic even when I was a business school student. And anyway, that first purpose is not what I've been asked to talk about (even though many professors would consider it their primary purpose and obligation.)

What about producing prepared students ready for business or professional life? As we have discussed here, I don't think many schools do a wonderful job with helping students develop the social, psychological, interpersonal, political and emotional skills to succeed in life. Business schools don't; law schools don't; PR degree-programs don't; education in general doesn't.

I did note in the Wall Street Journal special Report today (Wednesday September 20) that some business schools like Michigan and Dartmouth Iin the US) and ESADE (in Europe) are rated very highly in developing (or screening for) students who are willing team players without the pomposity that graduates of some other schools have. Anyone want to comment on what those schools are doing well?

I would not give business school faculty at large a particularly high score on producing useful business research. First, it should be noted that few of the key managerial ideas of past decades (TQM, Six-sigma, business process re-engineering, etc) actually originated with faculty research. Get the impression that most "BIG" ideas and big thinking come from consultants and business itself. Or am I being unfair?

I have written before that I am nervous about businesses using business schools for executive education. I think business schools can do a wonderful job at teaching analytics and things of the mind, but are less well equipped to teach managing (ie dealing with real live human beings.)

So what would I do to improve all this, even a little?

Here are a few initial opinions:

  1. Build on strengths not weaknesses -- most graduates of business schools (at least in the US and UK) go into consulting, investment banking and other advisory businesses (PR, accounting, etc.) Very few graduates really go to work for "regular" companies. Maybe business schools should admit to themselves that they are training consultants, not managers.

  2. Business schools like everyone else should spend more time listening to their customers -- if they can ever figure out who the faculty really want to serve. Other academics? Recruiters? Students Its very unclear.

  3. Invite business people in to give lectures and seminars not to the students but to the faculty

  4. Require that all faculty do a consulting job for a local business (NOT executive education) and have the client come back and report to all the students and the rest of the faculty how helpful the professor was

  5. Make all business school academics run their own business, and report annually to the rest of the faculty how well it is going

  6. Find ways to screen students (and faculty?) for character, not intelligence

  7. Focus more on designing educational experiences (not content) that help students develop skills through guided practice (how to function in teams, etc.)

  8. Stop trying to do a little bit of everything: require that each business school have a strategy, a target niche and a differentiation. Working to build this in competition with other schools will help faculty understand organisations much better.

  9. Set publicly announced targets for the school's strategy and appoint an external monitoring board (with high visibility and embarrassment.) Introduce accountability into faculty members' lives.

So, those are some of the ideas I plan to throw out.

What would be some of your ideas of things business schools could do to improve their mutual understanding with business?

Wednesday, September 19, 2007

360-degree Feedback Programs

Michelle Golden, whose own blog is always worth reading, writes in to ask about 360-degree reviews and upwards evaluations, especially in light of what she perceives to be a much needed shift from a labor force ("asset") mentality to a knowledge-worker mentality. She writes:

Personally, I find them to be a very effective tool when executed properly (which I believe I do and have done for small firms up to a Big 4) though I see them poorly executed sometimes with what can be morale-damaging consequences.

In a well-done 360, I appreciate the contrast that comes to light between the subject's views of him/herself, their managers' perspective, their peers' perspective and their direct reports' perspective. And sometimes, the clients' perspective.

Interestingly, but not surprisingly, the subject usually underestimates or overestimates (significantly and consistently) how they perform across a broad variety of management and leadership areas such as decision-making, crisis management, teaching, learning, follow-up/accountability, delegation, etc. Done well, I've seen 360s build confidence around strengths and indicate a clear path of important areas for people to work on.

My questions for you are:

1) What do you think of 360 evaluations for those who manage others or will be doing so?

2) Do you know of or use other tools that help establish measures of management characteristics such as those just listed?

3) If used, do you think they should be private to the subject for personal development or as a tool the organisation uses to evaluate the effectiveness of their people?

Michelle, I find this question to be on a par with the question: "Should we ask our clients for feedback on how we are doing?" It astounds me that, even in some very elite firms, that battle is still being fought, yet it rages on, as does the debate over 360 for managers.

The simple truth is that, if you really want to be more effective at anything (sports, playing an instrument, romance, managing) you have to find a way to get constructive feedback, somehow. In life, the absence of complaints is not a dependable indicator of the absence of opportunities to improve.

So, it all starts with that big "IF" -- do you care enough to want to improve? If so, then we're just discussing mechanics. If you don't (and the vast majority of people do NOT want to do what it takes to improve unless they are absolutely compelled to) then no 360-degree program is going to prove effective: there are too many ways for such systems to be gamed, subordinates intimidated, feedback to be ignored and change made optional.

We have discussed getting feedback on this blog particularly in the discussion: Getting Good at Getting Feedback (16 people joined in on that one so far).

I also reported in another blog post on a manager who asked his people to evaluate him and promised to resign if he did not improve by 20% (Teaching Guts), which tells you something about my view on your third question, Michelle.

In my experience, the overwhelming majority of 360-degree programs fail to deliver the desired benefits of actual improved managerial performance for one (or all) of the following reasons:

a) There is actually a lack of understanding of what the manager's role is, so it's hard to provide feedback to and evaluate the manager if what he or she should be good at is ambiguous (or has a high level of deniability -- "That's not my job" "That shouldn't matter if I deliver", etc.)

b) Feedback is collected with highly structured, bureaucratic questionnaires which do not address the relevant behaviours and characteristics. They are too formal.

c) The feedback is delivered in such a way (eg without coaching) that the recipient is allowed to "misinterpret" what the information is really saying

d) The feedback is kept "confidential" so there is no "embarrassment factor" if the manager fails to improve. The system relies on best intentions -- the system is not a strict accountability system, which it needs to be if it is to work. Mangers exempt themselves from accountability when they can.

My quick summary is that a manager who really wanted to improve would not need the formality of a company-wide 360-program to get there, and managers who do not wish to be held accountable will not only not be helped by the system, they will ensure that it has no teeth!

There's more, Michelle, but let's see what you and others in the real world who have direct experience with 360-degree programs have to say.

Tuesday, September 18, 2007

Call for BLAWG Review Submissions

The Blawg Review showcases the best recent posts on law blogs (or "blawgs," as the lawyers like to call them) each week.

I will be hosting the review on September 27 as part of the Blawg Review's special September "back to school" series of academic hosts. I am letting you know in advance in order to encourage my readers to submit your own articles for the review.

If you aren't familiar with the Blawg Review, you can peruse this month's other "back to school" editions hosted by Workplace Prof Blog, the Institute of Global Security Law and Policy blog and Concurring Opinions.

I am a business and management type and NOT a lawyer, so I particularly encourage bloggers (and blawgers) to submit articles on the realities of work and professional life, the business of law, firm management, marketing, strategy, and career development.

I will do my best, but it will be hard for me, a non-lawyer, to assess and interpret purely legal submissions. I ask for prior forgiveness for any errors I make!

Blawg Review Submission Guidelines

  • Deadline for submission is 11:59 p.m. PST on Saturday, Sept 23
  • I greatly appreciate if you can send your submissions well before the deadline!
  • You are welcome and encouraged to submit blog posts by other people which you'd like to recommend as well as your own writing.
  • Articles on law practice management, marketing, business strategy and career development are especially welcome.
  • Click on this Blawg Review submission link to submit your article

With your support, I look forward to presenting readers here as well as the Blawg Review regulars with an excellent roundup of blog articles on the business of law and life as a lawyer.

Saturday, September 15, 2007

The Secret of a Great Marriage Is

To give your love without conditions, but to work every day to deserve the love you receive in return.

****

Your thoughts?

Thursday, September 13, 2007

Help Me With My Strategy Please

If past blogposts are any guide, you folks seem to enjoy giving me advice as much as I like giving it to you, so now it's your turn again.

In broad outline, here are some of my strategic challenges and choices that I'd like your input on.

I'm 34 years old, with a reputation and track record of consulting with, speaking to and writing about businesses (around the world) in the professional sector (law, accounting, investment banking, executive search, IT services, real estate, consulting, etc.)  I don't plan to stop anytime soon, so (like everyone else) I need to think periodically about my choices for the future.

As time has gone by, a few trends have emerged in my business:

a) When I started, I think I was pretty much a pioneer in writing about professional businesses and there weren't many people with that as a consulting specialty.  Nowadays, there are many consultants focusing in this area.

b) On the other hand, interest in my work spreads to new industries with every passing year, and a higher and higher portion of most economies are becoming made up of knowledge-intensive businesses.  The world is moving toward my specialty, and it's tempting to start writing about business in general.  But I'm concerned about losing my reputation as a specialist.

c) As I have tried to make an impact on the world with my thoughts, I find that there are (broadly) two groups in my audience.  The bigger group is made up of relatively younger people, or those outside the power structure (staff people, other consultants, small firms and solo operators like me).  This group tends to enjoy my emphasis on core principles and staying true to dreams and ambitions.

d) The second group is made up of top officers in top firms, working at the frontiers of their business, who seem to appreciate me being provocative, challenging the traditional ways professional businesses are run.  (Of course, there are often people in these positions who don't like being challenged that way!)

e) I'm interested in working with and serving both groups but don't want to get too schizophrenic.  Both in content and marketing, the audiences are different.  The first audience reads blogs, and writing for them allows me to feel that I'm having an impact by interacting with tomorrow's leaders.

f) The second audience (top officers in top firms, working at the frontier) is harder to reach, because busy leaders tend not to read articles, blogs, or books.  I may also need a different "positioning" for that audience, because a reputation for only pointing out what's wrong (or could be better) isn't always considered completely helpful.  Senior people also like to believe that I am, in some sense "on their side" -- trying to help, and not too much on the side of the revolutionaries trying to overthrow the power structure.  I like to think I present a lot of affirmative and constructive advice, but I do have a bit of a reputation as the type of consultant, speaker and writer who talks about the elephant in the room that no-one else wants to talk about.  (I know, I know, I wrote about how to do this with charm and style in my article The Trusted Advisor.  But it isn't always easy to challenge and be seen as constructive).

g) My choices are not really driven by economics, but the desire to make a contribution and receive the recognition and strokes that come from having made such a contribution.  However, the economics of serving the two audiences are very different.  If I serve the first audience and want to make money at it, it will probably mean selling ebooks, CDs and videos.  (I think there's a demand for that).  If I serve the second audience, it means generating and emphasising new thoughts in new articles, and deriving an income from high-level face-to-face consulting.  So far, I've been able to do both, and be accepted as doing both, but I don't know whether that will continue to be a good model (or even viable) moving forward.

Obviously, I haven't given you enough information, but hopefully we can have some fun -- and I can get some free advice.  Here are some (sincere) questions:

Should I continue to try and be a "professional business specialist" or write about general business issues?  This might be a question of writing style and language more than anything else, but it affects my "positioning".

What can I do to best serve the first audience of other consultants, staff people, younger people and small firms?  If I wanted to, what would be the best way to "monetise" my services to that audience?

If I want to keep serving the second, top officer audience, how do I carry on being challenging and provocative without being one more person pointing out what's wrong with the established structure?  Is it possible to pull off the high-wire act of being both a provocateur and a wise counsellor?  Should I continue to try that?

Wednesday, September 12, 2007

A Career Opportuntity for Someone

I'm probably not going to do this ever again, but I'm going to post details about a job opening here. A respected and close friend runs a small but very successful strategy consulting firm, and they are in the market for a Vice President. This is a special favour for my friend, who is one of the good guys who understands true professionalism. Here's the description:

The Beacon Group is a strategy consulting firm focused on supporting a select group of Fortune 500 clients as they build strategies and tactics to win in their marketplaces. Based in Portsmouth, NH, we are a young, dynamic firm growing quickly with opportunities for new employees to work in a fast-paced, entrepreneurial environment. We offer an exciting and lucrative opportunity to excel through a career in management consulting. A Beacon Group Vice President must be equal parts consultant, leader, and strategic thinker. The following is the job description for Beacon Vice Presidents:

  • To build and maintain an individual consulting practice that is consistent with The Beacon Group's vision, goals and growth objectives
  • To contribute to building long-term relationships and developing new business with existing clients
  • To create engagement relationships with new clients
  • To commit to the professional development of himself/herself and others
  • To serve as a senior leader in the office

Top Vice Presidents who have demonstrated outstanding capabilities and a strong commitment to Beacon may earn promotion to Senior Vice President. At 6 month intervals from the Vice President's hire date, a formal review is given to assess progress and future career opportunities with the firm. Both qualitative and quantitative metrics are used to evaluate performance and recommend potential growth opportunities. Financial rewards increase substantially with outstanding accomplishment at the firm.

A Vice President will have the following responsibilities:

  • Identify prospective business with existing clients or new clients
  • Determine the scope and nature of potential engagements
  • Write successful proposals
  • Manage the contracting process with our client
  • Oversee the delivery of engagement work
  • Supervise project teams
  • Sell and deliver multiple engagements simultaneously
  • Provide insightful analysis of engagements
  • Meet revenue objectives
  • Serve as mentor to more junior firm members
  • Internally support and further the firm's cultural, ethical and mission objectives

The candidate should have at least 8 years of professional experience, preferably with exposure to management consulting. He/she should hold a BS/BA and ideally an MBA from a leading business school. He/she will have strong analytical skills, demonstrated sales experience in a professional environment and have the ability to provide Senior-level written and oral communication (both in individual and group settings). We also welcome candidates with foreign language capabilities.

My friend says they are specifically interested in healthcare and financial services consultants who are successful at business development. They will have to be located in Portsmouth and need to be comfortable in a small firm that is a true meritocracy. Compensation is "highly competitive."

How to apply? Send a resume to jobs@tbg-online.com or rchristie@tbg-online.com

Monday, September 10, 2007

Lessons in True Professionalism

Hyokon Zhiang writes:

The Korean version of True Professionalism by Richard Wood (that I and Innomove colleagues have worked on) has just been published. The article has both aspects like a father who strictly persuades us of the meaning and the value of doing things right, and one like a mother at the same time who warmly encourages hesitant us saying that doing things right is ultimately beneficial for ourselves. I strongly recommend this article to people who think themselves as professionals, or want to be professional.

Personally, the professionalism side of Richard's advice was the most influential on me -- more than strategy, marketing, recruiting, or any other more "skills" related topics. That's why I translated True Professionalism to begin with. And I believe that there must be other people like that.

I am interested to hear people's experiences about professionalism. For example,

  • How do you have the resolve to do what is the right thing to do vs. what is immediately profitable.
  • Taking the high road. In some moments the high road is obvious but hard to give up the temptation to pursue short-term gain. Sometimes you want to follow the high road but it is not obvious which route that is.
  • Sometimes you feel uncomfortable about your firm's or colleagues' behaviour, and sometimes you feel disappointed about yourself in going along
  • Some experiences give you life-changing lessons.

So, let’s pass on some advice and experiences, as requested. What have you learned about what it means to be a true professional? How have you learned to sustain professional behaviour in spite of the world’s temptations?

Think of Work -- new careers videocast & audiocast

In Think of Work, the 22nd episode in this series, we are going to examine the issue of professional engagement and excitement. All too often professionals are doing tolerable work for tolerable people or worse, work that they dislike for people they don't care about. The impact of this, not only on a personal level but in the marketplace, is staggering. We will look at ways to change this in your professional life.

Audio Timeline

00:40 -- Introduction
01:08 -- A survey on professional excitement: Does your profession excite you?
03:25 -- A survey on professional excitement: Do your clients excite you?
06:04 -- The importance of choosing work and clients that actually interest you
09:08 -- Conclusion

You can download Think of Work or sign up to receive new videos automatically with iTunes or other video players. (Click here for step-by-step instructions on how to subscribe.) My seminars are always available for download at no cost.

Saturday, September 8, 2007

The Psychology of Waiting Lines

I just received an email suggesting I blog about waiting times in business. I suspect the author of the email knows about my article The Psychology of Waiting Lines, written more than 10 years ago. The topic here is not how to make the waiting time shorter, but how to make it more acceptable or palatable to the person waiting.

In spite of its age, I still get lots of calls from reporters who want to do stories on this, and the article is among my most frequently cited (for those who are counting). This is a great opportunity to get you all involved. I'll give you the highlights of what I said back then, and you can tell me what I missed or should add.

I had eight propositions about how people experience waiting and what businesses could do to make a wait feel less onorous.

1) Occupied Time Feels Shorter Than Unoccupied Time.

In various restaurants, it is common practice to hand out menus for customers to peruse while waiting in line. Apart from shortening the perception of time, this practice has the added benefit of shortening the service time, since customers will be ready to order once they are seated, and will not tie up table space making up their minds.

2) People Want to Get Started.

One's "anxiety" level is much higher while waiting to be served than it is while being served, even though the latter wait may be longer. There is a fear of "being forgotten". (How many times has the reader gone back to a maitre d' to check that his or her name is still on the list?). Many restaurant owners instruct their service staff to pass by the table as soon as the customers are seated to say "I'll be with you as soon as I can, after I've looked after that table over there". In essence, the signal is being sent: "We have acknowledged your presence".

3) Anxiety Makes Waits Seem Longer.

Nearly everyone has had the experience of choosing a line at the supermarket or airport, and stood there worrying that he had, indeed, chosen the wrong line. As one stands there trying to decide whether to move, the anxiety level increases and the wait becomes intolerable. This situation is covered by what is known as Erma Bombeck's Law: "The other line always moves faster"

4) Uncertain Waits Are Longer than Known, Finite Waits

Clients who arrive early for an appointment will sit contentedly until the scheduled time, even if this is a significant amount of time in an absolute sense (say, thirty minutes). However, once the appointment time is passed, even a short wait of, say, ten minutes, grows increasingly annoying. The wait until the appointed time is finite; waiting beyond the point has no knowable limit.

5) Unexplained Waits Are Longer than Explained Waits

On a cold and snowy morning, when I telephone for a taxi, I begin with the expectation that my wait will be longer than on a clear, summer day. Accordingly, I wait with a great deal more patience because I understand the causes for the delay. Similarly, if a doctor's receptionist informs me that an emergency has taken place, I can wait with greater equanimity that if I do not know what is going on. Airline pilots understand this principle well; on-board announcements are filled with references to tardy baggage handlers, fog over landing strips, safety checks, and air-traffic controllers' clearance instructions. The explanation given may or may not exculpate the service provider, but is it better than no explanation at all.

6) Unfair Waits Are Longer than Equitable Waits

In many waiting situations, there is no visible order to the waiting line. In situations such as waiting for a subway train, the level of anxiety demonstrated is high, and the group waiting is less a queue than a mob. Instead of being able to relax, each individual remains in a state of nervousness about whether their priority in the line is being preserved. As already noted, agitated waits seem longer than relaxed waits. It is for this reason that many service facilities have a system of taking a number, whereby each customer is issued a number and served in strict numerical order. In some facilities, the number currently being served is prominently displayed so that customers can estimate the expected waiting times.

7) The More Valuable the Service, the Longer the Customer Will Wait

That perceived value affects tolerance or waits can be demonstrated by our common experience in restaurants -- we will accept a much longer waiting time at a haute cuisine facility than at a "greasy spoon." In universities, there is an old rule of thumb that if the teacher is delayed, "You wait ten minutes for an assistant professor, fifteen minutes for an associate professor, and twenty minutes for a full professor." This illustrates well the principle that tolerance for waits depends upon perceived value of service -- perhaps with the emphasis on the perception.

8) Solo Waits Feel Longer than Group Waits

One of the remarkable syndromes to observe in waiting lines is to see individuals sitting or standing next to each other without talking or otherwise interacting until an announcement of a delay is made. Then the individuals suddenly turn to each other to express their exasperation, wonder collectively what is happening, and console each other. What this illustrates is that there is some form of comfort in group waiting rather than waiting alone.

****

So, those were some of the principles in my original article. (Here's the link again to the full piece, The Psychology of Waiting Lines.)

Now comes your challenge to help this discussion along: what "cool" approaches have you seen businesses use to apply these or other principles and make us, the customers, tolerate waits or even turn the wait to the business' advantage?

Who's doing clever things with managing waiting lines (or queues, as my Australian family calls them)?

Friday, September 7, 2007

What reporters hate about PR people

I just received a copy (thanks Steve Rubell) of a speech given by Tommy Fernandez, the journalist who covered the legal beat at Crain's New York Business, at the July meeting of Law Firm Media Professionals

Taking no prisoners, Fernandez aims fairly and squarely at his audience of the Public Relations professionals who work for law firms -- those who are always trying to get his attention and press coverage for their firms.

Here are his "reasons why reporters hate you"

There are too damned many of you. (He gets more than 100 calls involving law firm pitches per day. Do the math.)

It's getting nearly impossible to tell your pitches apart. There is no trend you can imagine that I have heard several times today.

You don't listen (or keep promises about when you're going to get back with a quote or supporting evidence for a story.)

You treat reporters like your social worker ("you've got to help me out of this situation".) I am not here to help you. I am not your social case worker. I am not here to protect your job, make you feel good or help your clients. The sooner you accept that reality, the better of you'll be.

You treat reporters like a social trophy ("Come to lunch and meet our top execeutives and discuss the latest developments in document flow management software." "What do you mean you don't want to spend three hours with our management committee to educate us on ... .")

Your clients are dumb-asses and you don't tell us: "Is that really the right question to be asking? Is this really the right story to be writing? I'll tell you a story you should be working on, although it won't really be a story until the winter, but that's beyond your deadline, isn't it?"

Reporters hate you (PR) because you act like used car salesmen. "A study in nausea" he calls it. -- Drop your fantasy. There is no spiel, no gimmick you can use to compel me to abandon my common sense. The attitude of reaching (PR) goals is actually one of the easiest ways you can shoot yourself in the foot.

There's more, lot's more, but you get the idea. Not surprisingly, this was Mr. Fernandez' farewell speech -- he's moving on to cover other journalistic beats.

All of which goes to show. What exactly? That PR people don't understand journalists?

You don't have to be in PR or the law to get a lot out of Mr. Fernadez' rant.

The real lesson is that all of us get so wrapped up in what we want FROM the other person that we fail to understand what would make them want to give it to us.

It's beneficial, if painful, to have the other side tell us, in uncertain terms, what it has been like working with us!

Thursday, September 6, 2007

Screening for Character

I'm of the belief that the overwhelming majority of recruiting interviewing is a complete waste of time. It's not science and almost nobody has the practiced craft or art to be good at it. We like to pretend that we can find out important things in a one-hour interview, but we really can't.

Everyone's heard the phrase "Hire for attitude and train for skill" and I believe it fully. In fact, I'd go further and say that once you have checked out credentials and qualifications, character, not just attitude, explains the vast majority of someone's long-term performance and whether or not they will fit into your company.

And if the goal of an interview is to judge someone's attitudes, personality and / or character then its going to take a LOT more training than most interviewers are given to determine those things. I don't know too many people, even with extensive training, who could get a smart person to reveal his or her true character in such a format.

The problem is, if it isn't interviews, what other recruiting processes could you use that would actually screen for the characteristics you need?

The best firms, in my view find a way to ask the people who already know the candidates to pass judgement. For examples, when hiring on campus, smart recruiters ask faculty members to give them the real low-down truth about the different students. Or they ask this year's hires to tell them about the students in the year below them or that they met in other on-campus activities. It's usually well-known on campus which individuals have personality, ambition, integrity. Ask three or four faculty or fellow students and their lists will be close to identical -- they have been working with them in close quarters for a year or more and their judgments will be accurate.

But what if you don't have access to these "insider" sources that can tell you the truth about candidate's attitudes, personalities, character?

I'm convinced that an important part of the answer lies in designing processes where people reveal (consciously or unconsciously) their true colours.

In my article First Among Equals, I gave a couple of examples of this:

Two firms in my experience were creative about their interviewing process. The first, a law firm asked all candidates at their final interview to say which had been their favourite course in law school. They then called in a secretary and (with a half-hour to think about it) asked the candidate to explain the content of the course to the secretary. The secretary, in essence, had the final say on whether the person was hired. It was not enough, this firm believed, to know your stuff. Before you were hired, you had to demonstrate the ability to explain it to an intelligent layperson.

The second firm, of accountants, brought all their final candidates together, and put them in a room with a two-way mirror. The candidates were told they would be observed, and were asked to do a joint exercise (equivalent to building a house out of playing cards). The resulting behaviour was fascinating to watch. Thinking that they were suppose to be demonstrating leadership, many candidates competed to "take charge" of their group. In fact, the accounting firm was looking for people who felt comfortable being part of a team without the ego need to be its leader, and made offers only to those who did not try to dominate.

I'd be interested in hearing about other creative ways that organisations determine whether potential recruits really have desired character traits. How do you really tell if someone is good with people? Is a team player? Is honourable, has integrity and is trustworthy? Is the type of person who can maintain their composure in a crisis? Has the "good kind"of ambition and determination without too much of the "bad kind?"

There's got to be something better than an interview to uncover the truth about these important things.

Wednesday, September 5, 2007

What's a Senior Partner For?

I received an email enquiry as follows:

Have you commented in your writings on the value of a firm having both a senior partner and managing partner -- akin to the corporate equivalent of a chairman and CEO -- or can you direct me to some recommended material?

The first thing to note is that the use of the two terms senior partner and managing partner is not a common phenomenon worldwide. It's normal in the UK and Europe, but very rare in Australia, which tends to combine the roles into one. "Senior partner" is not a term you'll hear used much in Australia.

I haven't written about this topic directly, although I wrote an article on governance in Managing the Professional Service Firm which included these thoughts:

Like a nation state, these (governance) elements can be divided into three groups. The firm's board represents the legislative branch whose duty it is to approve (or disapprove) the policies under which the polity will operate. The managing partner, together with the executive committee and the business manager, form the executive branch. Finally, the compensation committee represents the judiciary.

The board of partners corresponds closely to the corporate model of a board of directors representing the interests of the "shareholders" (in this case, partners). Like a corporate board, a primary function of this body is to oversee and monitor the activities of the executive (the managing partner) to ensure that the shareholders' interests are being served.

Many firms have observed that where the firm's highest committee serves both a policy and executive role, the day-to-day minutiae tend to dominate the committee's deliberations and real policy debates are neglected. Accordingly, most firms have found it wise to separate the policy and executive functions. This same conclusion is generated by a "division of powers" consideration. By separating the policy and executive functions, the firm avoids having too much power located in one body.

The senior partner or chairman can play the policy / legislative functions (at least in the sense of the firm's core constitution) or its judiciary functions -- setting pay for those in high positions, or serving as a court of appeals for those who wish to protest an executive decision.

The senior partner, as chairman of a board of partners, could exercise the same policy formation and management oversight roles that a chairman in a public company is suppose to fulfill. I say "supposed" because we all know that there is a lot of charades and facades in corporate governance. In the publicly-held corporate world, few boards really exercise much oversight -- governments have had to legislate (i.e. Sarbanes-Oxley) to get them to do some basics. Most corporate boards have been "captured" by management, and do not really exercise an independent function.

All of which is to say that it would be dangerous to assume that the corporate model or terminology is a positive metaphor. It may be exactly the model you want to stay away from!

However, it does help us outline a choice that must be made about the senior partner role. In corporate governance theory, the chairman plays an oversight role towards the CEO / managing partner, holding the managing partner "accountable" in the same way that the managing partner holds top executives within the organisation accountable for their targets and performance.

This is actually a very intriguing model, particularly in a partnership where the chairman of the board of partners is supposed to represent the shareholder / partners (as, in theory, the corporate chairman is supposed to represent the corporate shareholders.)

It's a good idea, but is it achievable and desirable in your firm? Is your CEO / managing partner really prepared to be held accountable? Especially when he or she spends his or her year holding everybody else accountable? It's my experience that top people will say they want to be held accountable. But they don't really. They will agree to the forms of accountability being put in place, but will neuter it when it actually tries to exercise any power.

There's a completely different way of looking at all this, which is actually much more likely to work. That is to make one person (the senior partner) the external face and the other (the managing partner) the internal face of the organisation.

In this (quite common) approach, the senior partner represents the firm to the marketplace and other external constituencies (governments, media, communities, media) while the managing partner focuses on actually managing the internal constituencies -- partners, junior professionals, other employees.

While this division of labours makes a lot of sense, it's worth pointing out that the skills (and orientation) involved are quite distinct. As a result, the (equally common) policy of automatically promoting the managing partner to senior partner at the end of the managing term is probably not a sensible idea.

Anyone else out there have a view on the right division of responsibilities between a senior partner and a managing partner?

Saturday, September 1, 2007

Choosing a Doctoral Thesis

Since people know that I used to be a university student, and that I have a specialty field (professional businesses) I get quite a few emails and letters from doctoral students asking me to suggest thesis topics.

They want to know what CEOs or managing partners would find interesting, what the researchable and challenging issues are.

My reply always surprises them.

I point out that the only purpose of thesis is to get your doctorate degree approved. By very definition, your thesis will be the worst piece of research you will ever do.

Furthermore, no-one in the real world ever pays attention to a doctoral thesis, so you shouldn't even try to design it with their interests in mind.

What academics care about and what real-world people care about are two different things, and the ONLY people who can graduate you and let you get on with your life are your thesis committee -- your professors.

The job of a doctoral student is to forget what the world finds interesting and to focus with a laser-like beam on what the thesis committee thinks is interesting and worthwhile. If you're getting a doctorate, you're in academia and you MUST play the academic game.

And the whole game is won or lost at the thesis proposal stage. Here's where you have to deploy your sophisticated negotiating skills.

You have to make sure that what your professors think would be a worthwhile and interesting piece of research is actually doable. So, you have to bargain (subtly, deferentially and with an appropraite amount of grovelling) until you get a contract that says "If I do these things as the research, then, no matter what I find, you'll sign the completed thesis, right?"

Then you fulfil your contract, graduate and only then begin to care about what the real world finds interesting and would consider helpful research (if you still want to do any after your first taste of it.)

Good luck!

Friday, August 31, 2007

Goodbye winter

I thought people were supposed to take vacations in August? Yet look below at all those who stayed around to join the fun during this past month.

(Don't tell me they were using blackberries at the beach!)

Ta very much!

Yee're greet, the lot of ye!

commentors

Stephanie West Allen, Antoine Henry De Frahan, Mark Baker, Deepa Balaji, Martin Bamford, Eric Boehme, Leo J. Bottary, Bob Brown, Bruce, Duncan Bucknell, James Bullock, Tim Burrows, Shawn Callahan, Jimmy Campbell, Charles, James Cherkoff, Todor Christov, John Clough, Colin, Tom Collins, Petri Darby, Bob Daugherty, Mike DeWitt, Dean, Stephen Downes, Francis M. Egenias, Eric, Raissa Evans, Steve Farber, Anna Farmery, Doug Fletcher, David Foster, Allan Freeman, Jordan Furlong, Michelle Golden, Brooks Gould, Mark Gould, Lisa Guinn, Jim Hayward, Ken Hedberg, Joseph Heyison, Dennis Howlett, David Jacobson, Eric C Jaffe, Jaylpea, Jennifer, David Koopmans, David Law, Ed Lee, Bruce Lewin, Karen Love, Tom Lowe, Ludwig, Andrew Lumsden, Tim MMF, Peter Macmillan, Greg Magnus, Stephen Marshall, Steve Matthews, Lex McCafferty, Jim McGee, Jeff Merrifield, Ann Michael, Cristian Mitreanu, Johnnie Moore, Matt Moore, Mike Myatt, Liz Nash, Steve Pearce, Bill Peper, John Eric Pollabauer, Gregory Price, RJON, Jeff Risley, Rolf Van Der Meer, Bill S, Kosol S., Shuchetana, Carl A. Singer, Brijinder Singh, Andrew Smith, Prashant Subhedar, Nut Suwapiromchot, Charles Tippett, Eric Tong, Fiona Torrance, Coert Visser, Dan W,Curt Wehrley, Ian Welsh, Fred Wiersma, Mott Williamson, Darren Woolley, Hyokon Zhiang

trackbacks

BrainBasedBusiness
Bryan C Fleming
Business of Marketing and Branding
Client Service Insights (CSI)
Consumerism Commentary
CPA TRENDLINES
Creating a Better Life
Golden Practices
legal sanity
Manage To Change
Musings from Strategic Leverage Partners
Roman's miles
Searchlight Crusade
Seeds of Growth
The Business Innovation Insider
The Business of America is Business

Marketing in a One-Off Industry

Tim Burrows, from GHD in Australia, has submitted the following question for us to discuss. Here's Tim:

Across the spectrum of industries, there is a wide variety of client needs, ranging from repetitive and regular advice through to one-off projects. In the latter case, some of these clients you may never serve again. How do you market yourself if you are in a one-off industry?

I'm not arguing that word of mouth referrals are not useful, and that's still where you start to build a reputation and a lead flow. But does the emphasis need to change if you are mainly or mostly working on one-off jobs? Are there other activities that would be useful in this situation that would not be that useful in the case of "repeat business clients"?

I would be interested to see what kind of responses you get from the rapidly growing community that is participating in the discussion on this blog.

OK, Tim. You clearly want the views of others as well as me, so I'll try and keep my views concise.

The essence of being in a one-off industry is that you have to have to repeatedly impress a stranger -- quickly -- with your capabilities. You're always meeting new people, and need to get them down their buying cycle fast.

I still believe that the best tactics for attracting new clients (even or especially) in a one-off industry are those I wrote about in Managing the Professional Service Firm:

a) Give lots of speeches,

b) Keep up a regular stream of little articles

c) Put on seminars (on-line) and

d) Do surveys and other data-gathering research that can position you as the source of "Facts no one else has got" -- even if those facts are just opinion surveys among your target audience asking them about current trends.

The surveys provide the regular, fresh content for the speeches, article-writing and seminars.

Those were my opinions, 10 years ago, and so we have to add in everything we've learned about online marketing (see my recent article Adventures in Modern Marketing), so you probably especailly need, in a one-off business, a website -- with lots of content -- where people you don't know (or who don't know you) can find you easily and be easily impressed with what you have to offer. (The second part is harder)

****

So, that's my contribution to get us started. Others? How do you market in a one-off business? What do you do DIFFERENTLY than you do in a "repeat transaction" or "ongoing relationship" world?

Thursday, August 30, 2007

The Sad Life of the Staff Person

In Are Law Firms Manageable? (Also published as "The Trouble with Lawyers") I described a common culture where individual partners did not really want to be teamplayers, working for the "greater good" of the firm. Instead, they focused on their own practice or that of their own small group.

(Lawyers are not unique in having this individualistic, lone-wolf culture, as we have frequently seen in this blog.)

However, as a result of this culture I get lots of emails from people in firmwide staff support roles -- like marketing, HR, IT -- who ask me "How can I perform my role if the partners won't cooperate? How do I get individualistic partners to work for the common good and invest time or resources in HR, IT, marketing? How can I do my job if the partners won't let me?"

(By the way, this is not just a problem of partnerships. The dilemma exists wherever there is an internal corporate shared services group. I've worked a lot with those people, too.)

My answer is always the same: Forget the common good. As a lowly, subordinate staff person it's not your place to try and convince people who are effectively your superiors to be better team players. If top management has failed in that, you're not likely to pull it off.

Instead, my advice is to start small and go for an early success. Find a single person, partner or small operating group who WANTS your help. Help them with what they want to accomplish as an individual or small group. Prove that you can help.

You're not looking for where you can make your biggest impact, but where you can make your quickest impact. If an powerful individual says "I worked with this staff person and they really helped me" then you'll have your advocate to help get you used by others in the future. You will slowly build influence and power.

When many of them are using you, then you will be well-known enough and influential enough to drive for common approaches and collective action.

So, that's my initial advice for a staff person trying to have an impact in an individualistic culture. Anyone else got suggestions?

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

What Should My Comment Policy Say?

I greatly appreciate the contributions of the many readers who take the time to comment on this blog.

It has been suggested that I should offer some general comment guidelines in order to set expectations for new readers and to assure a consistently positive experience for ongoing readers of this site.

However, I don't want to do this alone. You're part of this, too. So, I've drafted some comment guidelines here, and I'd like your reactions. What should I add, delete, modify?

When we're done, I'll post the finished guidelines on the blog.

Humour is always welcome on the blog, but please take this topic seriously.

COMMENT GUIDELINES

Please recognise that the comments on the blog are part of a conversation between real people. We interact here with professionalism and courtesy.

Also please recognise that this is a conversation between and among all of us, not just between you and me. Try to address your comments to the broader community.

For the sake of your own privacy and that of others, please do not post phone numbers or email addresses in the body of your comment -- you cannot assume the good intentions of everyone who reads them.

Please do not post raw URLs -- which may be long and skew the page or the comment sidebar -- but make the URL an actual HTML link. (Just highlight the term you want to hotlink and then click on the "link" icon in the comment editor to add the URL.)

My blog is not the place to promote your services or products to readers.

I will edit/delete spam comments and trackbacks, duplicate comments, unsupported accusations, personal attacks of any kind, terms offensive to groups when used in a pejorative manner, or comments that explicitly promote a product or service.

In addition, I reserve the right to edit/delete comments that are some combination of vulgar, vile, cruel, without redeeming qualities, and an embarrassment to the site.

If you have left a valid email address, I will let you know by email if I edit or delete your comment. If you prefer to keep your email address private, and I support your right to do so, then I will edit your comment without notice.

As an absolute last resort, I will ban repeat or particularly egregious offenders.

In short: please behave here as you would in any other public space surrounded by your family or professional peers, and all should be well.

Thank you for your understanding and support in making the discussions on this blog a productive and enjoyable experience for our entire community.

*****

So, what do you think? What Should I add, delete, modify?

Tuesday, August 28, 2007

What My Boss Could Do To Convince Us

a) That he / she really wants to make this place customer-centric

b) That he / she really cares about the long term

c) That he / she really wants us to be team players

*******

Suggestions?

Octoberspiel

MACONOMY will be conducting a conference in Copenhagen on People and Profitability: A Time for Growth on October 5 and 6. I will be a speaker on the first day.

Monday, August 27, 2007

Getting Hired by New Clients -- new client videocast & audiocast

The 21st episode of this series, Getting Hired by New Clients, will focus on the challenges involved in building a trustworthy reputation and the importance of demonstrating rather than asserting your capabilities. As you will see, as with any relationship, it is up to you to go first.

Audio Timeline

00:39 -- Introduction
01:03 -- A personal account of the power of recommendations and reputation
03:37 -- The cycle of mutual recriminations the client/provider relationship
05:31 -- How to "go first" as a provider
12:11 -- Demonstrate, don't assert
14:22 -- Conclusion

You can download Getting Hired by New Clients or sign up to receive new videos automatically with iTunes or other video players. (Click here for step-by-step instructions on how to subscribe.) My seminars are always available for download at no cost.

Sunday, August 26, 2007

You Gotta Go First

In my post about The Best Advice I Ever Received a wonderful lesson was contributed by Jeff Risley:

"Just remember, wherever you go, there you are."

In other words, if you think change is needed in a situation, think about changing yourself first before changing everything around you.

I particularly like that lesson. In fact, I'm struggling to write an article with that theme, aimed at CEOs and other top executives who always want their people to change but overlook the fact that they have to go first.

If you have a story or an insight on that theme that I can use in the article, comment here or drop me an email (richard@vistageconsulting.com.au).

Wasn't it Gandhi who said something like "You must become the change you wish to see"?

Saturday, August 25, 2007

Corporate Strategy and Personal Profiles

I was recently facilitating a strategy discussion with a company in an industry that has a long tradition of hiring, celebrating and rewarding individualistic solo operators. In spite of that tradition, the company's leaders wanted to develop a company-wide reputation and strategy.

As we discussed the investments and initiatives necessary to pull this off, one of the "players" in the room asked: "Why would I want to do this. What's in it for me?"

(This is normal. The industry I was working with is only unusual in that people there actually say things like this out loud. In other industries and professions, they just think it all the time, without actually saying it!)

Anyway, as I worked to help the company -- and the individuals within it -- understand their choices, we came up with a categorisation scheme based on two dimensions.

The first dimension (or choice) is whether people actively want to be part of a team, with joint accountabilities, responsibilities, and rewards (team players), or whether, (as solo operators), they would prefer to be in situations where they can avoid being tied down, tied up or tied into working with other people, preferring to rise or fall or their own personal efforts.

I may have used biased language here, but the point is that people really do differ here as to how they want to live their lives. (Disclosure -- I admire the heck out of the true team players, and would bet on them to win, but prefer to be what I am -- a solo operator.)

The second dimension we explored was that some people have an appetite for high-investment strategies (invest a lot to get the chance to reap high rewards) while others are reluctant to invest that much, even in their own future. They prefer to focus on "winning today," letting tomorrow take care of itself.

Combining these two dimensions led us to analyse 4 kinds of preferences that individuals (and companies) have. The labels were developed in conjunction with "Linda." (Thanks.)

Type 1 is the solo operator who makes little investment in the future, but bets on the ability to catch fresh meat each and every day. Call this the Mountain Lion approach. "Pay me for what I kill today."

Type 2 is the individual who prefers to act in coordination, but doesn't like to invest too much. Call these people (collectively) the Wolf-Pack. "If we act together we can kill bigger animals, but it had better pay off soon or I'm joining another Pack!"

Type 3 is the individual who wants to act as a solo operators, not really enjoying collective action, but is interested in taking care of their future by investing resources to get somewhere new. We weren't sure what to call these people, but they remind me of Beavers building dams to provide a home for their family. (The reason I have difficulty coming up with the right species for this one might not only be that I'm a country boy, but also because this category is the one I think I'm in.)

Type 4 are individuals who want to be part of something bigger than they can accomplish alone, and have the patience, the ambition and the will to help the collective organisation invest in that future. I want to call this "The Human Race" since one of the rare things about Homo Sapiens that differentiates it (at least in scale) from other species is its ability to act collectively to build and develop. (It's called civilisation.)

However, Linda pointed out that Type 4 could also be a description of an Ant Community.

"Ant Community" doesn't sound very appealing as a self-image, does it? Yet it's what I and a million other business consultants and CEOs and political leaders are trying to get their people to do whenever there is talk about strategy -- join together for a common purpose and stretch for common achievement. Are we trying get people to be more fully human, or be like ants?

To many people, the OTHER types seem so attractive. Who wouldn't want to be a Mountain Lion and or part of a Wolf-Pack (so muscular, so strong, so energetic,) rather than an ant (or just a homo sapiens.) Why wouldn't you vote for that?

We had secret voting machines in the room which allowed people to remain anonymous, so I asked people which of these four preferences best described their own, personal desired way of behaving. (I took the vote before coming up with the animal labels.)

Guess what? All four groups were well represented. Only 10 to 20 percent in this particular company put themselves in the "I want to be part of something bigger than me that is working to build for the future." (I don't know if that's shockingly low to you, or matches your experience.)

What do you think the chances are of melding people that describe themselves that way into an institution that has a differentiated reputation?

I'm really interested in how misaligned the very concept of "strategy" can be for some companies with the type of people they attract, hire and retain. Firms and their leaders PRETEND and HOPE and SAY that they want to invest and build collectively, and everyone else pretends to go along as if that's what they want too.

But, when you look closely, that's not actually the truth about what the people in the company really want to do.

Can anyone help me make sense of all these thoughts? What do you think?

Friday, August 24, 2007

The Best Advice I Ever Received

Get over it. Let it go. Move on.

**********

What was the best advice you ever received?

Thursday, August 23, 2007

Two Entrepreneurs

I have just published two profiles of entrepreneurs who exemplify how disruptive and revolutionary a true commitment to client service and business principles can be.

In the first article, An Innovative Law Firm, 29-year-old Christopher Marston launches his own law firm, convincing all new hires (from a recent graduate to a 30-year veteran bank executive) to defer compensation until his experimental model pays off.

On his blog, Marston wrote: "Most attorneys I know are not happy. The opportunity to build a firm that can be a win for the attorneys by creating a great work environment and at the same time be a win for clients who are endlessly disappointed with law firm service and billable hours is what drives me to get up every day and do what I do. People who think Exemplar is about a pricing model have missed the point. Exemplar is about changing lives ... one by one ... until we're all done!" He plans to have 24 people in the firm by year's end.

(This article first appeared as the introduction to the inaugural issue of Innovaction, an online journal celebrating innovation in the practice of law published by the College of Law Practice Management.)

* * *

In the second article, An Entrepreneurial Journey, software services engineer Geoff Considine retraces his career, reflecting on how he built "Woodisms" into building his own successful firm. Geoff feels these are the most important guidelines that he has learned -- often inspired, he says, by my work:

  • Be worthy of trust.
  • Everyone knows that you are smart -- don't try to prove it.
  • You are there to help, not to be right.
  • Be a concierge -- if it needs doing, do it.
  • Develop services and products that are worth paying a premium price for.
  • Do business as if you were working with a good friend --

(An Entrepreneurial Journey was first published as a feature article at PSVillage.com)

If you would like to be emailed automatically when I add future full-length articles to the site (or know of anyone else that would benefit), I invite you (or them) to sign up for my (free) article email list.

Wednesday, August 22, 2007

Integrity Impugned

This happened ten years ago.

I had been hired to assist the executive committee of a major consulting firm to discuss their strategy. There were 8 or ten senior officers of the firm around the table, including the CEO, who was due to retire in 12 months.

As I was generating various options for them to consider, the CEO suddenly said to me (in front of everyone else): "You just want to see us change so you can get consulting fees."

I had no idea what to say, and said nothing. I was hugely offended. It's one thing to dislike my ideas, but to question my ethics? Impugn my integrity?

On the other hand, don't all clients and customers distrust the motives of all professional provides (and all other businesspeople?)

The air hung heavy and silent until one of the other executives picked up the conversation and moved on.

I carried on working with that firm, through the term of my contract, and no-one ever referred to the CEO's remarks again.

I have often thought about what I SHOULD have done or said.

What would you have done?

What are you going to say or do when someone accuses you of only being in it for yourself?

Saturday, August 18, 2007

Assessing the Risks of the Next Step

You'll read in lots of places that, in business, the right strategy is to "fail often, fail fast, fail cheap." That way, you learn, innovate, and develop.

It's good advice for an organisation, but not necessarily for an individual. While I like to be encouraging, urging people to stretch to fulfill their capabilities and dreams, the truth is that the world can be an unforgiving place, and you do have to choose your "next challenge" with care.

For example, if you are aiming for a big promotion, you had better make sure you want that responsibility before you try to move up. If it turns out not to work out well (for any reason), a company will most likely NOT put you back where you came from, but move you out. (It’s happened to me.)

Actually, the same is true when companies take on new client work and deals: take one on that runs into trouble, and you don't go back to the market reputation you had before, but to one with a big black mark. (That's happened to me, too.)

Be sure to think through what it means to move up in an organisation, because it is hard to go back. The higher you climb, the more responsibilities you get that you simply didn't know existed when you were a naive junior. With promotion comes incredible responsibility and narrow career choices.

Life doesn't get any easier as you move up the ladder. All you ever do as you progress is trade one set of problems for another, hopefully higher class, set of problems. One set of stresses for another.

Am I counselling anyone to not be ambitious? No, what I'm saying is that you don't accept or pursue "promotions" or "challenges" "or "glamorous client assignments" just because they are there. They've got to be the right ones for you.

You've got to go through life recognising that, if you fail at new challenges, you'll have rebuilding to do. You have to weigh both the benefits of succeeding and the risks of failing before you decide.

As you progress, life does get more interesting, but it doesn't get easier.

Friday, August 17, 2007

The Trusted Brain Surgeon Advisor

Duncan Bucknell, who is a "lawyer, patent attorney and intellectual property strategy consultant" -- and a regular participant in these discussions -- writes in to ask:

To use an analogy I picked up from you, it seems to me that the trusted adviser is the local doctor -- the person you first turn to for assistance.

The Brain Surgeon gets the most challenging and difficult work. However, they are too expensive to call all the time. You want them on your team when there is something really important, but you don't need them all the time. So, is it actually possible for the brain surgeon to be anyone's trusted advisor? The business model for the trusted advisor is clearly very different. (You have previously discussed hourly rate and lower leverage etc.)

It also affects things such as conflicts of interest policies. A true trusted advisor will work for fewer clients, because he or she is busy looking after each one more fully. He or she will also see conflicts where other advisors may not -- simply to be genuinely looking after his or her client's best interests. The brain surgeon can not afford such a tight conflict policy. He or she has a larger pool of clients who call for help less frequently, but when it is REALLY needed.

Richard, can you please shed some light how it is possible to stay a trusted advisor and a brain surgeon at the same time?

Duncan, let me both agree and disagree with your propositions. Your analysis seems to be position the "Trusted Advisor" as a particular role or "positioning", rather than as a set of behaviours and skills.

I made the same distinction in an article called "What kind of Provider Are You?" where, like you, I pointed out that the two roles are quite different. In that book, among many other contrasts, I pointed out that the "family doctor role" (I sometimes call it "psychotherapist") is primarily about the skill of diagnosis -- helping the client understand and unbundle the complex symptoms in a situation and decide what needs to be done.

As you say, it is to other people that I may turn (almost always WILL turn) to execute the highly specialist tasks that emerge from the diagnosis. I don't want a surgeon deciding what needs to be done (they will always say "operate") and I don't want my family doctor or "trusted guide" always saying "yes, I can do that, too, let me just get my knife!"

So, I end up concluding that you do have to decide what you want your market positioning to be. The tough part is that we're all capable enough to do it all, but it would be a poor personal or firm strategy to actually do a little of everything and go to market shouting "You want it we got it!" That's no way to build a reputation. (Even though many large firms try to do exactly that.)

If there's a solution for a large firm (not an individual) I could see successfully pulling it off by having clearly organised different teams, staffed with different people (just as a hospital does.) "Here's our diagnosis doctors, and when the time comes, we have specialist surgeons to hand you over to, if you ever need them." It won't be credible if the same doctors keep working in all wards of the hospital!

Of course, even a brain surgeon, who focuses on highly technical tasks, needs to learn interactive skills such as those described. Brain surgeon's don't have to be strong, brooding, sullen, abrupt types. They can and should learn how to interact with clients for the times when they have to. But that's not their role. It's not their positioning.

You had it right first time, Duncan.

Thursday, August 16, 2007

Life Could Be Better

You here a lot of people saying things like these:

  1. We're too busy doing the wrong things to have time to do the right things
  2. We've got so many of the wrong people in the key positions that we can't get the right people appointed
  3. We got too may of the bad clients to serve that we don't have the time to get the good clients
  4. We've been known as people who do X for so long, that no-one will believe that we now do Y
  5. I'm stuck doing stuff I hate but I can't afford to quit
  6. He / She's never going to change, so why bother?

When I do hear such phrases, I'm reminded of this:

"The past has a vote, not a veto."

-- Rabbi Mordechai Kaplan, Born in Lithuania in 1880s

Innovation in the Practice of Law

Innovaction, an online journal celebrating innovation in the practice of law, has just been published by the College of Law Practice Management. It contains a number of articles (including one by me), a roundtable panel discussion, and a collection of success stories. Check it out!