Friday, February 6, 2009

The Client From Hell

Bob Sutton, author of the fabulous book "THE NO-ASSHOLE RULE" has developed an amazing quiz to rate your client(s).

You've GOT to check this out!

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

What Management Owes the Individual Professional

R Sigrid van Roode, from the Netherlands writes in with the following question:

"Our company will start improving our consultancy using the input of your article True Professionalism.  I have carefully read the article (as have all my colleagues) and I have found a situation in my work that to me seems paradoxical.

"In achieving happiness and fulfillment in work, you encourage the professional to start and change himself first, take initiative, show enthusiasm.  It is not advisable to wait for the company itself to change:  that will never happen.  It is also not advisable to 'blame' the management:  that turns the professional into a victim of his surroundings (which a real professional would never allow to happen).

"The paradox is:  professional and company/management are, in my view, interdependent.  They fulfill each others needs and in a way facilitate each others existence.  What is the role of the management in a professional organisation, specifically when it comes to encouraging and stimulating the professionals?

"Actively seeking a positive attitude towards work and client is obviously the main responsibility of the professional himself.  How can the management of a company pick up on that positivity, that initiative?  If the initiative of the professional is not met and answered by the management, the incentive to try and improve oneself, to walk that extra mile for the greater good of the company, will simply be non-existent.  The professional will most likely leave and try to find that reciprocal relation elsewhere.  In short:  how does one manage a professional?

"Any light you could shed on that interesting subject would be greatly welcomed!  Could you for example perhaps point me in the direction of literature I could read on that subject?"

***

The role of management in my view is to:

(a) Provide a clear purpose for the organisation, so that the individual can decide whether that purpose is one they can believe in and contribute to.

(b) Help the individual find his or her passion, providing alternatives, encouragement, support during rough times

(c) Provide clear and honest feedback

(d) Enforce common standards so that the individual is part of a community of like-minded people of whom the individual can be proud.

Does anyone else have different answers?

Saturday, January 31, 2009

The Problems with the Traditional Law firm Management Model

I received a multi-part question about law firm management, which questioned the "traditional" model which many firms use.  Here's the question:

***

My premise is that the traditional system is not only antiquated, it is the cause of many of the problems and issues facing large law firms today.

I am referring to (a) the whole process of law school recruiting, (b) the "class" system for associates, (c) the "up or out" progression to partner and (d) the concept of being a partner inclusive of lockstep compensation.

(a) Law school recruiting / summer program:

This is very expensive from both an attorney time and a financial perspective.  Typically the first year class is larger than needed due to a high number of departures over the first three years.

Classes 1 to 3 are, from an actually working perspective, an unknown commodity and are being trained.  They typically start by earning $160,000 plus bonus.  Many are looking to only pay off their law school loans or aren't even committed to practicing law and often treat this period as a career determining step which accounts for the high turnover.  Considering all the firm investment in these attorneys they aren't usually profitable to the firm till the third year by which time many have already left.  In addition, a growing number of clients are refusing to pay for these associates as their billing rates far outstrip the level and often the quality of work they perform.

Proposed solution:  First, maintain a pool of staff attorneys and document analysts to perform the low level routine (years 1-3) type work.  Made up of part-timers, those wanting a home/life balance (1,800 hour requirement with bonuses paid for hours in excess) and those from second and third tier law schools but with previous work experience.  Hired laterally with no pretense for marked advancement thus there being reduced expectations.  Provides a well paying prestigious job for attorneys otherwise not able to work at large major firms likely resulting in dramatically reduced turnover than currently exists with law school recruits.  Treated as paralegals are treated, quasi administrative/quasi professional staff.  Paid less than 1 to 3 year associates and bill out at less as well which makes clients happy.

Also, hire laterally attorneys with 3  years experience with excellent backgrounds and slot them into "levels" 1 through 5.  Let someone else recruit and train them!  Once an attorney has 3 years of experience they are a much more stable and valuable asset.  We will pay greater than market as well as guarantee partnership.  Therefore, we will target only "A" quality attorneys.  We will also be able to command top dollar for these attorneys since they are all top rated and will be more stable since they are being paid more than market and guaranteed partnership.  This appeals to clients knowing that they will likely be dealing with the same attorneys and not incurring transition costs associated with having to bring in new attorneys on their deals in mid stream when others leave.

(b) The "class" system.  Even though people mature and progress at different rates, under the traditional system people advance strictly based on the passage of time.  Poor performers are asked to leave but decent and average performers advance at the same pace as the excellent performers.  This causes an inequity in the allocation of work, both the type and amount, which ultimately leads to disgruntled attorneys further adding to turnover.

Proposed solution:  Progression from level to level is earned based on performance as evaluated on a semi-annual basis.  The intention is that each attorney will "graduate" from level 5 in a 5 to 7 period when joining at level 1.  Unlike the current "class" system, attorneys will progress from levels 1 through 5 based on performance, not merely the passage of time.  A minimum of 3 years experience is required for level 1.  The purpose of promotion to the next level is the continued growth and development of the attorney with increased training, responsibility and client contact.  Since partnership upon "graduation" from level 5 is guaranteed, this level ascension is viewed as more than just annual salary and rate increases but as partner building.  Since we'll be starting with "A" quality associates with at least 3 years experience, the success rate should be quite high.

(c) Up or out.

For the vast majority who don't make partner for one reason or another after 8 or 10 years, they are typically either asked to leave or invariably leave on their own if given the inauspicious title of "special counsel".  This then results in the firm's loss of investment for after training and mentoring all those years these people take their human capital elsewhere.  Sometimes to a competitor.

Proposed solution.  Upon "graduation" from level 5, partnership would be guaranteed.  This will lead to low leverage which has worked quite well at a firm such as Wachtell with leverage of just 2.51 in 2006 as per the American Lawyer and was the model in the 60s, 70s and 80s when leverage at large New York firms averaged less than 2 to 1 as per the National Law Journal.

Clearly over time partnership ranks will expand at a rate either equal or possibly in excess of our level based associate ranks.  However, this is viewed as a benefit and will enhance retention and overall performance.  The theory is that most partners will perform at a high level given their background and mentoring.  In addition, since there will be a large pool of staff attorneys not eligible for partnership the makeup of our attorneys will be the opposite of a bell curve with large numbers of staff attorneys performing the first through third year type work, relatively few level based associates and a large partner group.

(d) Partner comp.

In the traditional model, the lucky few who make partner are then compensated on a lockstep or modified lockstep basis.  Almost certainly every year a handful of new partners are made.  This results in the firm's need to exponentially grow to maintain the same leverage.  In addition, by simply converting associates to partners, there is a dilution of the profits per partner (barring an increase in business and/or rates.)  Here again there is client backlash against the ever rising billing rates forcing more law firms to grant discounts and write-offs.  Finally, lockstep or modified lockstep is becoming more difficult to maintain at most firms with rainmaker partners either wanting a greater share of profits at their current firms or willing to go to the highest bidder.

Proposed solution.  Two-tiered partnership compensated based on a meritocracy.  Since we are starting with "A" quality associates and providing partner building training and mentoring, the idea is that the vast number of those attaining partnership will be worthy.  In addition, since we will be a two tiered partnership compensated based on merit, all partners will be compensated in proportion to their firm contribution.

***

OK, folks.  What's your reaction to my questioner's analysis and proposed solutions?

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Compensation Systems: Sales Commissions

What's the latest view on paying sales commissions in professional organisations?

I’m generally not a fan, because paying a commission:

  1. Fails to distinguish between revenue and profit.  It can reward bringing in work that the organisation loses money on (or at least makes less money than other alternative uses of its scarce resources.)
  2. Fails to distinguish between on-strategy and off-strategy work.  The organisation ends up with an "if it moves, shoot it" mentality.
  3. Over-rewards the person who makes the final sale (the transaction), and under-rewards activities (for example, seminars, articles, speeches) that "court" the audience and lead them into conversations that result in sales.  Consequently, it encourages an impatience that may backfire in building business.
  4. Encourages salespeople to think of their own rewards (the commission) rather than truly helping the client, and hence creates an uncaring market image that may backfire.
  5. By overstressing individual commissions, can prevent the cooperative teamwork necessary to execute a full coordinated marketing program.  Instead, the sales efforts are no more than the (weakened) sum of a lot of individual efforts, none of which has the impact to make a big difference.

In spite of these concerns, sales commissions are still common in a lot of professional businesses.  In some, such as real estate brokerage or headhunting, it's at the core of how individuals are paid (X% of all revenue generated to the individual, the remainder to the firm.)

And, as firms (in, say, law and accounting) try to get their junior professionals involved in generating business, I see them experimenting with paying those juniors a percentage of what they generate.

What do you think about all this?  Are sales commission systems good in a professional business context?  If not, why are they common?

Sunday, January 25, 2009

Compensation Systems

I'm thinking of writing a monograph or an article on compensation systems.  As part of it, I began a list of some of the things a compensation system needs to accomplish.  It's a long potential list of objectives -- too long, since no one system can accomplish all too many objectives -- and many of them are contradictory!!

Criteria for a good compensation system:

  1. It encourages individual initiative
  2. It encourages working for the good of the whole
  3. It helps people improve, not just rewards them when they do
  4. The decision process is seen as based on all the real facts (i.e. thorough)
  5. Inputs to the process are received from multiple constituencies (group and project leaders, clients, subordinates, peers.)
  6. The decision process is perceived as fair
  7. The criteria for differential rewards are well understood at the beginning of the year
  8. At the end of the process, people know why they got what they got
  9. At the end of the process, people know what to do (and how to do it) next year to get higher rewards
  10. It encourages people to work for the long-term, not just latest year
  11. It provides an incentive (encourages people) to stay
  12. It can reward a variety of contributions necessary for the health of the firm
  13. There is an appropriate return to those who built the business
  14. There's a chance, over time, to achieve the highest levels (i.e. no permanent second-class)
  15. It does not lock-in high rewards for past contributions that are not sustained
  16. The system discourages "cruising" (those on a high reward no longer being energetic)
  17. Timing of rewards does not put firm's cash position at risk
  18. The system does not allow or encourage "gaming" (such as hoarding credit)
  19. Individual superstars can obtain a premium reward

Which of these items do you think are most critical?  Least?  What have I left out?

Friday, January 23, 2009

Survey on Pricing

Mike Schultz of Rain Today.com sent this request:

We are conducting our next major RainToday.com and Wellesley Hills Group benchmark study on Pricing and Fees in Professional Service Businesses and we would like your input.  Please take 20 minutes to share how your firm approaches pricing its services.

You can access the survey here.

As a thank you for your time and input, upon completing the survey you will receive the complimentary RainToday.com report of your choice from the list of our most popular reports below:

  • The Professional Services E-Guide To Online PR (PDF)
  • How To Write And Market A White Paper E-Guide (PDF)
  • How To Become A Thought Leader E-Guide (PDF)
  • How To Set Appointments Through Cold Calling E-Guide (PDF)
  • Marketing Strategy, Planning, and Budgeting for Professional Services (Webinar Recording)

And, feel free to pass the survey on ... your colleagues can receive a free report as well.

Thank you for helping make this research possible.  I appreciate your time and input!

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Focus and Diversification

Here's a question from Mike Spack in St. Louis Park, Minnesota:

"I was talking to a colleague about his employer's strategic plan.  They are a 120-person science/engineering consulting firm.  They are 100% employee owned.  Their plan says no more than 10% of the firm's receipts should come from any single sector.  This strategy blossomed from a time 10 years ago when the firm only worked in three sectors and almost went under when one of the sectors dried up.

"They now work in about 25 different sectors, many of which don't even have potential for cross-selling.  The interesting thing is they are attracting talented people in a broad range of specialties to work for them.  Many of whom have come from firms that have a small niche.  The idea of having a broad client base appeals to many engineering/science types, who are not naturally risk takers.

"This seems to strongly go against your beliefs on developing a consulting firm.  You seem to advocate having a deep, but narrow focus which requires strategically choosing who you will consult for.  Am I missing something?  Is this a viable business strategy for them since they are 100% ESOP and they are 'all in it together?'  Can they make this work or are they doomed?"

****

Mike, I don't have an absolute distaste for diversification, but I do believe in "first depth, then breadth."

If you're going to have a portfolio of client sectors that you compete in, you still have to make sure that you are a credible "specialist" in each.  It's not enough to say "we can do that, too."  If you're going to attract clients, you usually have to convince them that you REALLY know the special circumstances of their sector, and are not just one more generalist.

So, this raises the question of how many sector specialties you can have and still be seen as an informed expert in that sector.  I don't know the details of the engineering/science business (since it's not one of MY specialties, ha-ha), but the numbers you give do make it seem like your friends' firm has swung from one extreme to another.  You say they have 120 people, competing in 25 sectors.  That seems like "a thin layer across a lot of things" to me.  I'd guess that, in many of those sectors, there are more focused competitors who might persuasively convince clients that they have a special interest in their sector and a special capability to serve them.

I don't disagree that many professionals like to work across client sectors (it's fun as well as risk-diversifying), but you have to balance what the provider would like to do with what the clients will pay for.

Does anyone else out there have a perspective on this?

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Mentoring

One of the best books on mentoring that I have found is "The Elements of Mentoring" by W. Brad Johnson and Charles R. Ridley.

Here are some of their chapter headings and subheadings:


Getting to Know Your Protégé

Spend time

Identify and communicate strengths and weaknesses
Allow fears and emotions to be discussed

Expect Excellence
Set high expectations and communicate clearly

Model what you expect of others

Demonstrate confidence

Affirm, Encourage and Support
Show that you value them

Instill confidence

Kindly shed light on unrealistic expectations

Provide Sponsorship
Discern their dream

Help them with first steps

Use your status to get them opportunities

Get them to function on your behalf occasionally

Teach and Coach
Clear Instruction on expectations, roles and functions

Story-telling and metaphors

Help people understand organisational politics

Offer Counsel in Difficult Times
Provide insight, not necessarily answers

Listen, reflect feelings clarify alternatives
Validate feelings

Protect When Necessary
Recognise that protégé will occasionally suffer personal or political problems

Use protection sparingly

Stimulate growth with Challenging assignments


Nurture Creativity

Encourage innovative thought

Safe haven to experiment

Model innovation

Provide Correction -- Even when painful
Confront negative performance or behavior

Help with ideas -- don't just criticise

Narrate Growth and development
Discuss milestones openly

Self-Disclose when appropriate

Accept Increasing Friendship and Mutuality

Model work/Life Balance

Display Dependability

****

What's your experience been with best practice in mentoring?  Have you experienced organisations where it works well?  What is the secret to effectiveness at this?

Friday, January 2, 2009

Ruthlessness and Charity

In an editorial in today's Wall Street Journal, Lawrence B. Lindsey, author of a new book "What a President should Know ... but Most Learn Too Late" gives the opinion that we (the electorate) should seek (as our president) an individual who is ruthless about protecting us against others, but (who) acts with charity towards all and malice towards none at home.

Lindsey acknowledges immediately that this is a tall order.

I don't know if Lindsey's opinion is (a) correct or (b) translates into the business world, but it's an interesting hypothesis about the contrast between an "aggressive, competitive" style when dealing with the external world, and a "nurturing, collaborative" style that many (including me) would advocate inside the firm.

I have a suspicion that "switching" mindsets is difficult for many people, if not most of us.  Those who are aggressive externally may have a bias towards creating internally competitive organisations, and those who tend toward the "nurturing, collaborative" style may fail to evoke the ambition and dynamism on the external marketplace needed for commercial success.

We could create a categorisation scheme of four types (of people or organisations):

  • Externally aggressive, internally nurturing and collaborative
  • Externally aggressive, internally aggressive
  • Externally nurturing and collaborative, internally aggressive
  • Externally nurturing and collaborative, internally nurturing

Which would you bet on to succeed?  Which do you think is actually most common?

Friday, December 19, 2008

Medical Practice as a Professional Service

R Paul L. Shillam, Controller at Pacific Medical Centers in Seattle wrote in to say:

"I just read your article published in Consulting (Nov/Dec 2008). Each time I read your views on professional consultants, accountants or legal firms, it easily translates to the practice of medicine. In a medical practice, there is a group of professionals trained in problem solving and decision making, and then dispensing recommendations to their clients. Clients can either choose to implement their recommendations or not. The medical consultant's success depends a great deal on the relationship between the client and consultant. I could go on with the parallels.

"I think you miss a great opportunity to contribute to the changes needed in health care by limiting your practice to 'service firms'. Isn't the practice of medicine a service anyway? I would be interested in translating much of what you say about the 'trusted advisor' and 'relationships' in professional service firms to the practice of medicine. There is a huge push to change the way medicine is delivered in this country and the common sense approaches your offer to service firms have applicability in the practice of medicine.

"Here's an idea, do a survey of some of your physician acquaintances to see how they react to your ideas ... just a thought."

***

What's the reaction of the rest of you? Do any of you have experience applying professional service firm lessons to medical practitioners? How easy or difficult is it to make the "translation"? How receptive is the medical community?

Wednesday, December 17, 2008

New Business Thinkers

Are there any business thinkers that you are paying attention to that have not been "around" and well-known for years already? Who, if anyone, is an emerging business thinker worth paying attention to?

Saturday, December 13, 2008

Digital Marketing for Professional Firms

David Koopmans, Director of Mokum Marketing in Melbourne, Australia wrote in by email to raise the topic of how professional services firms can use the web in their marketing strategy and what the specific benefits are.

He points out that among some types of professional firm there is often resistance to the concept of marketing in general, and the digital space in particular.

If you were advising a professional firm about web marketing, what would you stress?

I'm not sure how much hard evidence there really is about the benefits of the web in marketing professional services. I suspect that key decision-makers and buyers are not spending much time on the net. Their staff subordinates (HR people, marketing directors, strategy people etc.,) may use it more, and you may be found that way, but I doubt that there is much of a direct executive audience.

I would probably point out that the old adage "demonstrate don't assert" remains the key to effective use of web technology, and that websites need to have voluminous amounts of easy to search and easy to find content, so that you can you can prove that you have something to offer (and are generous and professional enough to share it.) The ease of use of your digital marketing gives you an opportunity to show your ability to put yourself in the shoes of the client / purchaser and understand things from their perspective, rather than saying "let us tell you about us."

I'd also stress that you need to be well advised by people who understand search engine optimisation, so that if there are buyers who don't know you, you are found when they begin searching.

It's still early days for blogging, podcasting and videocasting, but I'd have to guess that, for most professional service firms, these are not high return activities -- again, because I'm not sure that the "high-level" buyers are listening and watching.

I've had a lot of fun and success with my own activities (which I reported on last year in an article called "Adventures in Modern Marketing") but it's very hard to unbundled the incremental marketing benefit that being active on the web has brought. I'm not sure what I would advise a client to do in this area, nor how much of their marketing budget to devote to web activities.

What do the rest of you think? What advice would you give to a professional firm about digital marketing? What have we learned?

Friday, December 12, 2008

Meeting Rules

We all know meetings are a curse.

Here are some of the rules I would offer to help make them more productive.

  1. Do not call meetings when some other form of information sharing is possible.
  2. Since most people can read ten times faster than a presenter can speak, send material ahead.
  3. Meetings need to have concrete goals (a purpose for what must be accomplished), not just an agenda.
  4. Select speciifc start and stop times and stick to them
  5. Restrict attendance to only those who must be there
  6. Appoint a reporter at the beginning of the meeting, charged with recording the discussion, writing it up, and circulating the meeting notes within 24 hours
***

Those are just some of the rules I would offer. What meeting rules would you propose?

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Reputations

Consistency, dependability and regularity work: occasional peaks of excellence don't.

For example, always meet your deadlines.

If you are asked to do something, make sure you know exactly what it is and when it is due.

If you have doubts about your ability to complete on time or about the task's priority or importance, raise your concern with your manager or client immediately.

It is OK to need more time as long as you ask for it ahead of time. It is OK to struggle and ask for help.

It is not OK to break your commitments. The fastest and surest way to fail is to break your word.

Wednesday, December 3, 2008

The Rule of St. Benedict

At a seminar I conducted last Friday, the topic of enforcing standards came up -- as it always does. And, again as always, I made the point that the courage to enforce standards by asking otherwise productive people to leave is both essential and scarce. We also discussed the charcateristics of an effective manager of professionals.

Over the weekend, I heard from Adam Simon, Managing Director of Business Optimisation Services at PRG-Schultz Europe. He wrote:

Many thanks for your words of inspiration at last Friday's seminar. Before going into business 25 years ago I spent some time as a Benedictine monk and have often tried to draw on that experience in my business life.

As you were leaving, I asked if you had read the rule of St Benedict and you said no. I think you will love parts of it, especially two chapters that I draw your attention to for a starter: Chapter 2 what type of man the Abbot should be. I do not think that in all management writing, pace Drucker, Peters and all the gurus, there is a better description of what a good manager should be. Chapter 28, Of Those Who Having Often Been Corrected Do Not Amend, which follows your principle that people have to be pulling in the same direction or leave. Whilst many of the specifics in the rule have no relevance, the spirit is totally modern with its understanding of human frailty and the difficulties of living with others.

Here is a link to a translation of the rule into English (slightly old fashioned language, better modern translations do exist but I could not find them on the web).

CHAPTER II

What Kind of Man the Abbot Ought to Be

The Abbot who is worthy to be over a monastery ought always to be mindful of what he is called, and make his works square with his name of Superior. For he is believed to hold the place of Christ in the monastery, when he is called by his name, according to the saying of the Apostle: "You have received the spirit of adoption of sons, whereby we cry Abba (Father)" (Rom 8:15). Therefore, the Abbot should never teach, prescribe, or command (which God forbid) anything contrary to the laws of the Lord; but his commands and teaching should be instilled like a leaven of divine justice into the minds of his disciples.

Let the Abbot always bear in mind that he must give an account in the dread judgment of God of both his own teaching and of the obedience of his disciples. And let the Abbot know that whatever lack of profit the master of the house shall find in the sheep, will be laid to the blame of the shepherd. On the other hand he will be blameless, if he gave all a shepherd's care to his restless and unruly flock, and took all pains to correct their corrupt manners; so that their shepherd, acquitted at the Lord's judgment seat, may say to the Lord with the Prophet: "I have not hid Thy justice within my heart. I have declared Thy truth and Thy salvation" (Ps 39[40]:11). "But they contemning have despised me" (Is 1:2; Ezek 20:27). Then at length eternal death will be the crushing doom of the rebellious sheep under his charge.

When, therefore, anyone taketh the name of Abbot he should govern his disciples by a twofold teaching; namely, he should show them all that is good and holy by his deeds more than by his words; explain the commandments of God to intelligent disciples by words, but show the divine precepts to the dull and simple by his works. And let him show by his actions, that whatever he teacheth his disciples as being contrary to the law of God must not be done, "lest perhaps when he hath preached to others, he himself should become a castaway" (1 Cor 9:27), and he himself committing sin, God one day say to him: "Why dost thou declare My justices, and take My covenant in thy mouth? But thou hast hated discipline, and hast cast My words behind thee" (Ps 49[50]:16-17). And: "Thou who sawest the mote in thy brother's eye, hast not seen the beam in thine own" (Mt 7:3).

Let him make no distinction of persons in the monastery. Let him not love one more than another, unless it be one whom he findeth more exemplary in good works and obedience. Let not a free-born be preferred to a freedman, unless there be some other reasonable cause. But if from a just reason the Abbot deemeth it proper to make such a distinction, he may do so in regard to the rank of anyone whomsoever; otherwise let everyone keep his own place; for whether bond or free, we are all one in Christ (cf Gal 3:28; Eph 6:8), and we all bear an equal burden of servitude under one Lord, "for there is no respect of persons with God" (Rom 2:11). We are distinguished with Him in this respect alone, if we are found to excel others in good works and in humility. Therefore, let him have equal charity for all, and impose a uniform discipline for all according to merit.

For in his teaching the Abbot should always observe that principle of the Apostle in which he saith: "Reprove, entreat, rebuke" (2 Tm 4:2), that is, mingling gentleness with severity, as the occasion may call for, let him show the severity of the master and the loving affection of a father. He must sternly rebuke the undisciplined and restless; but he must exhort the obedient, meek, and patient to advance in virtue. But we charge him to rebuke and punish the negligent and haughty. Let him not shut his eyes to the sins of evil-doers; but on their first appearance let him do his utmost to cut them out from the root at once, mindful of the fate of Heli, the priest of Silo (cf 1 Sam 2:11-4:18). The well-disposed and those of good understanding, let him correct at the first and second admonition only with words; but let him chastise the wicked and the hard of heart, and the proud and disobedient at the very first offense with stripes and other bodily punishments, knowing that it is written: "The fool is not corrected with words" (Prov 29:19). And again: "Strike thy son with the rod, and thou shalt deliver his soul from death" (Prov 23:14).

The Abbot ought always to remember what he is and what he is called, and to know that to whom much hath been entrusted, from him much will be required; and let him understand what a difficult and arduous task he assumeth in governing souls and accommodating himself to a variety of characters. Let him so adjust and adapt himself to everyone -- to one gentleness of speech, to another by reproofs, and to still another by entreaties, to each one according to his bent and understanding -- that he not only suffer no loss in his flock, but may rejoice in the increase of a worthy fold.

Above all things, that the Abbot may not neglect or undervalue the welfare of the souls entrusted to him, let him not have too great a concern about fleeting, earthly, perishable things; but let him always consider that he hath undertaken the government of souls, of which he must give an account. And that he may not perhaps complain of the want of earthly means, let him remember what is written: "Seek ye first the kingdom of God and His justice, and all these things shall be added unto you" (Mt 6:33). And again: "There is no want to them that fear Him" (Ps 33[34]:10). And let him know that he who undertaketh the government of souls must prepare himself to give an account for them; and whatever the number of brethren he hath under his charge, let him be sure that on judgment day he will, without doubt, have to give an account to the Lord for all these souls, in addition to that of his own. And thus, whilst he is in constant fear of the Shepherd's future examination about the sheep entrusted to him, and is watchful of his account for others, he is made solicitous also on his own account; and whilst by his admonitions he had administered correction to others, he is freed from his own failings.

CHAPTER XXVIII

Of Those Who Having Often Been Corrected Do Not Amend

If a brother hath often been corrected and hath even been excommunicated for a fault and doth not amend, let a more severe correction be applied to him, namely, proceed against him with corporal punishment.

But if even then he doth not reform, or puffed up with pride, should perhaps, which God forbid, even defend his actions, then let the Abbot act like a prudent physician. After he hath applied soothing lotions, ointments of admonitions, medicaments of the Holy Scriptures, and if, as a last resource, he hath employed the caustic of excommunication and the blows of the lash, and seeth that even then his pains are of no avail, let him apply for that brother also what is more potent than all these measures: his own prayer and that of the brethren, that the Lord who is all-powerful may work a cure in that brother.

But if he is not healed even in this way, then finally let the Abbot dismiss him from the community, as the Apostle saith: "Put away the evil one from among you" (1 Cor 5:13); and again: "If the faithless depart, let him depart" (1 Cor 7:15); lest one diseased sheep infect the whole flock.

Friday, November 28, 2008

Mentoring

There's an interesting discussion this month in the print version of CONSULTING magazine about mentoring programs in consulting firms. What's notable is how diverse the programs are. Some are highly structured, while others are based on encouraging mentees to seek out their own mentors among the senior staff.

One common element is the claim that senior people are evaluated on how well they develop their mentees. I wonder how real this is, and how much is just paying lip-service. I'm sure it's on the list, but I don't know how much weight is actually given to it. After all, senior people have lots of other things they are evaluated on.

Do any of you have experience being effectively mentored inside your firm? What were the key elements that made the mentoring program work well in your organisation?

Friday, November 21, 2008

Technical Excelllence

In many professional businesses, high technical excellence is taken for granted -- we assume that having it is "table stakes" for competing.

However, it's not a trivial issue to ask whether and how a firm goes about ensuring that its employees in fact meet high standards of technical expertise, especially in a world where companies tend to signal that revenue generation is a more pressing (if not more important) topic.

Who is best positioned in a professional organisation to judge an employee's technical quality? I assume that it might be that person's supervisor, but there could be some built-in conflicts: what if the supervisor is under economic pressure to meet group goals and hence compromise (a little) degrees of technical excellence?

I'm curious about your experience as to how your firm or company goes about ensuring technical excellence. Is it some combination of:

  1. Training
  2. On-the-job supervision
  3. Peer Review Processes at the Job Level
  4. Annual Performance Appraisals
  5. Reward schemes

Or something else?

Thursday, November 20, 2008

Believer or Sceptic?

When working with clients on change initiatives, I notice that they have two widely different strategies for appointing the internal person to lead the project. In some cases, they appoint a "true believer" who really wants to see the change happen. In other cases, firms go out of their way to appoint a sceptic, so that only proposals that can overcome the scepticism emerge from the study task-force, and proposals are not made that will not be implemented.

As a consultant, it's easier initially to work with a true believer, but the implementation success may be higher if a sceptic is appointed.

Does anyone have experience with this? if you were a company manager, who would you appoint to lead the charge on new strategic change intiatives?

Friday, November 14, 2008

Another reader question

My question to you and all your website contributors;

What have been people's experiences with the strategy of targeting only working with one client per industry sector and deliberately broadcasting to the market that that is your "modus operandi"? It's a bit clumsy, but, for example -- "We guarantee our clients that we will not work for their competitors, thereby preserving exclusively for our clients, the commercial advantage of partnering with us"

I know the applicability may vary with the type of services one offers, but do others have any thoughts on this approach?

Thursday, November 13, 2008

Implementing a Client Service Strategy

One of the most common topics I am asked to advise on is achieving distinctively high levels of client service. I find that many firms underestimate how tough a diet and exercise program (see STRATEGY AND THE FAT SMOKER) it would really take to pull this off.

Among the changes that most firms would need to make are:

  1. Adopting a culture that no longer allows people to "opt out" on the topic of client service excellence on the grounds that their skills lie elsewhere. A firm can't get a reputation for something that not everyone does.
  2. Finding some way to monitor client feedback in real time (not just once a year) and make it credible to everyone that there will be a follow up for anything less than excellence.
  3. Providing training in client counselling skills
  4. Providing research support from the marketing department to help service delivery people stay current on client industries
  5. Enable sharing of experiences (workshops and workbooks) among practitioners on an ongoing basis to establish a continuous improvement approach to client satisfaction.
  6. Implement disciplined project management systems, including mandatory processes for communications strategies with clients mid-process.
  7. A systematic program of senior officer visits to clients to "role model" the firm's commitment.

None of these approaches are new or innovative. (I first wrote about them in the 1990s, and I wasn't the originator then.) However, it is still my experience that firms are less than systematic in implementing a client service strategy.

What systems do you think are need to pull this strategy off? What else needs to be in the "change package?"