Wednesday, August 15, 2007

Doing It Through A Blanket

A number of my clients have been asking me how you sell to a corporation where you do not have the opportunity to meet the "real" client executive who is going to use your service or product, but have to "sell" though a consultant who has been hired to run the client's buying process. They say they want to use the principles in my article The Trusted Advisor approach in their selling, but don't see how you do that if there is a gatekeeper. (They describe this to me a tryng to make love through a blanket!)

There's probably been a lot of research on this topic about which I am not aware, but I'm fascinated with how much this approach to buying has grown and spread. It happens in corporate purchases of:

  • Advertising
  • Public relations
  • Asset management
  • Outsourcing
  • Large management consulting projects
  • Law firm selection and monitoring
  • and many other services.

My curiosity is aroused in trying to explain why this is expanding so much. Why don't corporate officers select and choose their own outside providers? Why do they need the consultants to advise them?

I can see why you would need an advisor if you were a one-time buyer, buying only periodically, or buying something particularly big. Then, you would want to tap into the specialists' expertise and greater knowledge of what's out there, and who's good. It would save you search time. We've all used people to perform that role for us at one time or another.

But what if you buy the product or service all the time? What if it's your JOB? If you are, say, the investment officer for a state pension fund, wouldn't it be your job to know who's out there? Or if you're a marketing manager who's been in place for 5 or 6 years, shouldn't you know who the possible agencies are and what their reputation is?

My guess is that these buyers DO know, and are employing "consultants to the process" to achieve other goals. If we are to successfully "penetrate" this layer between ultimate client and vendor, then we must understand what the buyer is hoping to achieve by putting it in place.

There are a number of possible purposes, including:

  1. By using third-party consultants, buyers can make the buying process appear more formal and detached, and give the appearance to their corporate masters (or Wall street Observers) that they are being diligent and responsible in their buying. They are buying affirmation, reassurance and cloud-cover against attacks that they were "soft" or relied too much on things like "relationships."

  2. Putting the third party in place allows all sorts of buying games including "Good Cop / Bad Cop" (Client/consultant) The hired-gun gatekeeper plays tough guy, while the client (who has to work with the service provider afterwards) can remain above the negotiating fray and preserve the bases for a good working relationship.

  3. Some consultants could offer a lot more than just a "gatekeeper" function. The client may have only an unfocused understanding of his or her own needs, and what the consultant is doing is providing a "strategic navigator" service, so that the client can understand which outside service (a pill, a nurse, a brain surgeon) he or she really needs to buy. By separating the diagnosis from the execution, the client benefits by not having biased people (the vendors) always selling what they have, rather than what the client needs.

I have some additional thoughts, but let me find out if this is a topic of interest to anybody out there. The questions for you (all) are:

  1. Are there other reasons companies hire consultants to advise them on their buying?

  2. How well do the vendors understand the real reasons?

  3. What are the implications for the DIFFERENT rationales for how a vendor should respond. Does the vendor do different things if the client is using consultants for different purposes?

Monday, August 13, 2007

Experts vs. Advisors -- new client videocast & audiocast

In this episode, entitled Experts vs Advisors, we're going to dig deeper into what it feels like to be the buyer of professional services. There are two ways that sellers come across in marketing their profession. They are either seen as being interested in the prospective client, their needs and the best solution for them or they are seen as interested in the transaction itself and the cash that goes with it. It's obvious which would lend the most to creating a trusting relationship, but often convincing the buyer that the care and interest is genuine is the true test. We will look into the best ways for you to think in order to put this care and interest across to your prospective client.

Audio Timeline

00:39 -- Introduction
00:45 -- The seller in the eyes of the buyer: Interested in the buyer vs. interest in the cash
02:28 -- Convincing the buyer that you care about them
03:39 -- Conclusion
04:21 -- Special announcement: Forthcoming Book and DVD offer

You can download Experts vs Advisors or sign up to receive new videos automatically with iTunes or other video players. (Click here for step-by-step instructions on how to subscribe.) My seminars are always available for download at no cost.

Saturday, August 11, 2007

How We Really Make Decisions

Bob Sutton, co-author (with Jeff Pfeffer) of the terrific book Hard Facts, Dangerous Half-Truths & Total Nonsense, had a fascinating post a few days ago about "Lovaglia’s Law."

Michael Lovaglia, (a professor at the University of Iowa) proposed Lovaglia's Law: The more important the outcome of a decision, the more people will resist using evidence to make it.

Bob discusses this, and agrees that, the more consequential the outcome, the more power, greed, stress and irrationality come into play in influencing how people react and how individual and collective decisions are made.

He offers the idea that it could be a clever strategy to "try to reframe big decisions as small ones -- to fool yourself and others into believing that what seems big is really small!" If the decision seems less critical, logic and reason have a better chance of influencing the outcome.

I think there is something very important here. I have always been fascinated by the fact that (in spite of what they teach us in school) logic, reason, rationality and sensible analysis seem to play so little part in human affairs -- at the office, in our home lives, and elsewhere.

It sometimes seems as if, for all of us, nearly all the time, rhetoric triumphs over reason, personality over substance, politics over merits, neuroses over facts.

I'm not saying this as a complaint. I'm saying that it's a more accurate critique of human affairs than the misleading interpretation we sometimes fool ourselves with -- that our smarts (logic, reason and rationality) are what drive the world.

Tom Davenport (author of Thinking for a Living) recently published an article in the Harvard Business Review arguing that there is a huge competitive advantage to be gained by companies if they were to develop a more analytical approach to business, using advanced analytical abilities. It's a great article, but its truth and its power comes from the fact that so few of us, as individuals or as institutions, in our work lives or in our personal lives, actually do make our decisions primarily through logic and analysis.

That's why it can be a competitive advantage for anyone who can escape Lovaglia's Law.

Friday, August 10, 2007

Can We Copy Our Heroes?

One of the frustrations of life is that we can't always do what our heroes are able to do. In fact, that may be the very reason that why we admire them and pick them out as heroes. They can do (or be) things that we cannot. If we could do it, we might admire it less!

When I was a teenager, my best friend was the natural centre of attention because of his ability to sing and play both guitar and piano. I could do none of these, and every attempt to do them led to embarrassment rather than success. It took me a long time to stop trying to copy my hero (and to develop my own ways of getting attention).

Later in life, I came to admire people who could remain calm and self-composed when dealing with troublesome situations, and also people who could be trusted advisors, truly counselling those they dealt with, rather than lapsing into energised problem-solving ("Oh, I have an idea! Let me tell you about it!")

I wrote an article about being a trusted advisor not because I was or am a natural at that skill, but for the very reason that I wanted to understand it better and try -- try -- to build more of it into my repertoire.

The problem for me is that the very reason I admire such people -- their controlled, interpersonal "emotional balance," is something that I have to work very hard at. By nature, I'm an exuberant, reactive, "wow, look at what just happened" kind of person. It's not a bad thing -- it’s just the base, the raw material, on which I am built -- and it would be foolsh (or impossible) to deny it.

What I've had to do -- what I think all of us have to do -- is kind of a dual approach.

On the one hand, I do work at trying to learn from those I admire, attempting to adapt some of the things they can do into my own terms. I try to take "slices" of what they can do or be, rather than try to copy the whole person, which can be discouragingly impossible.

On the other hand, I've learned that self-acceptance and building on one's own "natural" strengths and aptitudes are important.

Rather than ask "How do I change who I am?" or "How can I be more like those I admire?" I have had more success through a (conscious or unconscious) "self-acceptance" -- This is who I am, so how do I find a way to be that? How do I make it work for me and for others?

The hard part is not just the advice that we should build on our strengths. That's very true, but only part of the story. Another important part is "Know -- and accept -- thyself."

Back in action -- come and comment

We are pretty sure the glitch with the comment function is fixed, so come on back and join in the conversational fun.

Thursday, August 9, 2007

The First 100 Days

Patrick McKenna has written a fabulous new 23-pagee-book called FIRST 100 DAYS: Transitioning A New Managing Partner.

Here's an outline of Patrick's step-by-step recipe:

1. Begin Before The Handoff (during the countdown before you officially take office)

  • Position yourself as a leader who is eager to listen to the opinions of your peers.
  • Build a working relationship with the departing Managing Partner.
  • Create constructive dialogue with key thought leaders and power brokers within your firm.
  • Tie up loose ends with key clients.
  • Try to deal with sensitive problems before you take office.

2. Plug Your Gaps

  • Figure out what you need to know and learn it as rapidly as you can.
  • Establish your advice network.

3. Establish Performance Standards

  • Negotiate your specific metrics for success.

4. Seize Your Day

  • Pay attention to personal habits.
  • Make symbolic gestures.
  • Convey basic information.

5. Set Your Agenda

  • Identify your one burning imperative.
  • Get critical partner buy-in.
  • Develop an action plan to implement your initiative.
  • Launch a pilot project.

6. Exploit Early Successes

  • Identify something that would not have happened had it not been for your burning imperative.

Patrick's monograph is made up of 11 pages of his advice, followed by 11 pages of direct quotes from law firm managing partners reflecting on their experience. I showed Patrick's monograph to some clients of mine outside the legal profession, and they agreed that it's incredibly useful and well-written.

Tuesday, August 7, 2007

Dealing With the Worried Well

In medicine, there's a long tradition of the concept of "triage" -- quickly dividing emergency room or battlefield patients into groups so you can decide where your efforts as a doctor are best spent.

The word itself comes from the Latin (or is it Greek?) meaning three groups, but along the way a scheme was evolved which put people into four groups:

(a) the sick (who really need you but can be hard to help),

(b) the early sick (who you can usually help),

(c) the worried well, (who don't really need you but want to hire you) and

(d) the well (who don't need you).

This is a very handy scheme to use in other environments. For example, if you are a manager in charge of a group of people, the scheme can help you decide how much personal time to allocate to each of the individuals in your group.

It can also apply to customer groups. In some businesses, including consulting, the economics of these different groups vary wildly. The sick, since they cannot really be cured, are often unprofitable. The early sick are reasonably profitable.

As long as they'll pay for your time, the "worried well" can be a source of very high profits -- there's nothing really wrong with them, but they keep coming back for one more reassuring examination or study.

Of course, this is not all good news. There's an ethical issue here -- do you really want to make your income from people who don't really need or benefit from your services?

In addition, unless you have the pricing right, the worried well can choke up your delivery capacity, making you unavailable to those who really need you.

Who are the worried well in your business life? How do you deal with them?

Monday, August 6, 2007

Site Upgrade

Very shortly, I'll be rolling out a major upgrade to my website.

Most of the changes relate to the engine that drives this site -- the "under-the-hood" part of the website. However, visitors will also be able to notice a few changes, including:

Popular Posts -- the blog will now include a list of the most popular posts, based on the number of comments, in the hopes of keeping this site's liveliest conversations alive and accessible to new visitors;

Blog Comments -- a WYSIWYG (what-you-see-is-what-you-get) editor will let you add basic formatting to your comments, including hypertext links; and, the new 2-click commenting process will help us remove the lag caused by comment moderation, keep the conversation on the blog more up-to-date, and at the same time keep comment spam in check;

Subscription Options -- in addition to being able to subscribe to specific media on the site (such as blog posts or podcasts), I've now added RSS feeds to the 5 resource libraries, so that if you are interested in a specific topic, you can subscribe for notification of new materials anywhere on this site related to strategy, managing, client relations, careers, or other;

Feedback -- the new feedback section on the podcast page lets you write a review of the podcasts on iTunes or Yahoo, or cast a monthly vote for the podcast at Podcast Alley (all of which I greatly appreciate).

As with any beta project, there may be some minor bugs at first, so I ask for your understanding as we work through any initial technical difficulties.

The end result should be a much more technically efficient site at my end and a much more pleasant experience, I hope, for you, the readers.

Thank you to the many readers whose input, feedback and suggestions are reflected in the coming site changes. Keep the good ideas coming. And I hope you enjoy the new version of the site.

Sunday, August 5, 2007

Advice on Careers

What do you think I ought to cover in my next podcast series?

I intend it to be, like my past series, about 14 or so 20-minute presentations, exept this time the topic will be advice to individuals in building their careers.

I'll draw on previous articles of mine (like It's Not How Much You Know, But How Much You Want It, Cultivate the Habits of Friendship, and the many career blog posts we have discussed here.

But I'd love your input on which topics would really be useful to cover.

If you were going to give advice to someone at the early stages of life as a professional (in any business or industry) what would would you try to help them understand early?

Saturday, August 4, 2007

Stop Chasing The Prom Queen and the Star Halfback

Rick Telberg, who writes a great blog (CPA Trendlines) about the accounting industry (profession?) has an interesting post, based on research, about who decides when companies choose a new audit or accounting firm. He reports that:

"(outside) CPAs are apparently under the impression that company owners are the Dudes of Decision. ... Only seven percent thought the CFO, controller or internal auditor makes the decision. Just five percent said it's the CEO, and only two percent thought the board of directors decides."

"But when we asked corporate accountants who makes the decision, we got a whole 'nother point of view. CFOs seem to think that they, the CFOs themselves, make the decision. At least 56 percent of them think so. Only 26 percent said it's the owner."

It's been my experience that everybody makes the mistake of thinking that THEIR project is so important to the client enterprise that it must be the client CEO who not only makes the buying decision, but wants to meet all the possible providers (i.e. them.)

Even for a relatively small company, this becomes a ludicrous proposition once you start looking at how many different service providers are competing for the CEO's attention. A typical company might, on a regular basis, need to buy:

  1. Legal advice from more than a few law firms (different firms for different issues and jurisdictions)
  2. Advertising advice from an ad agency
  3. Public relations and public affairs advice from one or more PR firms
  4. Accounting services (audit plus) from one or more accounting firms
  5. IT services from a technology firm
  6. Executive Training from an HR consulting firm
  7. Executive search for a new top officer from a headhunter firm
  8. Financial or merger, acquisition advice from an investment bank
  9. Asset reallocation in pension plan restructuring from either a money management firm.
  10. Real estate strategy for office, manufacturing, distribution, retail operations from a real estate firm
  11. Supply channel (logistics) advice from either a possible partner or third-party advisor.

What's amusing to me about this list is that examples of everysingle one of these firms has asked me to conduct seminars for their people about how they can become their clients' key TRUSTED ADVISOR, focusing on the CEO. But they can't all be, simultaneously!

It seems that everybody wants (to use the Australian terminology) to date the prom queen and the star halfback, and, as a result, is probably neglecting or treating badly someone else who might really want a relationship!

The problem is, of course, that most CEOs don't want this number of close personal advisors, so, they delegate the details, the relationship and hold their subordinates accountable.

The neglected, less glamorous people around the beauty queen and the captain of the team may actually be the very people who can give you what you want!

Providers who are still trying to meet (and sell to) the CEO probably overestimate their own importance and misunderstand the priorities of a CEO.

(Thanks to Dennis Howlett for directing me to Rick's post.)

Friday, August 3, 2007

I'm honored

I am thrilled to announce that my podcast series is included in the final voting slate of nominated podcasts for the 2006 People's Choice Podcast Awards contest as one of the five finalists in the Best Business Podcast category.

In the preliminary nominations round, a review committee selected the finalists based on the criteria of sound quality, delivery, show format, and show content, as well as 50% of the score allocated to the number of nominating votes.

So, I must give my heart-felt thanks to the friends and listeners who have surprised me by voting for the podcast during the nomination process. Given that I only launched the podcast series six months ago, I didn't expect to even be nominated for the Podcast Awards, let alone find myself a finalist!

I'm NOT asking you to vote for my podcasts in the final round -- I fully expect another to win, and don't believe in futile activity.

What I hope you will do is to support the cause of podcasting (and yourself) by checking out the other nominees for Best Business Podcast:

I'd also love any feedback in my planning for the future: If you are already a podcast listener, what do you look for in a podcast? And if you don't listen to podcasts yet, what would it take to make podcasts enticing for you?

Start the Day Off Right!

There's a fascinating (and possibly very important) study conducted by Nancy Rothbard (a Wharton professor) and Steffanie Wilk (an Ohio State professor) on call-centre employees. It's called Waking Up on the Wrong Side of the Desk: The Effect of Mood on Work Performance.

They report that the mood you bring with you to work has a stronger effect on work performance than mood changes caused by events in the workplace.

Think about that -- if you come to work already in an optimistic or upbeat mood (because of things that have nothing to do with work), you are more likely to be productive, efficient and do better quality work.

This matches my life -- if I start out right, I get a huge amount done; but if I start out grumpy I almost never turn it around. The start-of-day mood is disproportionately influential.

It also matches a phenomenon I wrote about in an article called The Psychology of Waiting Lines, where I offered a lesson learned by every waiter and waitress: -- Its hard to play catch-up ball. If the customers sit down happy in a restaurant (or diner) it's not too hard to keep them happy, but if they sit down disgruntled, there's almost nothing you can do to please them -- they are loaded for bear!

There are lessons here for self-management, and also for companies or managers trying to help employees become productive. As the authors point out, people rarely receive training from their employers in the problems they have in their personal lives, yet the moods they develop as a result of these problems may be (may be? -- ARE!) a major determinant of employee performance.

So what does THAT say a manager has to be good at? Helping employees deal with personal problems, so that they come to work in a positive frame of mind?

There's no escaping the fact that the pragmatic conclusion is yes -- even though many of us would love to believe it's not our place to get involved in employees' personal problems. Ignore this at your peril!

And what about us as individuals? Should each of us develop "start of the day" devices (uniquely tailored for what works for us as individuals) to start the day off right? Some might go for a run, some might meditate, some might just play the following Bee Gees song sequence: "In the Morning" "Words" "Melody Fair." "Islands in the Stream (Kenny and Dolly version)" ( I said it had to be individual, right?)

Seriously, there are two questions for you to respond to: Do you have a personal device or approach to set up the day, and (b) what do you think managers can / should do to help employees / team-members do so?

Thursday, August 2, 2007

What New Hires Are Thinking

Rachel Beanland (a PR practitioner from Amherst, Massachusetts) has just written a fascinating article called "Ten things you didn't know about the grad you just hired".

Based on interviews and email correspondence with young professionals, it's fabulous, and (most of it) applies well beyond the boundaries of the PR profession, and deserves a wider audience.

Here are her 10 lessons:

  1. The grad you just hired didn't have a hard time finding a job.
  2. They know they're underpaid, and they won't put up with it longer than they have to.
  3. It's not taking them long to grow bored.
  4. Even when they're happy, they're looking for another job.
  5. Their bosses aren't their mentors.
  6. Getting thrown into the work force is turning them into experienced pros before their time.
  7. Some don't feel their universities prepared them for ... (insert profession or industry name here)
  8. They're looking to find a balance between work and their personal lives.
  9. Many of them would love to become independent practitioners or start their own firms one day.
  10. They think they'll stay in the (insert name) profession, but not necessarily in (the place they started.)

As Rachel writes when she quotes some of the 20-something's she talked to: "If you're not taking notes, there's a great likelihood you'll read some of these comments again anyway -- in letters of resignation as up-and-coming talent goes on to bigger and better jobs."

Wednesday, August 1, 2007

Welcome, welcome back and thanks!

It's time to thank the community for participating. For the month of July, here are those who joined our discussions. They have my appreciation, gratitude, and thanks. I don't know who to thank more -- those who joined in for the first time, or those who have been loyal, frequent participants for some time. Obviously, it's both equally!

Now, who is going to design the logo for the "club badge" that we can all wear? What should the T-shirt say?

commentors

Adnan, Alberen, Hugh Alley, Steve Arpano, Lora Banks, Chris Barrow, Rich Berger, Kent M. Blumberg, Eric Boehme, Bonnie, Leo J Bottary, Breakingranks, Duncan Bucknell, James Bullock, Tim Burrows, Shawn Callahan, Anita Campbell, Sebastian Carey, John Carroll, James Cherkoff, Clarke Ching, Eric Christiansen, Dan Crites, D, DUST!N, Jennifer Davis, Krishna De, John Dillard, Eric, Steve Farber, Brad Farris, Charlie Garrard, David Giacalone, Mark Gould, Charles H. Green, Dennis Howlett, Jaylpea, Jennifer, Jon, David Koopmans, Peter Kua, Ed Lee, Bruce Lewin, Tim MMF, MOHAN KRISHNAN, Bruce MacEwen, Peter Macmillan, Steve Matthews, Lex McCafferty, Patrick J. McKenna, Ann Michael, Matt Moore, Justin Patten, Bill Peper, Tim Percival, Bill Perry, Peter, RJON@HowToMakeItRain.com, Jeff Risley, Steve Rucinski, Roman Rytov, Brent Schlenker, Sebastian, Carl Singer, Starbucker, David Tebbutt, Fiona Torrance, Coert Visser, Curt Wehrley, Fred Wiersma

trackbacks

AccMan Pro, Adam Smith, Esq., Adventure of StrategyAntitrust Review, Biz Growth News, Blog Carnival, Blogtrepreneur, Bryan C. Fleming, Burrows, Client Service -- Leo Bottary, Coolz0r -- Marketing Thoughts, Creating A Better Life, Direct Response Works, Fat Pitch Financials, Financial Freedom Library, Golden Practices, Law Firm Business Development, Law.com Blog Network, Legal Sanity, Marketing Babylon, Marketing Profs Daily Blog Fix, Matt Inglot's Thoughts on Entrepreneurship, Money Thinking, morepartnerincome, musings from strategic leverage partners, Names @ Work, Natalie Solent, Reforming Project Management, Roman's miles, Seeds of Growth, Small Business CEO, Success Connections, The Agonist, The Bell Curve Scar, the blogging boss, The Business of America is Business, The Coach Approach, The Expertise Marketplace, The Marcus Perspective, Tim Worstall, What's on Mike's Mind, Women@Sun

Integrity Impugned

Because of prior poor experiences -- or the generally bad caricatures that exist about many professions -- clients are often suspicious (at least initially) of the motives of their service providers.

Just think of the many jokes about consultants who act as if they are more concerned about looking for the next follow-on assignment to cross-sell than doing the current one well; lawyers who are suspected of running up the billable hours because they are paid by the hour; and advertising agency people who are more concerned with winning prizes than selling the client's product or service.

Whatever your profession, you need to be prepared for the fact that, at the beginning of every new relationship, you must avoid confirming other people's (inevitable) starting suspicions about your motives, and must actively work to demonstrate that you are, in fact, unlike the providers that the client may have experienced before.

This is not easy. It turns out that it is not enough just to be trustworthy. You must also know how to give the client the experience that you are visibly, obviously, trustworthy.


The Incident

The need to learn how to do this was brought home to me by a dramatic incident that happened at the start of my consulting career -- eleven years ago.

I had been hired to help the executive committee of a major consulting firm in formulating their strategy. There were eight or ten senior officers of the firm around the table.

As I was generating various options for them to consider, the CEO suddenly said to me (in front of everyone else): "You're not really trying to help us. You just want to see us change so you can get consulting fees."

I had no idea what to say, and so said nothing. I was hugely offended. It's one thing to dislike my ideas, but to question my ethics? Impugn my integrity?

The air hung heavy and silent until one of the other executives picked up the conversation and moved on.

I carried on working with that firm, through the term of my contract, and no-one ever referred to the CEO's remarks again.

The silent approach worked that time, but it is not clear that it's always the best way to handle confrontational challenges. What should you say or do when someone accuses you of only being in it for yourself?

When I wrote about this (now ancient) story on my blog in 2006, it elicited more responses than almost any other topic I have "blogged" about. As one of my correspondents said -- "Here's a topic we can all relate to."

Apparently, confrontational challenges from clients (perhaps not of this precise form, but in the same "Gotcha!" category) are still quite common.

No matter what your profession, you too, are highly likely to encounter something like this suspicion and distrust in your career. How well will you be prepared to handle the situation?


Why He Did It

In order to figure out the right thing to do or say in situations such as these, it's worth taking the time to try and speculate on what a client executive might be really trying to say if he or she were to challenge your motives in this way.

Among the possibilities are:

  • The person has had bad experiences with previous service providers. He (or she) isn't really reacting to anything you've done or said, but is showing his or her general view of outsiders.
  • It could be a method of "testing" you to see how you react. (Yes, clients do that -- quite frequently.) The client could plan to base his or her judgment of your motives (and skills) on the way you handle yourself.
  • The client might be (appropriately?) annoyed at the person who had brought you in, possible because they had not engaged in the proper consultation and prior approval process. The "complaint" is expressed as if it's about you, but it might really be aimed at someone else in the room.
  • The client might just be asserting his or her power, sending a signal to you, the outsider, the person who invited you to the meeting (and, of course, everyone else!)
  • It could mean nothing more than the fact that the client is the kind of person who has a generally combative shoot-from-the-hip approach.
  • The client might be truly worried about past and current change-related initiatives -- exactly what he or she is talking about -- and is truly trying to address the issue of the need for change.
  • It is also possible that the client is reacting to some (hopefully incorrect and unconscious) signal that you have sent that you do, indeed, have your own best interests at heart, not the client company's.

That's an incomplete but nevertheless wide range of possibilities, each requiring, if true, a different response. (What else do you think might be among the possible explanations for the comment and behaviour of a client in a situation like this?)

In a perfect world, as soon as you are challenged in this way at a meeting, you would have the presence of mind (and mental agility) to diagnose immediately why the CEO said what he did -- which of the possibilities above were actually the case. You could then proceed appropriately.

But only a few of us are born with that skill. The rest of us probably need to prepare for such situations, and think ahead (if at all possible) about what we might say and do that would shed some light on the situation. How do you find out what's really going on?


Say Nothing?

I have asked many people in my seminars (and participants on my blog) what they would have said in response.

Some people think the best strategy would be to say nothing. They suggest that one should just let the comment hang in the air, and let everyone in the meeting feel the discomfort created by the challenger's remark -- while managing your own discomfort. If no one else in the room "takes the bait," then you would still have choices left.

This is a tempting option. In an ideal world, of course, someone else would soon leap to your defence, saying something like: "I've known this person for a long time, and he/she is not like that."

But you can't bank on that happening! (In fact, in my experience, the odds are low that it will.)

Other people would argue that, when awkward situations like this arise, you need to "survive" until the nearest coffee break, lunch break or end-of-day adjournment, and find a way to ask each person one-on-one (in confidence:) "What just happened there? Is that a real issue?"

Back in the days when I was a smoker, I could do this on the pavement outside the building or wherever we sinners were banished to. I've had more than my fair share of hushed bathroom conversations, too.

It is also an option to try to have a closed-door one-on-one discussion with the "challenger" himself (or herself) after the meeting. That would take courage, but at least there would be a chance of resolving the issue (and beginning a more constructive relationship) in a calmer setting.

Reinforcing the temptation to do nothing is the theory that, if you were to react directly and perpetuate a discussion of your motives, it would only serve to reinforce the topic of your ethics, potentially turning it into a real issue.

Among the many goals you might have in figuring out a response, one of the most important is to avoid derailing your discussion of the issues.


Possible Responses

But doing absolutely nothing clearly isn't right, either. At that very moment, it might be tempting to shrink into a small, invisible ball, but that is unlikely to be very helpful.

What response could you give if someone challenged your motives in the way described in my story? When I have posed this question to various groups, the suggestions have included replies such as these:

  • "If you're not comfortable with me, then that's completely fine. Nice to meet you and all the best for the future."
  • "I don't fully know about your past experiences with consultants, but I have your best interests at heart."
  • "I will do right by you, because it's much more important to me that you be successful and that I can build a long term relationship with your firm, as well as use you as a reference to help me grow my business."
  • "A few more billable hours don't mean much to me. I've got a full plate as it is. My success is driven only by your success."
  • "You don't need me. However, as you know, my work comes with a guarantee. I'm clearly happy for you to decide whether it has been worthwhile and whether or not you want to pay me."
  • "I understand if you don't want to, and that's fine -- we're all busy people, so just let me know either way and we can get on with our day."
  • "I only work with clients who provide me with real, as opposed to manufactured, challenges. Generating fake work for the sake of a quick buck wouldn't actually benefit either of us, would it?"
  • "I know this is always a major concern when working with consultants and I thank you for addressing this concern. Let us invest a few minutes to visualise the benefits we want to obtain for your company in this process."
  • "That's not how I operate. If you really believe that, then let me give you a last piece of advice -- for free: find an advisor you trust."
  • "It's my role only to help provide options and create ideas. I'm not here to make decisions for you or to force you into anything"

What do you think? Do you think any of those responses would have "worked?" If not, what would you have considered saying at that precise moment?

Notice how easy it would have been to turn the CEO's comment into an argument, with you and your challenger immediately being on opposite sides. Many of the possibilities given above are both contentious -- implicitly or explicitly -- and defensive.

And by making it a contest, you almost certainly will lose.


Another Approach

It's worth reflecting on the fact that, at least in the situation I have described, the CEO didn't ask a question. He made a statement, one that was possibly (maybe even probably) addressed as much to the whole room as it was to me.

You could argue that, in situations like these, your integrity hasn't really been impugned. It has just been challenged. It is up to you to demonstrate that you can deal with the challenge and then move on. The key here would be to find a way to demonstrate integrity, rather than react to the fact that your pride has been wounded.

If you are capable of it, probably the wisest and most effective way to respond would have been to exhibit a calm demeanour that truly deflected the attack, without taking it personally and without any attempt to defend yourself. (Not easy!)

On my blog, Johnnie Moore commented: "I've been practicing doing this when someone says something surprising (pleasant or not) and I'm not sure what to say. I simply invite them to say more. 'That's interesting. Could you say a little more about that?' This acknowledges the person instead of defending; gives me a little time to think; and often elicits more information."

Another approach would be to ask the CEO if he or she wants to pursue this topic right now. That way, if he or she is just trying to rattle you and has no substance, he or she has an easy way out. If you were to start by questioning him when he was only "joking" or testing, then you put him or her on the defensive. Since he or she can't lose face in front of his subordinates, that's a bad outcome.

If the CEO wanted to talk about it right now, then you could ask for more information about the issues. You could try and shift your role from "advisor" to "facilitator", by asking whether or not he or she sees a need for changes, and then asking for other people's reactions to his comments.

The key here is to stay focused on the problem and the proposed solution -- shifting the conversation away from discussing you, and back to discussing the issues.

Attempting to justify yourself will never work. It's better just to act as if your challenger couldn't possibly be questioning your integrity.

Another approach would be to try to make sure that the responsibility for dealing with the CEO's statement is shared by everyone in the meeting, not just you.

You could ask all the other executives, "Is this an issue that this group is concerned about? If so, should we discuss it before we go any further?"

That would give the other executives the opportunity to express either their agreement with the CEO's sentiments or their assurance that they have no such concerns. And you will get a chance to see which way the wind is blowing.

This approach can, however, be risky. You would have to worry about whose side the rest of the executive committee would be on if you tried to make the case for your honest intentions.

Would they support him -- or you? In general, the odds are against you. Even if they don't distrust your motives, why should they take the side of the outsider in an open discussion?

Worse, what if everyone did feel the same way as the CEO, or even worse again, took his side so as to not offend him?

From that point of view, perhaps the last thing you really want to do is pose the question to the group in real time. Their answers are highly likely to be driven by appearance, politicking and positioning.


Rehearsing

Hard as it is to figure out the right thing to do and to say in situations such as these, it can be even harder to use the right tone and body language that accomplishes the goal that you have.

There is a paradox here. You cannot be convincing about your trustworthiness simply by asserting it ("I'm trustworthy -- honestly!") Accomplishing the goal of being trusted means that we must learn how to handle ourselves in ways that people actually experience our sincerity and integrity.

But to pull this off, we may need help not only with finding the right words, but also with the process of becoming self-aware of our non-verbal body-language. For most people, it will be necessary to rehearse reacting to suddenly challenging situations in order to ensure that they, indeed, come across to others as they wish to come across.

Consider, for example, the advice given above to "let the (challenging) comment hang in the air, and let everyone feel the discomfort ? while managing your own discomfort."

This is not a simple thing to do. How does one learn to manage one's own discomfort? Situations like these call for what I call "adrenalin control" -- the ability to control one's own reactions, behaviour body language and even breathing so that you can respond in a way that accomplishes what you intend.

The most important thing to realise about situations like these is that when they occur, we rarely have the self-control to think and react rationally and thoughtfully. In a very real sense, we are put into a state of shock.

If you are the kind of person who has a track record of picking up on social clues, staying calm in the face of challenge, saying what you mean to say just as you're saying it, then obviously you don't need rehearsal. (But -- boy! -- am I jealous of you!)

Diffusing an emotional situation is never easy, and few of us know exactly how to do it. Even those who can are not always able to describe how they do it.

Other people need practice and tips on these things. I think helping "non-naturals" with their emotional skills (or whatever you want to call it) is an important thing that firms can help their people with (at any age.)

Some people have a concern that it might be artificial to try to anticipate situations such as these, and to have a pocket full of what they (pejoratively) call "semi-canned responses."

Personally, I think there is no inherent virtue in trying to "think on your feet" if you are not very good at it. Planned responses are a huge problem if your intent is to mislead. But good intentions alone do not mean that you will succeed in leaving the right impression. You need to ensure that you know how to exhibit (not just possess) trustworthiness.

Naturally, there can be a risk that over-rehearsing leads to focus on "the performance" rather than conveying your sincerity. The question of which is the bigger risk (over-rehearsing and being phoney or under-rehearsing and being unprepared) comes down to each person's interpersonal and social skills.

This is, I believe, an important topic, often neglected in professional firm training. In discussing these issues in my seminars and presentations, it is commonly reported that many people feel that a majority of their client "failures" have come from getting the emotional / interpersonal tone wrong.

The simple fact is that no-one ever taught us how to come across as trustworthy. No-one ever prepared us for events such as clients who challenge our motives.

You may not have an experience exactly like mine, but the odds are high that you will be faced with some kind of "Gotcha!" challenge from one of your clients -- something that will catch you unawares.

The good news is that the skills are learnable. It is possible, with guided practice and experience, to understand how you come across to others, and to learn how to handle yourself well in stressful client situations. Experience helps -- but so does thinking ahead and anticipating awkward situations that might -- and probably will -- happen to you.

* * *

My thanks go to the many participants in my seminars and blog who joined in the discussions on this topic.

Tuesday, July 31, 2007

Marketing to Existing Clients -- new client videocast & audiocast

In Marketing to Existing Clients, the 19th episode in my live video and podcast series, we're going to look at four types of marketing and relative R.O.I. probabilities for each. We will also examine why most professional firms choose the least probable investment for their non-billable time.

Audio Timeline

00:40 -- Introduction
01:27 -- Investing in existing relationships vs. new sales generation
02:40 -- Four places in marketing for non-billable time
03:54 -- An R.O.I. comparison of non-billable hours
10:07 -- A real world example of the merits of relationship building as non-billable time
14:23 -- Why we choose the lowest probability marketing actions
17:19 -- Conclusion

You can download Marketing To Existing Clients or sign up to receive new videos automatically with iTunes or other video players. (Click here for step-by-step instructions on how to subscribe.) My seminars are always available for download at no cost.

Monday, July 30, 2007

The Multi-dimensional Organisation

I keep hearing from large, complex firms something like this:

"We have several overall departments in our firm, each with a number of product/service/discipline teams. We also have industry groups dedicated to developing a better knowledge of (and marketing to) specific industries. Recently, we added 'client teams' targeted at increasing the level of service we provide to our best clients. And all of these groupings exist in (most, not all) of our many geographic locations.

"With all this complexity (discipline, industry, key account, local office or region) a key player could (and does) spend an inordinate amount of time in meetings around here. There has got to be a better way to organise our firm!"

I don't have all the answers to this complex problem, but here are some rules I would apply in trying to solve it:

Rule 1: Use different levels of organisation for different things: lots of little teams for client-level relationships, one large central group for administrative services; it doesn't all have to be (in fact, can't be) one clean organisation. As long as everybody at any given time (say in a year) knows which team they are on and what their obligations to the team are, you can have teams of many different types and sizes.

Rule 2: Some forms of organisation are better than others: Most successful global firms are now organised with the following levels of importance. Most important is the target client industry (or "vertical" as people seem to insist we call it nowadays). Before anything else, most people's primary affiliation is with an industry team (or two).

Next comes, any specifically targeted client team. Third (now a lot less important) is to organise by produce / service or discipline (i.e. your specific technical specialty.) Firms need to have highly focused and skilled technical people, but few, in most professions and industries, are still organised that way.

Finally, (and this is a huge revolution from the past) geography is the least important band powerful dimension of the complex matrix. Organise (and market) by client or client sector, not by discipline or geography.

Rule 3: It's always better to get people feeling like they are (a) volunteers -- self-selected to (b) small (c) mission-oriented teams. Rather than being "assigned to large departments." (see my blog post from last Wednesday on this

Rule 4. Don't consume the scarce time of valuable people by assuming that "key players" should manage or be involved in everything -- ask where their highest and best use really is. Get key players willing to let other people decide some things even when they're not there. (This is easier of the firm members share an ideology, impossible if they don't actually trust each other!)

Rule 5:. Apply all the well-known lessons of meeting management. For example, never have a meeting without a goal, not just an agenda.

Rule 6: Shut down all committees -- assign responsibility for a task to an individual, charged with the responsibility of consulting, coaching and getting it done.

Rule 7: Adopt modern meeting techniques (everybody has to stand -- no seats)

Rule 8: Use as much use as possible of modern technology tools: internal blogs, wikis and "jams" to get collaboration and participation around issue, without having to meet.

Rule 9: Make sure every team leaders' mandate, objective and accountability is agreed to up-front, and that team leaders receive training in how to be effective coaches.

Rule 10: Pete Friedes' Rule. (Pete Friedes was CEO of Hewitt associates.)

One practice I had was to remind all those who reported to me that part of their role was to have my role in relation to their group. One way was to say that they should wear a CEO hat in managing their group. That change in perspective is significant. They were not to just be an advocate for their group or their people. They had to have a "whole entity" view. If one or two managers didn't exhibit that approach and tried to gain advantages by doing things that didn't serve the whole, I could gently remind them that part of their job was to have a CEO view of their part of the business.

(Peter's a gentleman, but implicit in his remarks are the implication that if the various group leaders didn't take that view, they might be asked to play a different role in the firm.)

Rule 11: Remember, even if you have an ideal structure, there will always be problems with cross-boundary, coordinated behaviours. Beyond structure, you need to examine whether you have the right processes in place, not only better structures. You don't get people to collaborate better by changes the boxes they're in.

And, finally,

Rule 12: Never forget that it's always about personalities: getting the right individual people in key managerial roles is the essential lubricant in all of this.

Saturday, July 28, 2007

Are You Dispensing Useless Pills?

Brendan Gaynor, a trainer based in Ireland, wrote in to agree with my article Why (Most) Training is Useless. He said:

I totally agree with the content of this article. However if we as trainers insisted on only proceeding with courses where the appropriate senior commitment was given we would find ourselves a lot poorer and very shortly out of a job.

I was genuinely impressed by the candid comments. It's refreshing to know that someone in the business does have the courage of his convictions and insists on delivering only effective training. Well done and keep up the good work. It's good to hear that somebody out there is baulking at the wastage.

And I am. If a client comes to me asking for a pill, I'm going to ask to discuss the symptoms, the ailment and the best means of recovery before I agree to dispense the pill. And, yes, that often means that (some) clients walk away and go to the person who'll provide the pill.

I have a hard time selling coloured water and patent medicines, even if my clients have faith in the efficacy of those things. I may not know completely how to cure them, but I don't want to treat them with things that we know don't work. When you're younger and less established, it's tempting to just do what the client asks for. I've reached the stage of my life when I want to help my clients more than that.

Many of us need to address this issue in our work lives. Brendan is telling nothing but the truth (and he speaks for a lot of people) when he points out that if we refuse to participate in meaninglessness things (or fight to make them otherwise) we would likely be poorer or out of a job.

But how cynical can we allow ourselves to get? How much are we continuing to participate in things that we (ourselves) believe have no impact, that (in our own estimation) contribute no value and accomplish little?

I do have more of a shot at having the "courage of my convictions" than most people do. I'm 34, I have an established business and reputation, and I'm at the "have to put kids through school and pay off the mortgage" stage of life.

But I hope I'm not alone in struggling to engage in meaningful things, even if it means I lose work (and I do.) I just want my work life to have meaning.

How about you?

Friday, July 27, 2007

How to Move a Terabyte

My latest article Adventures In Modern Marketing is now up on my website.

The article contains both the lessons I have learned in my own online marketing, as well as the generous and helpful advice I was given by those who participated in my blog discussion of this topic in June.

Among the topics I discuss are:

  • Helping busy people search
  • Online tracking systems
  • Nurturing the core community
  • Helping people help you
  • Gathering input
  • Becoming a more valuable resource
  • Word of mouth
  • Website navigation
  • Serving multiple constituencies
  • Participating in the broader marketplace
  • The role of traditional off-line marketing

I'm delighted to report that, since renewing and committing to my web presence in January 2006, site traffic and downloads have been growing and the results have been quite exciting. For example, by the end of July 2006 (i.e. in six months) visitors will have downloaded a terabyte (1000 gigabytes) of resources from my site.

In plain, non-jargon English, that's the equivalent of 42,000 videos, or 74,898 podcast episodes, or 6,168,094 PDF articles (although, realistically, it's actually a mix of each of those).

I really appreciate the contribution of my blog readers and their generous advice to this success.

Thursday, July 26, 2007

Two More Interviews

There's a couple of new interviews with me on my website.

The first is from a magazine called BUSINESS MANAGEMENT US (Q3, 2006). Here's an excerpt:

"The best way to form teams in a business is not to say: 'you guys are in the same department, therefore you will cooperate with each other', because giving orders like that is just not very effective in human terms.

"However, if you go to your people and say: 'I've got the following six projects that need to be done superbly well in the next year, does anyone want to volunteer for any of them?', then the fact that people all joined in to the same team and put themselves in voluntarily is much more likely to get them to want to get on with each other -- they self-selected to be interested in similar things.

"The trick of it is to unbundle the larger purpose of the total department and turn it into short-term, temporary projects, asking for volunteers, and then at the end of it, when the project is done, you redesign the next set of challenges for the business."

***

The second interview is called "60 seconds with Richard Wood." Here's a snippet of that:

Q: I believe you love listening to music. Who is your all-time favourite artist?

A: The Bee Gees. Totally unhip. In and out of fashion. Determined to keep trying. I can relate.

Wednesday, July 25, 2007

You Gotta Serve Someone

Whenever a superior, a customer or client gives you something to work on, you have their affairs, their reputation and their future in your hands. If you mess up, the embarrassment you will feel is nothing compared to the mess you will land them in. You are being trusted with someone else's baby. Deserve it. Being good is important, being trusted is essential.

You might view a project as small; perhaps a fee at the lower end of what you are used to, or not as exciting as other projects. However, the project could be the largest and most important thing the individual at the client company has handled in his/her career.

It can be difficult to accept the "server" mentality. Dale Carnegie once wrote that "You'll have more fun and success by helping other people achieve their goals than you will by focusing on your own goals."

When I first read that, as a university student in Toowoomba, I was shocked. It sounded like communism, or at a minimum, a self-sacrificing religious principle. However, as I progressed through the real world, I realised Carnegie was right. His principle is actually the vary core of exchange capitalism: I will give you what you want if you give me what I want.

To make this work, you must be sincere in trying to help the other party. It's not just a bargaining process ("You give me this, and I'll give you that, and then we'll go our separate ways.") Human beings don't work like that. We look for relationships, even in minor transactions.

If I hire somebody to do something for me (clean my house, handle my divorce, do my taxes, diagnose and cure my ailments), I don't want them to focus only on the bare minimum of fulfilling the contractual terms. If they do, I'm going to focus on paying them the bare minimum -- and no-one's going to be happy.

What I'm looking for is someone who wants to help me, and will deal with whatever arises. Such a person will get paid well, hired again, and promoted, and referred to others. If I hire you, never forget you're there to serve me. If you're not willing to do that, I don't want you.

Another key attitude is commitment. Commitment is not numbers of hours you work, the sales you generate or the rates you charge. It means placing other people -- the client and your colleagues -- first in your professional life. Commitment means attention to details, not because you might get caught, but because you want to provide the best product or service available and you relish the opportunity to step up and take on responsibility.

It's the paradox of professionalism: the more you put yourself first, the less people want to work with you and the less of life's rewards you get. The more you focus on serving others, the more they want to be with you and give you what you want. People (bosses, colleagues, clients, subordinates) can spot immediately those who bring a truly professional attitude to work, and reward those who do.

Monday, July 23, 2007

Rules of Relationships -- new client videocast & audiocast

In the 18th episode of this series, we will look at two critical aspects of communication in relationships. The true test of good communication is to find the time to talk especially when there is nothing to talk about. You need the ability to ask questions, listen, and -- especially -- remember!

Audio Timeline

00:40 -- Introduction
00:58 -- The ability to remember: the true test of a good listener
02:21 -- Communication and talking when there is nothing to talk about
03:38 -- Conclusion

You can download Rules of Relationships or sign up to receive new videos automatically with iTunes or other video players. (Click here for step-by-step instructions on how to subscribe.) My seminars are always available for download at no cost.

Saturday, July 21, 2007

Pop Music's Lessons for Marketing

There are some mysteries about my hobby -- pop music -- that I would love to know the answer to, because I'm sure that if I understood them better there would be some interesting business lessons:

a) What really ARE the marketing lessons of Madonna's career? How did someone of her (shall we say modest) talents become the lasting global phenomenon she did?

b) Why is there such a dichotomy between "hip" and "professional?" McCartney was always clearly the most talented musically, but he could never approach the reverence that Lennon achieved thorough his "attitude" and "persona."

c) On a related point, most of the (I think) truly talented pop music artists I like -- Abba, Beach Boys, Bee Gees, etc, -- are viewed as terminally unhip, no matter how well they sell. I know that says a lot about me, but beyond that, what does it say about the role of "hipness" in marketing?

d) I like the Eagles, I really do -- but how does one explain the fact that their Greatest Hits volume 1 is the best selling album of all-time (rivaled only by Thriller.)? Does that teach us more about marketing and management or more about musical tastes?

e) So much of pop music success seems to be about "catching the cultural wave" -- which is what a lot of businesses would like to know more about (and which "The Tipping Point" only just touched on.) Has anyone developed any general lessons? Anyone want to co-author the book?

Friday, July 20, 2007

What IF There's No Final Whistle?

Cristian Mitreanu has written a fascinating article called "Is Strategy a Bad Word?" He writes:

What explains the relative failure of most organisations to create effective strategy? Part of the problem ... can be traced to their interpretation of the word strategy itself ...

In war, objectives can often be clearly defined, and so strategy is thought of as a means to a specific end. ... By contrast, sustainable success is not, and cannot be by definition, an end unto itself or a goal to achieve. That is, goal orientation becomes arguably inappropriate when success has to be indefinitely sustained.

Despite this, an overwhelming number of top executives and researchers make extensive use of objectives in their quest for lasting corporate success. ... It is, of course, impractical and probably imprudent to advocate a total ban on using objectives in creating corporate strategy, but it is important for strategists to remember that the more specific an objective, the further away it may potentially lead the organisation from its optimal big picture.

Another person who offers the caution that we should beware taking our business parallels from war or from sports is Charlie Green.

How does your view of how you would make business (or career) decisions change if there were no "end points" and no date- or time-related objectives? What if all measures were temporary indicators on the way, rather than "final scores"?

What if you were aiming to create something that would go, on and on, outlasting even you, with no one point at time being the ultimate stage at which you measured your success?

This is evocative of a biological entity or a species. How does the species act if the measure of success is not a state at any period of time, but the overall health and fitness of the species to flourish and survive in whatever new environment comes along?

Bring it closer to home: What if the whole point of the enterprise (or your career) was to survive, pass on the gene pool and act as stewards for the next generation? What if your business' goal was to give your (business) offspring a better life than you had?

These are not new thoughts: others have written about this "stewardship" approach to running a business (for example, Peter Block although there's a weighting toard the moral argument in his work). Some of these ideas are also embedded in Collins' and Porras' book Built to Last (not built to maximise income next quarter, but built to LAST).

Viewed this way, the right measure for success of the enterprise would not be "net shareholder value" but whether or not you had "left the organisation behind in better shape when you leave than when you inherited it."

The fascinating thing is that I do hear some (usually very successful) firms talk this way, and this approach (related to the One-Firm Firm concept) does, in my anecdotal experience, lead to greater commitment by the members of the organisation, and hence better work and service delivered to customers, and hence superior financial returns.

So, let me try and elicit reactions from you out there, who are probably ahead of me in understanding this point of view -- what precisely do you do differently if you take this perspective? What does it mean for how you manage, deal with clients, employees and others?

Obviously, if you don't know when the final whistle is going to blow -- or if you know there isn't going to be one -- what does that do to how you live your life, your career and your business enterprise? Or as Cristian Mitreanu would ask: what does doing strategy really mean in this context?

Thursday, July 19, 2007

The High Priest's Catechism

Kieran Flatt, with whom I have corresponded, has written a piece about IT strategy in law firms called "Pick a side ... and stay there." Here's what he had to say:

There are a lot of firms out there with something of an identity crisis. Their profits are good but not stellar, their reputation is solid, their key client relationships are fairly secure. Do they choose the path of management theory and use IT to shift the bottom line? Or does the partnership buy into the philosophy espoused by Richard Wood, the high priest of profitability in professional firms, whose simple recipe for success is to focus almost exclusively on excellence ........ with much less emphasis on strategy, processes, technology and management structure than is the norm.

It is a tough call. Either get big and global, rely on good management and innovative systems, commoditise much of your business and slash your margins to compete -- which gives the leaders of the IT department a vital role in driving profitability and running the business -- or just focus on providing good support IT, keep costs to a minimum and expectations low, and let the fee-earners and partners get on with making the money.

While I appreciate being given yet another label to wear ("the high priest of profitability"?) I'd like to offer some clarifications.

First, I think Kieren unnecessarily downplays the variety of roles that IT can play. It's not just (or even) about slashing costs -- the greatest value may be in empowering the front-line professionals to deliver more value. As Richard Susskind's famous Grid illustrated, there are many ways to think about using IT and they are not all large-scale systems available only to mega-firms -- and they are not all about lowering costs.

What I'd really like to clarify, however, is Kieran's description of my philosophy as "focus almost exclusively on excellence ... with much less emphasis on strategy, processes, technology and management structure than is the norm." and "let the fee-earners and partners get on with making the money."

I'd phrase my philosophies slightly differently. If I'm the high priest of anything, here's my catechism:

  1. The main goal of business success is to figure out ways to get better, not to get bigger. That mostly means changing the behaviours and habits of the people who interact with clients and subodinates. Technology can help this, but is only a support instrument, never a substitute.
  2. If it ever comes to a choice between quality and volume, you must go with quality
  3. Strategy is not (yawn) about one more restatement of goals and plans but about permanently adopting new behaviours you are going to live your life by. I'm all for strategy. I'm just against strategic planning, which is nothing more than a diversionary device to avoid addressing strategic issues.
  4. The secret to business success does not lie in enhanced processes and systems but in enhancing one-on-one interpersonal interactions, inside and outside the business. Don't build a system before you have created the desire to use it. For example, you don't get people in silos to collaborate more by providing for the capability of better exchanges of jointly useful available data. You've got to manage them so they want to be team players.
  5. Technology is a wonderful tool to put in the hands of energetic people with focus and ambition. It's a terrible substitute for energy, focus and ambition. You don't hand out sophisticated weapons to people until they understand and believe in the cause for which they will be fighting.
  6. Too many places put in new tools so that the front-line senior people won't have to change what THEY do, -- ie, they pass the task of achieving competitive advantage on to the techies. Firms have taken this approach for a long time -- they would rather spend money on low ROI activities than change personally. They did this in marketing, always looking for something (branding, PR, brochures, websites) that could be done by somebody else, so they (the front-line senior professionals) wouldn't have to change the way they dealt with clients and customers.
  7. Management STRUCTURE is just another excuse to reshuffle the deck chairs on the Titanic -- I vigorously support effective management and managerial processes, I'm just against believing that formal structures, systems, procedures, policies and one more bureaucratic initiative truly represent what management is. The mantra is: focus on changing behaviours, not structures!

So, yes, Kieran, I agree there's an alternative to the "get big and global with innovative IT systems to slash costs" strategy. But it's not to "de-emphasise strategy, systems and management" -- it's to understand what these things really are, and to understand how firms of all sizes can adopt healthy philosophies and practices, even if they don't have the mega-bucks for investment that the big boys have.

And it certainly isn't "let the fee-earners and partners get on with making the money." That sounds too much like a cop-out, do-nothing strategy. The alternative to spending on IT is being vigorously active in helping individual human beings get better at interacting with other human beings inside and outside the firm, in ways that lead to greater enthusiasm, excitement dynamism and profits. (Of course, said that way, many firms will vote for the IT investment instead -- which is my point!)

Here endeth the lesson.

Wednesday, July 18, 2007

Work and LifeStyle Balance -- Can a firm Give Options?

Denise Howell, a long-time blogging lawyer, announced on Saturday that she had been fired by her mega-law firm and used the occasion for a stimulating post about the apparent inability of many (all?) businesses to really offer flexible work-lifestyle balance options to those seeking an alternative to flat-out careers.

Her blogpost elicited numerous comments on her blog and across the blogosphere. Virtually all of them provided sympathy and support, and took business (especially law firms) to task for failing to deliver on the promise of work-lifestyle balance options.

Since it is my normal role to be the provocateur, can I risk (without any lack of sympathy for Denise) exploring the opposing point of view, that it might not be possible for a business organisations to offer, in one firm, a wide variety of personal choices on work intensity?

I first wrote about the issue of shared intensity in 1997:

The importance of having something shared is illustrated by a firm which asked me to moderate a retreat between its two warring factions. One faction was involved in a transactional, high-intensity, premium-fee type of practice which demanded significant dedication including long workdays and frequent weekend work. The other faction had a more small-business, relationship practice where the pace and the rewards were lower. These two groups labelled themselves the "Sharks" and the "Flounders." (These sound like Richard Wood labels, but I didn't invent them -- they did!)

We struggled mightily at the retreat to establish firm policies which would accommodate both kinds of practice. All concerned hoped that differences between the groups could be resolved through compensation system adjustments. Of course they could not, and the firm eventually split up -- which was probably the right outcome.

Neither group was wrong in any real sense. One group wanted the excitement of a fast-paced practice and the rewards that flow from it, and the other was willing to forego high rewards for a more normal lifestyle. Either group could be happy and get what they wanted in a firm of like-minded souls. Neither could live with the other. Differences in intensity could not be papered over with dollar differentials. At bottom, there was no reason for these groups to be in partnership with each other.

(I'll be discussing this example a little more in my new podcasting series on strategy.)

I reported a similar real-world experience:

The importance of shared intensity is also illustrated by my experience working with a consulting firm aiming (they said) to be the "truly excellent and clearly a leading firm". We spent months figuring out precisely how to get them there, and came up with a plan that, all agreed, would work. But then one professional, in front of the whole group, said: "We are all saying we want to be the best, and we agree on how to become that, but are we really willing to accept that much change in how we practice?"

I called for a secret, anonymous vote with the following scale: Vote "5" if you really want to "go for the gold", and vote "1" if you just want to make whatever changes we have to make to avoid ruining what we've got. Or you can vote something in between.

The result? The vote was split between one group with "4's" and "5's", and another with "1's" and "2's". In preparing their strategic plan, they had all acted as if they wanted to be "truly the best", but when push came to shove, half of them didn't really want that much change in their lives. Was either group wrong to make their choice? Of course not. It's each individual's free choice as to what to do with their professional lives.

However, the firm now had a problem. How was it to proceed? One approach considered was to attempt to use the compensation system to accommodate these differing preferences. Those who wanted to "Go for the gold" (and succeeded) would be compensated for their efforts, while the others (who wanted a different lifestyle) would accept the financial implications of this choice. We named this the "Tolerant" approach.

However, the more we explored this possibility, the less feasible it appeared. Even if the right compensation levels could be determined, how would firm decisions on investments be made when there were fundamentally different goals? How well would people of different intensity levels work together? Could one really apply two different performance standards?

The more we discussed, the more it became apparent that to function effectively, the firm needed its professionals to share an intensity level (be it high or low). There needed to be a shared "Social Compact". The firm needed to agree on a set of values, goals, and performance standards and then be intolerant about everyone working to fulfill those goals and meet those standards.

Neither side was wrong -- not everybody has to aim to be world-famous, and not everyone has to make a lifestyle choice. But it is hard to achieve anybody's goals (income, prestige or lifestyle) if you're in partnership with others who do not share your goals. It was no-one's fault -- they were just in the wrong marriage.

Those were my experiences and views in 1997. Has my perspective changed?

Not really.

Please note that I am NOT arguing for everyone working themselves to death. My argument is that a single, given organisation, if it is to be cohesive and stick together, must have a SHARED, common intensity -- whatever that level of intensity is.

It should be possible for all the people who want medium-intensity career choices to leave their high-intensity firms, join together with like-minded people, and run a medium-intensity operation, accepting the trade-offs that come with that choice.

Like most business leaders (who, contrary to popular opinion are not all venal monsters) I would love to believe that a single business entity could offer choice of intensity -- but I'm not sure it can if it is aiming to be among the best in its field.

Can the Olympic team let people decide what work-life balance they want to choose? I don't know the factual answer to this next question, but I'd love to know: can a mission-oriented organisation like the Marines or NASA offer work-life balance options?

Forget "management." In a high achievement context, would the rest of the team (the colleagues and co-workers) really be willing to let individual choices be made, without giving in to resentments that some people are not seen as carrying their "fair" share of the burden? I'm not arguing that such resentments are valid -- but I am reporting that they are virtually unavoidable and poisonous when they do occur.

Is it really possible, as many (including Denise) would hope, that an organisation can offer a Chinese menu of work choices and benefits (take one from column A, one from column B and so on), I doubt the practicality.

I'm reminded of one of the lessons of Jim Collins' book "Good to Great" that to cover the gap implied in the title of the book, it is first necessary to (and I quote) "get the right people on and off the bus." In other words, in you want to come on our ambitious journey, fine. If you don't that's also fine, but we're going there and your either with us or -- you're not with us.

Now, I could easily have got this factually wrong. Maybe it IS possible to both be the best and offer intensity options. If so, I'd love to be directed to real-world examples.

Writers and Performers

Shaula Evans, part of my tech team, spotted an interesting discussion with John Updike, which raised some concerns about the future of publishing. Since we discussed the future of writing books in this blog back in February, she thought we all might be interested.

Apologising for her rephrasing, Shaula says

In short, much of the advice to (published and aspiring) authors in the digital age boils down to: "Don't worry about monitising books. Give books away, and make money through collateral revenue streams."

To which Updike responds that authors are writers, not performers, and not likely to succeed as entertainers.

Of course, you (Richard) have already addressed in your post the reality that those of us who are not already John Updike are not likely to make money through the conventional book publishing and promotion model, either.

It makes me wonder if the middlemen (Amazon, speaker's bureaus, promoters) are the only ones making money here ...

Shaula, I would also relate your comments to the recent stories (New York Times July 17, 2006) about film director M. Night Shyamalan's superior ability at self-promotion. Do film makers need to turn themselves into a "brand" to get their films into blockbuster status? Should we all be taking lessons from Madonna on how to create and market (constantly evolving) personas in order to draw attention to ourselves?

Do these challenges apply also to those of us trying to practice so-called "professions?" Do we consultants, lawyers, accountants, engineers and others have to take note of all this?

I do believe that there is such a thing as marketing with greater or lesser taste, but as much as I want to sympathise with Updike, I think we live increasingly in a pop-culture world where performing and entertaining ARE indeed where the money lies.

And, Shaula, if the writer doesn't want to take control of the marketing, the performing, the persona creation, then, as has always been true in the music business, the intermediaries will write the contracts and make the most money.

Tuesday, July 17, 2007

Carnival of Business #13: July 17th 2006

Today, I'm hosting this week's Carnival of Business. Numerous submissions were made, from which I have selected what I thought were the most interesting (presented here in descending order, starting with those I liked most.)

I LOVED Small Business CEO which describes how a Japanese company is redesigning barcodes to have appealing visual elements, to help with branding. There's a neat video to watch, too! I'm usually a "function over design" type of person, but this one got through to me.

David Lorenzo's Career Intensity has a thoughtful Top Ten list for Superachievers (and actually, for everybody else.)

The Business of America is Business contains an excellent discussion of the ongoing debate about whether the extradition by the US of the three UK bankers connected to the Enron affair is valid. Whether you are new to the story or have followed it all along, there's good analysis here.

Matt Inglot has a really useful post (for beginners) about how to process online payments. I found it very helpful.

Getting Out of Debt has some creative ideas about running a home-based business, especially on turning weaknesses into strengths.

Christine Kane (a musician) writes about having an Adventure Day -- doing something unpredictable and fun. She took the idea from a business context and applies to personal life, but it translates back very easily. A fun and stimulating post.

Money Thinking presents a list of eight questions to ask to determine if your new business idea is a good one. Not the first time I've seen these thoughts, but a good concise list.

Small Business Trend Radio has a 60-minute audio on search engine optimisation for small businesses. I would have preferred the information packaged in a way that didn't take 60 minutes of my time, but there was useful information there.

Debt Free explores the issue of the number of visas issued to allow foreign tech workers to come to the US, making the argument for protecting domestic US employment. Vehemently argued, with supporting statistics -- but he didn't quite convert this citizen who has a bias for open markets.

Blogtreprener describes how, every Friday, he and a group of friends get together to discuss ethical issues. This post, on ethics in entrepreneurialism, is a bit lightweight but could stimulate some interesting discussions in any group you may have.

Sequence Inc reports on the lawsuit against insurance companies by those damaged by Katrina. Does hurricane damage cover flood damage? There's not a lot here that's not been in the newspapers, but it's an interesting topic.

Nubricks.com referring to a US site, talks about (some pretty obvious) good and bad reasons to cash in on the equity in any real estate you own.

RadicalHop.com makes the simple but effective point that there is no such thing as time management -- only self management.

Monday, July 16, 2007

Romance and Sincerity -- new client videocast & audiocast

In Romance and Sincerity, the 17th episode in this series, we will distinguish between two mindsets for winning business. On the one hand you have the development of a relationship through genuine interest in your clients and their business. On the other, you have the one night stand mentality which is about winning business transaction by transaction. Which of these two classifications does your practice fall into?

Audio Timeline

00:40 -- Introduction
01:26 -- Romance vs. the one night stand: two distinct mindsets
02:46 -- Taking a genuine interest in your client's affairs
03:48 -- Human connectivity vs. revenue generation
01:01 -- Conclusion

You can download Romance and Sincerity or sign up to receive new videos automatically with iTunes or other video players. (Click here for step-by-step instructions on how to subscribe.) My seminars are always available for download at no cost.

Saturday, July 14, 2007

Does the Network Work?

Here's an old question that's newly relevant. In a network of operators, how do you tell if the network is working?

The network could be the different offices or departments of a single firm. In these days, when whole departments move between one professional firm and another, this is a highly relevant question. Groups that are shopping around have to decide which networks or "firms" to join.

Or the question could apply to today's "virtual" firms, where professional providers act in informal co-operation with each other over the internet without being legally bound.

Or it could be something in the middle: declared alliances without overlapping ownership.

In any of these cases, there follows the question: How do you tell whether the network is really adding value to its members (especially in comparison to belonging to other networks)?

If you were looking for some possible metrics, here's a few you might consider.

First of all, some metrics which attempt to judge the outcomes or results:

  1. Amount of referred work (as a percent of all revenues)
  2. Joint work (how many client projects involve teams simultaneously from more than one group or unit)
  3. Percent of clients served by more than one group / unit
  4. Percentage of joint proposals won
  5. Take top X clients and ask what percentage of the markets they operate in does the network do work for them (penetration percentage)
  6. Average rate (fee level) on joint work (network is adding value if joint work produces higher-than-average fee levels. If it produces less than average fee-levels, then more joint work by itself does not prove that network adds value)
  7. Average rate (fee level) on referred work (network is adding value if referred work produces higher-than-average fee levels. If it produces less than average fee-levels, then more referred work by itself does not prove that network adds value)
  8. Exchange of methodologies. (How many "tools" developed in one place are being used elsewhere?)

In addition to these measures of outcomes, you could also attempt to measure network effectiveness through metrics which judge "effort"

  1. Exchange of people among different groups
  2. Amount of joint proposals
  3. Amount of shared market research
  4. Amount of assistance on domestic proposals
  5. Amount of joint training
  6. How often is network expertise tapped into?

As I indicated at the beginning of this blogpost, this is an important topic even for single firms. Measures like these might allow the firm to judge its "cohesion" -- the degree to which it is truly acting like one organisation, rtahre than a bunch of separate operators trading under the same brand name.

Anyone got some additional and, especially, BETTER ideas?

Friday, July 13, 2007

Teaching Guts

In a prior blogpost about getting feedback, Steve Farber pointed out that the willingness to seek out feedback on yourself takes a lot of guts. He then asked me if I thought you could teach "guts."

By coincidence, on the same day, I received the following email from Jay Bertram, President of the Toronto office of TBWA, the global advertising agency. This is what Jay had to say:

I know you don't remember me. I was at a seminar you put on last year. Like many, I was thoroughly moved by your passionate plea for senior management accountability. The difference is I actually did what you challenged all of us to do.

Maybe it's because I'm Canadian and we do what we are told to do, but I took your challenge to heart and acted the first day I came back to my office.

I want to thank you for encouraging me to be a better manager. It is because of you that I am making a real difference for my employees. I have never been happier and more productive.

What Jay had done was to go back to his office and immediately ask all his people to evaluate their overall job satisfaction, their feelings about the office and (most critically) their overall rating of him as a leader. As I had recommended, he announced to all of his staff that, if he did not improve significantly in their rating of him as a leader, he would resign.

I telephoned Jay to thank him for his kind words, and to ask what it was that had given him the impetus to act. This is what he said:

It wasn't that I learned anything new, but because of your bluntness and forcefulness, you made me act on what I realised I believed was the right thing to do -- not what you believed was right, but what I believed was right. You helped me contemplate whether I really was acting in accordance with my own philosophies.

You challenged me to be prepared to be accountable. It struck home when you said that many people kept on lying -- to others and to themselves -- when they publicly proclaimed their commitment to standards of excellence or missions for their organisation.

Mostly, you gave me the reassurance that living up to my standards, and being prepared to be accountable for them, was the right thing to do.

You'll all gather that when I do seminars and presentations, I ask the organisers for permission to "not hold back." I like being allowed to tell the truth as I see it, and invite the listener to face up to the "elephant in the room" (the truth that everyone knows but no-one has the courage to talk about.)

For better or for worse, this can be very provocative, confrontative and disruptive. (Not all of my clieents give me permission to take this approach.) But, as in Jay's case, once in a while you get through to people by being dramatic, forceful and impassioned.

As I wrote about in Are You Abusive, Cynical or Exciting? and in Strategy and The Fat Smoker I understand those who are trying for self-improvement, and I understand those who choose not to try. What I don't understand (and don't think works) is to PRETEND to be trying for something without being willing to be held accountable for how well you are doing. I call it lying.

In my consulting and speaking over the years, I have tried various approaches to getting people to get on the self-improvement path by accepting this accountability (including feedback.)

Among the approaches I have used:

  • Making them feel dissatisfied with their current situation
  • Trying to paint a picture of the glamour of the future situation they could find themselves in
  • Helping people see that significant improvement in their lot is actually possible, if only they are prepared to try a little and then keep it up
  • Revealing the hypocrisy of the difference between their words and actions
  • Giving people hope that, yes, it is real-world to operate in different ways

As Jay reports, the most effective way to get people to change, and to accept feedback, has proven to be to cause them (force them if necessary) to articulate what THEY really believe and then to get them to ponder, in the dark midnight of their soul, whether they are truly living up to their OWN standards.