Monday, August 14, 2006

"Values in Action" -- new free seminar

This week's new (free, downloadable) strategy seminar, "Values in Action," asks the question, "Why don't most firms actually live up to the standards and values espoused in their mission statements?"

The answer? Values are what not what you aspire to, but what you are prepared to enforce with consequences for non-compliance. It's one thing to say you believe in something; it's another to be willing to be held accountable.

It takes courage to actually live by the values that you say you believe in. More than the right choice of products, services and markets, strategic success is about living up to your values.

The seminar includes:

  • The right way to handle a "rogue elephant" who won't play by the rules
  • The missing business element: managerial courage
  • Two effective ways to enforce organisation values for long-term success

This episode was based on an article, True Professionalism: The courage to care about your clients, your people and your career. The article is a call to arms, to find the strength and courage to do what we know to be right. The article's lesson is clear: act like a true professional, aiming for true excellence, and the money will follow.

The podcast also draws from ideas I discuss in these 3 articles:
  • Why Happy Staff Are The Key to Success
  • The Only Competitive Advantage in Professional Services
  • Culture Drives Performance: Now There’s Proof

and in these 3 previous conversations on my blog:

How vigorously do you "enforce" your values? Do your people think you live up to them?

Tuesday, August 8, 2006

New Strategy Podcast Episode: "Strategy Means Saying No"

This week's podcast episode, the fourth in my 14-part series on strategy, is entitled "Strategy Means Saying No."

Based on my article of the same name, it points out that most businesses in an industry end up looking the same because they offer the same services to the same key clients, and stress the same client benefits.

They do so because they don't have the courage to accomplish a true differentiation by saying no to off-strategy work.

The podcast includes a discussion of:

  • The key to strategic distinction: the courage to turn away business.
  • Why saying No is hard -- and how to get past the excuses
  • The sincere leader's challenge: convince people you really want change

You can listen to this week's seminar with the player just above this paragraph or download this episode. You can also subscribe to the podcast at my podcast page, or with iTunes, Yahoo! Podcasts or Podcast Alley.

The podcast also draws from ideas I discuss in these 3 previous conversations on my blog:

Have you ever had the experience of working with a leader who had the courage to say no? Do you have any insight to offer as to how an individual OR an organisation finds the "courage to stay the course?"

Tuesday, August 1, 2006

An Entrepreneurial Journey

In early 2002, Geoff Considine resigned from the job he had held for two years:  VP for Advanced Solutions, a firm that provided software and related professional services to the energy industry.  He had previously worked on a trading floor developing and deploying software for trading energy derivatives.  Before that, he had worked for six years for NASA as a research scientist.

Having been trained as a scientist, the transition to the private sector required many major adjustments.  Learning the derivatives trading business had involved lots of new technical knowledge, but learning professional services required an entirely different set of skills.

Some of the most important things that he learned at this job were:

  1. There is a pervasive attitude regarding the primacy of the billed hour;
  2. Good behaviour is often secondary to billing as far as management is concerned;
  3. Clients love a highly responsive services provider; and
  4. Smart people do not necessarily make good consultants.

He was surprised (somewhat naively) by the short view towards maximising billed hours at all costs when firms entered professional services.  His boss at the time pushed him to bill as many hours as he possibly could.

Senior management sometimes rewarded billed hours at the expense of a healthy culture.  This was ultimately at the expense of longevity and health of the group.  This approach also led to the decline of client relationships over periods of years.

On the good side, he learned that clients love a highly responsive consultant.  He started to think about the responsibility of providing people with a high level of personal service (as well as smart solutions) as the ''concierge element'' of his job.

In March of 2002, he decided to leave his job.  The company had 60 or so employees at the time, some very sophisticated software products, and some very smart and dedicated senior people.  There was, however, considerable tension among the heads of the various practices, and Geoff was also stressed out beyond belief.  It seemed as though something needed to give.

He was approached by another firm in the same space.  During this same period, however, several clients that he had worked with contacted him and asked if he was available to work with them in some new capacity.  He had not contacted any of these client firms to tell them that he was leaving, so they really had to do some work to track him down.

This was compounded by the fact that someone at his previous employer had instructed the receptionist who answered the main phone to tell anyone who called that they did not know how to contact him.  He wondered if this was standard business practice.

The long and short of his new situation was that he suddenly had three projects available and a job offer.  Geoff decided to start his own practice (www.quantext.com).

During this period, Geoff ran across my Managing the Professional Services Firm.  This article was something of a revelation.  Further, I responded to emails and even sent a draft of some of my unpublished work.  What Geoff realised as he read my work was that there are certain common themes that run through much of the professional services world, and many of these resonated deeply for him.

The most important idea that Geoff gained in his first year was this:  ''You are there to help, not to be right.''

This single ''Woodism'' is one of the core ideas that Geoff repeats often to himself and when discussing professional services with others.  People hire consultants because they want help with some issue.  You don't need to prove that you are smart -- that is determined when they hire you.

One of the other key themes that Geoff learned from me is the importance of setting billing rates.  As a solo startup, it is tempting to price your services low.  You know that you can make a good living even at low rates because you have low overhead compared to a big firm.

My writing convinced him that this was a bad idea.  Further, because Geoff wanted to leave the door open to joining another firm at some future point, low billing rates would have made him less attractive.

The bottom line is that you have to decide whether you are selling Mercedes or Chevrolet and your price point communicates that.  Geoff chose a path in which he invested a lot of time in developing valuable and unique products and services and was compensated for this investment via keeping billing rates fairly high.  He has not regretted this approach.

My emphasis on always building new expertise and value to share with clients rather than simply selling an existing theme to death matched Geoff's inclination.  The shelf life of intellectual property is relatively short, and is getting shorter.

Trust is always a big theme in my work, and Geoff feels that this is one of the most important issues that I emphasise.  If you make a big sale but lose credibility as a person or as a professional, it will not be worth it in the long run.

Sadly, overselling is pervasive and many a client of consulting firms ended up with sub-par solutions in the last decade.  When Geoff was learning this business, he was told repeatedly that delivering and deploying software that had been not fully tested was simply a standard in Silicon Valley and that everyone understood this.

There are many pressures to get the widgets out the door -- especially in software -- but the basic rule that Geoff advocates is not to ship a software product in a condition that you would not want to be using yourself.  Think of software that goes out the door as having your name on it.

Similarly, he saw many cases where a client was told that a sophisticated analytical model would be used on their project when in fact the model was very simplistic.  While these may be common cases, they often lead to bad outcomes and bad feelings.  Common practice does not make this the right thing to do.

In Geoff's work, he has come to believe that there are three ways to do business.  There are people who are unscrupulous -- class 3.  These people will do whatever they can get away with.  If you sign a contract with these people and they think you won't sue them if they break it, they will break the contract as soon as it is to their benefit.

Many people think of this as shrewd business.  We think of it as wrong.  Don't do business with people you don't trust.  It is not worth the stress.

Next, we have class 2:  people who feel that anything is okay as long as it does not break the terms of a contract or the law.  These people feel that it is good business to push the boundaries of what they can get away with -- as if it is a game.

These are the types of people who will slip ''clever'' language and clauses into contracts to try to gain advantage.  There is nothing unethical about this, but clearly this type of behaviour does not build trust.  You can deal with these people, but read the contracts carefully!

Finally, there is class 1:  people who do business as they want to be treated.  These are people that you trust and will work with again and again.  In both Geoff's and my opinions, life is too short to choose a class other than class 1.

There are plenty of class 1 business people and everyone can probably identify these people.  Class 1 people inspire trust.  No matter how you were managed when you joined the business, the trick is make your own choice about the kind of professional, manager and entrepreneur you want to be.  For Geoff and for me, it's first class all the way.

As Geoff looks back, he finds that all of this common sense is not too common but it certainly has all been reinforced time and time again.  The demands for high quality professional services are such that Geoff feels these are the most important guidelines that he has learned -- often inspired by my work:

  1. Be worthy of trust.
  2. Everyone knows that you are smart -- don't try to prove it.
  3. You are there to help, not to be right.
  4. Be a concierge -- if it needs doing, do it.
  5. Know your business.  Are you selling Chevy or Mercedes?
  6. Develop services and products that are worth paying a premium price for.
  7. Think in terms of relationships developing over many years.
  8. Do business as if you were working with a good friend -- Class 1.

Geoff's firm, Quantext, has now been in business for more than four years.  Geoff's favourite thing about starting Quantext has been building a business around this philosophy -- although being able to ski 25 days a year has not been bad either.

Monday, July 31, 2006

New Business Strategy Podcast Episode: "Practice What You Preach"

This week's podcast episode, entitled Practice What You Preach, explores just what it is that the most successful businesses do to achieve doubled margins and doubled growth rates -- appoint managers who know how to excite, enthuse and energise their people.

The podcast includes a discussion of statistical findings which yield:

  • 9 Characteristics where Successful Businesses most outperform others
  • 9 Most Important Factors for predicting financial performance

You can listen to this week's seminar with the player shown just above this paragraph or download this episode. You can also subscribe to the podcast through my new Business Masterclass podcast page, or with iTunes, Yahoo! Podcasts or Podcast Alley.

In the podcast I present the results of a study of the factors that drive financial success. Surveying 139 offices of 29 firms in 15 countries in many different lines of business, I asked a simple question: are employee attitudes correlated with financial success? The answer, as the podcast shows, is an unequivocal "yes!"

The podcast also draws from ideas I discuss in these 3 articles:

  • Could Happy Workers Double Your Profits?
  • Culture Drives Performance: Now There's Proof
  • Forget Money, Think Passion

and these 3 previous conversations on my blog:

I’d really love to get some reactions to the podcast episode. Did you like it? Did the findings of my study match your experience?

Monday, July 24, 2006

Strategy Podcast Series

Today I've added to my podcast page the second episode (Strategy and the Fat Smoker) of my new series on strategy.

That episode is based on the 2005 article of the same name, while the first episode in the series (How to Create a Strategy) dates back to a 2000 article I wrote. For me, part of the challenge and the fun of putting my podcast series together has been the chance to reorganise material from my five books and other articles into what I hope is an internally consistent sequence of thoughts and advice.

So, in addition to serving those who like to listen rather than read, the new podacst series also creates a new way, not previously available, of obtaining all my ideas on a related subject all in one package.

You can listen to this week's seminar with the player shown just below this paragraph or you can download this episode or subscribe to the podcast through my new Business Masterclass podcast page. You can also subscribe with iTunes or Podcast Alley.

Unlike the two previous podcast series (on Marketing and Managing) which were designed to help individuals in their individual role, this latest series is about the challenges of guiding an organisation. Over the course of the series, I'll talk about values, collaboration, geographical expansion, diversification, mergers and adaptability (not necessarily in that order, though).

Many people have been kind enough to suggest that my ideas apply beyond the boundaries of the professional sectors on which I previously focused, so in this series I have tried to modify my language to be as inclusive as possible.

For those of you who have already experienced my podcasts, you'll notice that I have made some changes to my podcast page to try and enhance the experience. For each episode in the seminar series, there are now "notes for the episode" in which I'll try and include things like lists I go through, so that you won't have to take notes furiously. There are also links to other materials on my site (articles, blogs, videos) that are related to each specific episode.

For the series as a whole, there is a 39-page set of handouts downloadable here. (Actually, you don't need to sign up for the podcast series to download the seminar handouts. And, if you go to that same link, you'll see free downloadable seminar handouts on Managing, Client Relations and Careers as well!)

I have also redesigned the podcast page to allow you to provide feeback by writing reviews on iTunes, Yahoo, and vote for the podcast on Podcast Alley. I appreciate your support and help in spreading the word about what you think might be helpful to others (if you think that.)

Finally, I hope I can beg your forbearance and indulgence (I didn't go to college for nothing!) if any glitches occur in implementing all these changes.

Saturday, July 1, 2006

An Innovative Law Firm

At the time of writing (April 2006), Christopher Marston is 29 years old, and is the CEO of Exemplar Law Partners, L.L.C., the three-month-old, 9-person law firm he founded straight out of law school.

Marston is an entrepreneur, and always has been.  He had his first song published at the age of 12, started a music services company (performing and DJ-ing) at the age of 14, and became an options trader at the age of 18.  After prep school, he obtained his Bachelor's degree from Northeastern University in Finance and Entrepreneurship.

He was a CFO for a technology company, and competed nationally in ballroom-dancing competitions.  He attended Suffolk Law and Business School in Boston, graduating in 2004 with a law degree and a Master's degree in Finance.

Straight out of law school, he spent six months developing a business plan for a new kind of law firm.  As he tells it:  ''What began as intellectual curiosity became in-depth research, which turned into a business plan.''

Like most of his classmates, Marston was not encouraged by what he had heard about the life of a typical lawyer in a typical law firm, and even though he had won many awards at law school, he wasn't tempted to join a traditional firm.

''Lawyers are slaves to the billable hour,'' he notes.  ''By measuring and rewarding billable hours, internally and externally, lawyers are actually punished for innovation -- greater efficiency just reduces the bill to the client.''

Accordingly, using every penny of savings he had accumulated from his previous activities, Marston launched Exemplar Law Partners, opening the doors to clients in January 2006.

Among the innovative practices (at least for law firms) he has adopted are:

  • Billing only on the basis of fixed prices.  Fees are determined for each project by a pricing committee.
  • Exemplar offers its clients a satisfaction guarantee.
  • Exemplar will only hire lawyers with business degrees or with extensive industry experience.
  • Exemplar has been ultra-selective in its hiring, interviewing over 300 people to get the nine people it has.  Among the criteria new hires must have are social graces, an interest and confidence that they can develop business, a team-orientation, and the willingness to risk their own compensation from day one by accepting no guarantee of starting salary in exchange for profit sharing participation.
  • An ''over-investment'' in an experienced management team from non-lawyer backgrounds -- the COO has 34 years' experience in banking, and the Chief Marketing Officer has 15 years' experience in various industries, most recently direct sales.  (''I sought out varied backgrounds for a new, fresh approach,'' Marston says.)
  • A ''No Grinch'' teamwork approach.  Marston says on his blog:  ''You cannot buy a position at our firm with your book of business.  In fact, we have turned several of them away.  We want everyone to work together to achieve success.''

A few of these policies deserve further comment.

When it comes time to work with a client, Exemplar has a five-person value pricing committee (Marston, the COO, the CMO, and two other attorneys) who discuss the parameters and scope of the client problem, resulting in a fixed fee proposal to the client.  No client or job is pursued or accepted unless it uses this approach.

Initially, the firm practices in the areas of Transactional Corporate work, Intellectual property, Real Estate and Entertainment Law.  Exemplar plans to work with outside lawyers in other practice areas until attorneys are hired.

All attorneys, senior and junior, are required to practice law, be involved in business development, and assist with the internal activities of the firm.  Each piece of client work is given to one person who manages the costing, delegation of tasks, meeting of deadlines, and quality of the legal work and service.

On guarantees, this is what the firm's website has to say:  ''We are so confident we will deliver unmatched value in the services we provide that we encourage you to determine what the value of the service was worth to you based on your experience.  If it was less than the price you paid, call us, articulate the shortcomings, and we will negotiate a fair price with you.  What we ask in return is for you to define the unmet expectation, or explain how we could have better served you.  In essence, you will be helping us make adjustments and improve our service.''

The firm has been active in marketing itself from its inception, with strategic media and speaking opportunities discussing the viability of the fixed price business model.  The firm has actively worked at leveraging buzz in the ''blawgosphere'' (i.e., the community of legal blogs), working with attorneys and bloggers who are following the company's progress.

The firm's Chief Marketing Officer says that ''Our personality and approach is more like that of an ad agency than a law firm.  It's progressive, fresh, and not afraid to tell it like it is.''

The firm is targeting small to mid-size clients:  young, growing companies, entrepreneurs, start ups, and fast-track companies.  It also aims at women-owned businesses, and real estate/ mortgage brokers.

On the non-negotiable requirement for lawyers that they must have prior business experience or training, Marston points out, ''It shouldn't matter whether the solution to a client's problem is 70% legal and 30% business, or the other way around.  The key is to be in the business of solving clients' business problems.''

On his selectivity in hiring, he points out that ''I really screen for entrepreneurial attitudes.  I asked people during the recruiting interviews if they were prepared to work for six months without pay in exchange for a piece of the action.  I wanted to see the look in their eyes when I posed that question.''

On his blog, Marston writes:  ''Over the past year and a half we have received more than 600 applicants.  About half of them were just looking for jobs.  We ended up speaking with about 300 of them, half of which were risk tolerant enough to meet for in-person interviews.  Only half of those had social skills and only half of those had ambition.  About half of that group had business sense and of the rest only half were humble enough to roll up their sleeves and build a firm.''

At the time of writing, after only three months in business, Marston is the sole shareholder in Exemplar, but he says that will change shortly.  There is, in his words, ''no class system'' at Exemplar.  Everyone, from someone straight out of law school to the most experienced person, is a part of the same reward scheme:  a salary with profit sharing and/ or equity participation.

He said, ''Unlike a typical partnership, we have severed the relationship between ownership, power, and profits in our firm.  In a typical firm, those with an equity stake have authority and a proportional share of the profits.  In order to have a more corporate-like model, shareholders will not have decision-making authority by virtue of ownership, and profit distribution will bear no relationship to equity ownership.''

''We have two major components to profit sharing:  First is the performance-based sharing.  Our new (non-lawyer) Human Capital Leader will be creating the formula for that distribution.  The second component of reward will be risk-based compensation based on when you joined, function and experience.

Loren Demino, who joined the firm upon graduation from Boston University law school said, ''I joined because there was clearly an opportunity for leadership, a chance to reshape the practice of law.  My family are entrepreneurs, so I found it very appealing.  I'm treated like a full member of the team.  I sit in on the firm's planning meetings and I am expected to do my share of networking in the community.

''Yes, I'm taking a big risk and couldn't do it without support from my parents.  No-one here has yet taken home a dime -- we're all betting that, together, we can make this work and benefit from the profit sharing scheme.''

On his blog, Marston wrote:  ''Most attorneys I know are not happy.  The opportunity to build a firm that can be a win for the attorneys by creating a great work environment and at the same time be a win for clients who are endlessly disappointed with law firm service and billable hours is what drives me to get up every day and do what I do.  People who think Exemplar is about a pricing model have missed the point.  Exemplar is about changing lives … one by one … until we're all done!''  He plans to have 24 people in the firm by year's end.

Marston believes that he is creating a new kind of law firm that will have great appeal to clients, ''because a revolution inside the organization creates the revolution from the customer's side.  Look at Southwest Airlines.  Herb Kelleher states that he hires for character and that organization actively seeks out ''happy'' people.  There is a high correlation between happy people and happy customers and miserable people cannot provide excellence in customer service (professional satisfaction in law is at an all-time low).  Therefore, the key to great client service is to get great people and treat them well.''

One client, who found Exemplar through the Boston legal referral service, put it this way:  ''They were wonderful to work with and really helped me set up and incorporate my jewelry business.  They understood that I'm an artist and didn't really understand all the business issues.

''They also showed concern for me as an individual, frequently asking me whether I was sure I understood and was ready to do what it takes to launch my own business.  Even though the work I hired them for is over, they still call me up to touch base and find out how things are going.''

The president of a jazz record label associated with a music school commented:  ''On a pro-bono basis they helped us with everything we needed to know to get our label going.  They were invaluable and incredibly smart, anticipating lots of issues I needed to think about.''


So, that's a brief introduction to Exemplar.

It's way too soon to tell if the firm is a success.  Marston freely admits that he hasn't yet made a penny from this venture, and, in typical entrepreneurial fashion, has invested his life savings in it.  ''We don't want to make money fast,'' he says, ''We want to make money right.''

It's important to note that virtually nothing Marston is doing is unknown in other professions and industries.  Other professions routinely price on fixed-price estimates, and many entrepreneurial start-up companies have made successful use of profit-sharing and stock-participation schemes even for their most junior people.  Many businesses bring in veterans from other industries to run their marketing and financial operations.

What's remarkable about Marston's initiative (and it is remarkable) is not his creativity, but his courage.  He has taken numerous topics that have been extensively discussed for decades in his profession (the weaknesses of billing by the hour, for example) and he's doing more than dabbling -- he has committed himself and his firm to living the new vision.  He's betting not only his life savings, but his career on this vision, and seems to have persuaded an increasing number of people to do the same.

In Built to Last James Collins and Jerry Porras pointed out that ''Walt Disney's greatest creation wasn't Mickey Mouse, but the Walt Disney Company.''  In other words, the greatest accomplishment in innovation may not be any one thing that a company tries, but the fact that it can create a culture that is capable of innovating, again and again.

If Marston succeeds his start-up phase, he may be well on the way to doing just that.

As one observer commented:  ''Marston is not making the usual (repetitive) law firm claims that he has the best lawyers around, or that his clients will always win.  He's saying 'What makes us different, even unique, is that you, the client, are our entire focus, and everything we do is tailored for your service, satisfaction and convenience.'  He's gambling that there are paying clients with interesting work for whom service is without doubt the primary consideration.  And he's gambling that there are good lawyers who want to join a firm to do just that.''

So, here are the questions for all of us to contemplate:

  • If you were a client, would you hire this firm?
  • If you were a young law school graduate, would you join this firm?
  • If you were an experienced partner, would you join this firm?
  • If you could buy a piece of equity in this firm, would you do so?
  • If you competed against this firm, what would you worry about?
  • If you wanted Marston to succeed, what's the one piece of advice you would give him?
  • Exemplar is currently targeting small and midsize clients.  Do you think that, if it gets established, it will be able to compete for work currently being done by the large corporate law firms?  Should they be worrying now?
  • Finally, where do you think this firm is going to be in 5 years time?

Some Good Advice

by Andrew Heathcote 2006

From Business Review Weekly, 2006.

Times are buoyant for Australia's accountants, but there is room for improvement in defining their roles, marketing and building relationships with their clients.

As the country's leading consultant to professional-services firms, Richard Wood is well placed to comment on the state of Australian accounting firms. He does not pull his punches. Wood is a doyen to many local firms and practice management consultants and his advice does not come cheap. Reports suggest he charges up to $2,000 a day to run his eye over a firm.

Below is an edited transcript of a BRW interview with Wood, who was born in Chinchilla but lives in Toowoomba. He discusses the evolution of Australian firms, the dangers of running multi-disciplinary practices, common mistakes in marketing and why many firms are not as confident about their own businesses as they want their clients to believe.


What is your take on Australian professional-services firms?

RW: The honest truth is that I see as much diversity in Australia as I do in other countries. In other words the best is as good as the best anywhere and the dumb stuff is as dumb as it is anywhere else.


Have Australian firms improved the way they do business?

RW: When I first started consulting 10 years ago, there was more mateship around than, say, in the US, which tended to be less tolerant [of poor performers]. It wasn't that Australian firms didn't know better, it was just that they waited to tackle issues until they really had to. But I have seen that change. There is now less willingness to run their businesses like a family.


How similar are the operations of multi-national firms in Australia to their offices in other countries?

RW: They are not really very similar at all. The only firm that really had a very strong "fit in or leave" culture was Arthur Andersen. All the other firms are built on what I call the hunter model. This model says that it is everyone's job to go out and chase them buffalo. And if buffalo die out, chase deer. And if, in our country, a flock of geese go flying by, you don't have to check with anybody because there is no worldwide strategy that dominates your opportunities. Most of these big firms, particularly since the demise of Arthur Andersen, are very entrepreneurial in their approach. They share things such as tools and processes, but fundamentally they are very decentralised operations.


Many professional-services firms try to set themselves up as multi-disciplinary practices. What are the dangers of this strategy?

RW: If you really want to be known for something in the market-place you can't do a little bit of a lot of things. If someone walks into McDonald's and says, "I would like a curry please", you are not going to get McDonald's saying "Let's close down the grill and make this chap a curry". Theoretically they are capable of doing it, but it would be an unwise strategy to say we will make anything for anybody who will pay. It will just result in being very unfocused and not having a particular reputation for any one thing.

But you can see where the temptation lies. If you are running the McDonald's store in Woolloomooloo the temptation is to sell the next customer anything he wants. It actually takes courage to stick to your strategy. I am not trying to say that the firms that do it are stupid. It is a natural business temptation but it will lead to you being unfocused and not special. It takes courage to stay special.


The market for professional-services firms is quite healthy. Many firms make comments like, "If you can't make money at the moment you never will". Do partners think about their own businesses enough when the market is strong?

RW: It is an old trade-off. It is kind of like asking: "Would you ever go to university if you can get a job tomorrow?" If you only judge your success on how well you are doing this year then no one would ever go to university. So, of course, when there is lots of business around the temptation to sit back is huge.

But a good career or business strategy doesn't just depend on this year. It needs to position you well for the future. Am I setting myself up to be able to ride out the bumps?


You mention in the articles on your web site about how firms should avoid one-sided conversations in their marketing. Can you explain this?

RW: Everybody talks about how they want business relationships with clients. But when you look at what they are doing they are not going after romance at all. What they are going after is a one-night stand.

What I have tried to point out is that if you are trying to build a long-term relationship with someone, a mutually beneficial relationship, then the tactics you use are 180 degrees different to what you use if you want a one-night stand. You can succeed at either but you better not get confused about which you are trying to do.

If you truly do believe in the business benefits of having relationships then what you need to stop doing is these quick-hit marketing activities that are all about saying how wonderful you are.


What are the most common mistakes professional service firms make with their marketing?

RW: Let me give you a little catch-phrase. People believe what you demonstrate, not what you claim. If I want you to believe something about me, then I can't stand there and say that if you pay me, everything I do for you will be fabulous. It is just not very persuasive. What you need to do if you want to improve at marketing is to actually do something for the other person. Demonstrate your ability to help by actually helping.

When I go into firms to evaluate their marketing materials, what I look for is whether they are actually offering the prospective client an idea or a suggestion or a piece of analysis that they have never seen before. What is really surprising is how often it is not there. Prostitute marketing, or "once you start paying I'll show you something", is really ineffective. What a lot of firms have to learn is that the best way to market themselves is by doing and not by telling.


Many firms like to talk about how their culture is unique. But how is this possible? What does culture really mean in a professional-services firm setting?

RW: More firms claim to have a culture than actually have one. It is an easy word to throw around. To me, a strong culture is where there are rules about what you must do to stay a member of a society. "If you don't fit this kind of behaviour then we reject you because we operate this way." It is a club with rules.

That can be very powerful in attracting new employees and for operating internationally or across borders within Australia. As a client I want to know that every one in the club will follow the same set of rules so I can trust people in other offices and other parts of the business.

But in order to develop this kind of trust you have to have the courage to throw people out who don't follow the rules. I would report to you that there are very few professional businesses that have that kind of courage. In most professional businesses you are allowed to break all kinds of rules -- if you bring in large amounts of cash.

I am not saying that is immoral. I am just saying that there is a price to be paid for it if you don't have rules that everybody follows. If everybody knows that the rules are optional then the internal trust and collaboration goes away. Strong cultures are very powerful but it takes real effort to create them. It takes courage.


What are the trends in how successful firms are charging clients? Are there more instances of fixed fees?

RW: It depends on the profession. Lawyers keep talking about it but the truth in law firms is that most of it is still done on an hourly basis. I would say there is movement but I wouldn't say it is a revolution. People have been talking about it for decades.


Are you supportive of it?

RW: One of the things that I do, that I always advocate despite few people taking me up on it, is giving clients an unconditional satisfaction guarantee. Every bill I send out says that if you are anything less than completely satisfied pay me only what you think I was worth. My point is that everyone talks a good game but what we really need to be doing is value billing. The trouble with many firms is that they are trying to have it both ways. They don't have the courage or the self-confidence to give a guarantee but want to figure out ways to get paid more. You can charge very high fees if you are prepared to stand behind the quality of your work and guarantee satisfaction. This is very powerful but very few firms have copied me. These firms are a lot less self-confident than they would give you the impression.

Thursday, June 1, 2006

Why (Most) Training is Useless

This article began as a series of posts on my blog. My comments elicited quite a lot of encouraging interaction, so I am integrating and updating them here in a form accessible to a broader audience.

For much of my professional life, I have been paid to do training. It has been very well received in the sense that I have (usually) obtained high ratings, and clients not only paid their bills, but invited me back to do it again and again.

However, I now believe that the majority of business training, by me and by everyone else, is a waste of money and time, because only a microscopic fraction of training is ever put into practice and the hoped-for benefits obtained.

Unfortunately, training and other kinds of meetings and conferences are too often organised as stand-alone events, with a life of their own, disconnected from the firm's progress.

What companies don't seem to understand is that, as I shall discuss later in this article, training is a wonderful last step in bringing about changed organisational and personal behaviour, but a pathetically useless first step.

Companies train people in new areas but then send them back to their operating groups, subject to the same measures and management approaches as before.

People can detect immediately a lack of alignment between what they are being trained in and how they are being managed. When they do detect it, little, if any, of what has been discussed or "trained" ever gets implemented.

A good example of ill-conceived (and premature) training approaches is seen in the many calls I get to put on training programs to help people become better managers. I put my callers through a standard set of questions:

  • Did you choose people for managerial roles because they were the type of people who could get their fulfillment and satisfaction out of helping other people shine rather than having the ego-need to shine themselves? (No!)
  • Did you select them because they had a prior history of being able to give a critique to someone in such a way that the other person says: "Wow, that was really helpful, I'm glad you helped me see all that." (No!)
  • Do you reward these people for how well their group has done, or do you reward them for their own personal accomplishments in generating business and serving clients? (Both, with an emphasis on their personal numbers!)

So, let's summarise, I say. You've chosen people who don't want to do the job, who haven't demonstrated any prior aptitude for the job, and you are rewarding them for things other than doing the job?

Thanks, but I'll pass on the wonderful privilege of training them!

A good test for the timing of training would be as follows. If the training was entirely optional and elective, and only available in a remote village accessible only by a mule, but people still came to the training because they were saying to themselves, "I have got to learn this -- it's going to be critical for my future," then, and ONLY then, you will know you have timed your training well. Anything less than that, and you are doing the training too soon.


The Keynote Speech

Most of the calls I receive about speaking at in-house company events are from companies that want a speech that is entertaining, informative, stimulating, or motivating. What they don't seem to want is anything that specifically addresses the way they run their firms or the real-world changes they are really trying to make.

For example, I recently received an enquiry asking me to convey to the audience the importance of living up to the organisation's "sacred values" (including the need for collaboration). They wanted me to be inspiring.

However, when I asked if I could take votes at the meeting as to how well everyone thought the organisation was currently performing on collaboration and what the current barriers to collaboration were, the organisers were terrified at the potential for disruption. I was not hired for that speech.

Very frequently, the person who calls me to discuss a speech or a training course is a conference planner or someone in administration -- someone who is often the least empowered to engage in a discussion about how to bring about the changes that management desires.

Their role is frequently unenviable. Such people are often (perhaps even usually) given an impossible task: put on a development program that will change things around here, but leave management out of it!

The connection between management and potential speaker can be even more remote. For a few months I experimented with working through a speakers' bureau. I met with their agents to explain the type of work I was willing to take on. I was astonished to discover that this was a relatively unusual request for them -- most speakers and most clients operated on the principle that if the date was available and the date was free, then a booking was made.

There was no norm, it appeared, on either the client or the speaker side, whether an extensive discussion should take place to see if the speaker could be used to further the organisation's goals and fit in with other changes that management wanted to bring about.


Business versus Management

Another problem contributes to the minimal impact of much business training: the fact that it's about "business!"

"Business," as a subject, is about things of the logical, rational, analytical mind: concepts such as "the value chain" or the numerous P's of marketing. Even when it's analysing and discussing people, business is often treated as an intellectual process of analysis and discussion: Maslow's hierarchy of needs, the characteristics of great leaders, etc., etc. Business, at least as it is taught in our business schools and most training programs, is about understanding and knowledge.

These are, of course, both very important. However, managing is a skill, and (as it transpires) has nothing to do with rationality, logic, IQ, or intelligence. Whether you can manage is a simple question of whether or not you can influence individuals or organisations to accomplish something. It's about influencing people, singly, in groups, or in hordes.

No amount of understanding, knowledge or intelligence will help if you are not able to interact with people and get the response you desire. I know a lot about management from my education. That doesn't necessarily mean I'm any good at doing it.

The same tension between knowledge versus skill, and rational versus emotional development, exists in many other developmental areas.

Consider the topics of marketing, cross selling, building client relationships, earning trust, and providing client service. It has not been unusual for one of my clients to use all of these terms in outlining their needs for a seminar.

Yet what a mixture of varying attitudes, understanding, knowledge, and skill needs are hidden behind that collection of words!

Becoming good at dealing with people (inside or outside the organisation) is not accomplished by taking a college course in psychology, sociology, anthropology, or any other "-ology" where people sit around and intellectualise about "human resources" or "market segmentation" but never have to actually deal with a real, live human being.

The same, alas, is true of schools dedicated to the study of business. Business school faculties around the world tend to be made up of men and women whose backgrounds (and inclinations and temperament) are based in things of the logical, rational mind. They are well equipped to teach business, but are not structured to develop skills.

If, however, we really want to help people develop skills, we must view "training" the way an exercise instructor would use that word -- designing a planned set of activities that engage the right "muscles" and slowly build them up through the experience of doing.

To help people develop as managers doesn't mean discussing management (or, even worse, leadership) but rather requires putting people through a set of processes where they have to experience it, try it out, and develop their emotional self-control and interactive styles.

As Bill Peper, a facilitator within General Motors' Standards for Excellence process, reports on my blog: "Businesses often use training as a surrogate for the hard work of true skill development."


The Hard Business of Making Change

The truth is that most firms go about training entirely the wrong way. They decide what they wished their people were good at, allocate a budget to a training director and ask that training director to come up with a good program.

As Ted Harro commented on my blog: "Training is too often used as a (personally) inexpensive way to look like you're doing something if you're a manager. As typically done, it requires little time and little personal change."

Bringing about change is immensely difficult. It requires that managers address questions in four key areas:

  • Systems: Does the company actually monitor, encourage, and reward this (new) behavior?
  • Attitude: Do people want to do this? Do they buy in to its importance?
  • Knowledge: Do they know how to do it?
  • Skills: Are they any good at implementing and executing what they know?

Issues that exist at each of these levels require a different intervention. But note that skills development, as important as it is, is the last step, not the first.

There is no point putting on skills training if there is no incentive for the behaviour; the people don't believe in it and they don't yet know exactly what it is they are supposed to be good at!

The importance of the attitude questions is often underestimated. It is management's job to make people want to learn things by managing the "why" -- helping them understand why this is important, why it is exciting and fulfilling, why people should sacrifice their time and attention to get involved.

If you can be convincing on the why, the training itself can often be trivially easy. When people understand and "own" the importance of a topic, recognising its purpose, meaning and value, and its role in their own careers, they often seek out (and find) the books, the videos, the on-line materials, and the college courses, without the company needing to make any provisions for these things.

In fact, when I do training-like sessions, that's what I focus on -- primarily trying to get people excited about the topic, so they will leave the session actively seeking out the new learning for themselves. However, this only works if they believe that their company's management also believes this is important, not just that I do!


The Right Approach

The correct process in thinking about training would be to sit top management down and ask: "What are people not doing that we want them to be doing? And do we really know why they aren't doing them?"

Then it will be necessary to figure out a complete sequence of actions to address each of these questions:

  • What behaviours by top management need to change to convince people that the new behaviours are really required, not just encouraged? If the behaviour is going to be optional, then so should the training be.
  • What measurements need to change?
  • What has to happen before the training sessions occur in order to bring about the change?
  • What has to be in place the very day they finish?

A full change program would include, at least, an examination of the following:

  1. Scorecards (new, permanent measures of performance being trained)
  2. Coaching (continuous monitoring and follow-up on the new metrics)
  3. Tools (to help implement the training, in place before the training)
  4. Training
  5. Rewards and/or recognition for achievement

On my blog, David G. said: "No manager should ever be given a training budget until they show which business metric that training will impact -- they should set a goal for that impact and review performance against that goal before allocating more training budget to that manager."

For maximum effectiveness, it is usually better to train people in their regular operating groups, so that the training can be action- and decision-oriented, with collective, "monitor-able" commitments. Training classes that are drawn from different parts of the firm force the program to be "educational" only.

Large training sessions may be more efficient, in the sense that they expose a large number of people to the same set of thoughts simultaneously, but they are markedly less effective in bringing about change, and hence, are much less economic.

Training should only be scheduled on topics that can be applied straightaway. Too often, companies give people tools and techniques days, weeks, months, or even years before they'll need them and then hope they will somehow recall them (and perform them!) flawlessly when needed. This is wishful thinking at best.

The best training is usually done by the firm's own practitioners. Although often seen as an expensive use of high-priced practitioners' time, the greater credibility obtained when the firm's own people do the training results in much higher acceptance and subsequent application of the training. Outsiders should be used only to help develop programs and "train-the-trainers."

Too often junior people are sent off to be trained and they continue to speculate whether their seniors or leaders are really committed and serious about the topics being discussed. As previously noted, they often are not.

I was counselling one training firm, which was preparing to bid on a training job. As part of the request for information, its client company had asked the training firm: "What are you going to do to ensure that our managers apply the lessons you teach?" It may have seemed a reasonable question to the client company, but it only revealed the common abdication of responsibility that firms bring to training.

Even if the group leader is not conducting the training, it really helps if the operating group leader attends the training as a participant. In fact, it should be mandatory. This ensures an action-orientation to the discussion and credible public commitment built in to the closing of the program ("We're going to do this!").

Even if the group leader has been through the training many times before, it's good for him or her to be there, because only the leader's presence can lend the sessions the seriousness they need and make the action commitments both practical and monitorable.

To ensure discipline, training programs should have mandatory pre-reading and pre-testing (whereby attendees can't participate if they don't pass). Yes, this sounds like a tough rule, especially when training senior people, but I have seen numerous examples of firms that invested in highly customised programs, designed to bring about corporate consensus and change, where one-half of the participants prepared, and one-half did not. The ensuing discussion was a waste of everyone's time, annoying both sides.

As Cem Kaner pointed out: "Rather than distracting from people's ongoing work, training should be structured to help them improve the quality or efficiency of what they are doing today." As such, participation and preparation should not be optional.

The litany is simple: if it's worth doing training, it's worth doing in a way that's going to make a difference. That means using session time wisely, and that means preparation. If someone doesn't want to prepare, they should not be allowed in the room, no matter how senior. And if your training program doesn't warrant this degree of rigour, then you are almost certainly dabbling and wasting a significant percentage of your time and money.

In 2004, I wrote an article entitled Meeting Goals which tried to make clear that, to be effective, a meeting must not only have an agenda, but must have a limited set of clear goals. Many seminars, keynote speeches and training programs suffer from misunderstanding this issue. Too many companies know the agenda topics they wish to cover, but have thought through insufficiently well the goals they have, and how these goals are going to be met.

The summary is this: If the training has been in regular operating groups, in carefully chosen topics, right when the group can use the training, and with the group's leader in the room, they can immediately begin a discussion of how they plan to integrate the training's ideas into their practices. With the right preparation and follow-up, training can be immensely powerful.

Without all this, it can be (and usually is) an immensely wasted opportunity.

Are Business Schools Ready for Romance?

by Professor Milenko Gudic 2006

From the Central and East European Management Development Association (CEEMAN) in CEEMAN News, April 2006.

CEEMAN is proud to announce that Richard Wood, a leading authority on professional service firms, will be the keynote speaker in the 14th CEEMAN Annual Conference on Creating Synergy between Business Schools and Business. He will talk on "Communication and Relationship Development: How to Improve Mutual Understanding between Business Schools and Business".


In your recent article, you were talking about the differences between the relationship and transactional approaches in dealing with clients, and for the former you were using the "romance" metaphor. In this context, how would you describe the prevailing practices in business schools today, when it comes to their approach to businesses. Are business schools ready for their romance with business?

RW: I don't think many business schools really want a relationship with business. I cannot speak for all countries, but in most places I go to, I see that business schools are still predominantly academic institutions, with scholarly values, not places filled with people who really want to engage with business. Oh, yes, business schools want to STUDY business, but from a detached point of view. Business schools want to be professors, they do not want to be managers. They want to be observers, not participants. Most of them are like anthropologists, studying mysterious tribes, but making no effort to join the tribe.

Business schools pretend that they are preparing people for business careers, but the truth is that they provide a very one-sided preparation.

This is what I wrote in a recent blog post of mine, entitled Why Business Schools Cannot Develop Managers:

As I have often reported, I have every business degree the planet has to offer, and even taught at the Harvard Business School. Yet at the end of all that I knew quite a lot about business and nothing about managing.

"Business" as a subject (and a degree program) is all about things of the logical, rational, analytical mind: Mike Porter's five forces, the numerous P's of marketing, Maslow's hierarchy of needs, etc, etc. It's about knowledge.

Managing, on the other hand, is a skill, and has nothing to do with rationality, logic, IQ or intelligence. It's a simple issue of whether or not you can influence individuals or organisations to accomplish something. It's about influencing people, singly or in groups (or in hordes.) No amount of intelligence will help if you are not able to interact with people and get the response you desire. (Believe me, I have experienced the difference. I know a lot about management from my education. That doesn't mean I'm any good at doing it.)

And of course, this is not accomplished by taking a college course in psychology, sociology, anthropology or any other "ology" where we sit around and intellectualise about "human resources" but never have to actually deal with a real live human being. (It reminds me of the Linda Ronstadt / Dolly Parton / Emmylou Harris song which contains the line -- you don't know what a man is until you have to please one!)

To help people develop as managers doesn't mean discussing management (or even worse -- leadership), but rather requires putting people through a set of processes where they have to experience it, try it out, and develop their emotional self-control and interactive styles.

MBAs are not getting the right education for management, although in developing their analytical skills the business schools are perfect for developing consultants, investment bankers and other professionals, as evidenced by where their graduates actually go. Henry Mintzberg, a professor at McGill has recently published a book -- Managers not MBAs -- which makes many related points.


What does it take for business schools to develop romance with business? Do they have to be "romantic" also internally. If yes, how?

RW: My original article contrasted relationships with transactions, which can be viewed as long-term interdependence versus loose temporary affiliations.

Business schools, like all university departments, are not created from people who want inter-dependency. Faculty in universities are not really wedded to their colleagues -- each is encouraged to be an intellectual entrepreneur, each developing his or her own intellectual capital. There is rarely a department-wide or school-wide point of view, because the faculty would hate that. Faculty want independence, not relationships. We are choosing for business school faculty people who absolutely do not want to be tied into an organisation which imposes common obligations, common purpose and common mission. Yet we ask these people to study and teach about organisations that need exactly that!

Similarly, there is not relationship with students or executive education. There are only short-term transactions with undergraduate, MBA or executive audiences. There is no real pretense at long-term relationships at most places. Maybe one or two in the world, but the truth is that these are marriages of convenience. We'll pay you our fees and pretend to listen to you if you'll give us the rubber stamp of your qualification.


In the last CEEMAN Deans and Directors Meeting on the Challenges and Methods do Faculty Development, when we discussed what kind of faculty students appreciate we heard an expression that you also frequently quote: people do not care how much you know, until they know how much you care. The question is whether the concept of care is related only to individuals, or it could be also something that schools as institutions could and should embrace.

RW: Yes institutions can care, if there is clarity about who you are truly trying to serve, and a real commitment to do that. That's what REAL missions are about. However, scholars are not committed to serve anyone, except maybe their intellectual peers. It would be theoretically possible to imagine a business school that truly lived up to its mission, but I have never seen one. Like most organisations, business schools know what they say they SHOULD be committed to (excellence, teaching, serve the community, provide practical business advice) but they don't enforce these standards. Or they don't enforce them at a high level. Mostly, you can keep your job as long as you don't actually mess up.


Large businesses have been increasingly developing their own internal education and training, including corporate universities. On the other hand, in the context of the increasing competitiveness in the globalising business education industry, schools have been "corporatising" themselves. What kind of challenges and/or opportunities these trends offer for the development of a real romance that business schools and business should strive for?

RW: Many large professional firms, in an attempt to develop their own managers, are linking up with prominent business schools to train their partners in management. The partners may be learning about business, but when it comes to managing it's a case of the blind leading the blind. If you want to get experience (or even understanding) of how people actually respond and function, individually and in groups, it's not clear that a group of scholars who are super-intelligent but have never actually managed anyone are the best providers of that service. Firms would be better off hiring the Dale Carnegie trainers.

But such approaches remain the exception rather than the rule, and, I suspect, are still being designed and conducted by faculty who were specifically selected for their interest in things of the mind -- intellectuals who predisposition is to draw analytical lessons from the experience, rather than to help people hone practical skills. Business schools are becoming MORE scholarly places as the years go by, not less.

I'm not saying business schools don't do wonderful things for people (and perhaps to them.) I'm very grateful for what my education did for me, and proud of the institutions I was affiliated with. I just don't think any of it had anything to do with making me a better manager -- or much of one at all.

As Coert Visser pointed out on my blog, Jeffrey Pfeffer has provided some additional reasons which explain why many MBA graduates often don't turn out to be great managers. One of those is that economic theories and models have a too dominant position in MBA's in particular and in management science and education in general. Many authors, like Jeffrey Pfeffer, Daniel Kahneman and Robert Frank have shown that many of the economics theories and practices are based on faulty premises about human behaviour. Management education needs better theories!

Peter FRIEDES said on my blog that there are two fundamental skills that managers need to have to be effective. The skill to Relate to their employees and the skill to require of their employees. Relating includes the skills to Ask, Listen, Include, Coach and Encourage. The Requiring skills include the ability to focus on goals, Declare, Insist, Control and Confront. If a manager has both sets of skills, and a reasonable sense of when to use each set, they will be a good manager. Almost no schools teach the Relating skills.

(Peter Friedes, the ex-CEO of Hewitt Associates, wrote a FABULOUS and PRACTICAL book called 'The 2R Manager". I still think it is essential reading for anyone taking on a managerial role.)

There's a lot that business schools COULD be, but I don't think the current faculty in most places have what it takes to go there, because they don't WANT to go there. They are (terrific) scholars, not people who really want to engage with the world.

Monday, May 1, 2006

Strategy Means Saying "No"

I was helping a prominent global company explore the strategy of achieving high levels of client service. We were discussing ways of investing resources and redesigning processes to accomplish this goal. The longer the discussion continued, the more uncomfortable some members of the organisation became.

"But what about the clients and customers who don't want all this high-touch contact?" they asked me. "What are we supposed to do with them? Won't we scare away a significant portion of our current customer base by doing things they don't want?"

"Yes, you will," I replied. "A strategy is not just choosing a target market, but is about actually designing an operation that will consistently deliver the superior client benefits you claim to provide.

"However, each decision you make to be more effective at delivering the preferences of those you target will (inevitably, inescapably, unavoidably) make you less attractive to clients or market segments that look for different benefits.

"But consider the alternative," I continued. "You could try to design your operations to meet a wide variety of preferences and needs, serving each client or customer group differently, according to their individual wishes.

"Your market appeal will then come down to 'tell us what you want us to do for you and we'll do that. We'll do something different for other people tomorrow!'

"You may get by with this approach, but you will be unlikely to achieve a competitive differentiation or reputation, except as people who, as long as they are getting paid, will do anything for anyone. Which is not an image I think you want to have."

Finally, someone said out loud what was on everybody's mind: "But do we have the courage to turn away business? Do we really have the confidence to tell paying customers that we are not right for them?"

My answer? "Not only should you do that, but the only way you can achieve any strategic distinction is to do that. Strategy is deciding whose business you are going to turn away."


The Focused Factory

One of the first lessons I was taught at business school was Wickham Skinner's principle of the "focused factory." No operation, Professor Skinner pointed out, can be good at everything simultaneously.

An operation designed to provide the highest quality is unlikely to be the one that achieves the lowest cost, and one that can respond to a wide variety of customised requests will be unlikely to provide fast response and turnaround. Any business that tried to deliver all four virtues of quality, cost, variety and speed would be doomed to failure.

This is not just an operational point, but a marketing one. To be differentiated in the eyes of the marketplace, you have to be known for something in particular. It's not enough just to be known. (That's name awareness, which is not the same thing as being seen as differentiated.) And you can't have a reputation for being something specific if you only do it occasionally.

The very essence of having a strategy is being selective about choosing the criteria on which a firm wishes to compete, and then being creative and disciplined in designing an operation that is finely tuned to deliver those particular virtues.

Consider McDonalds. For any customer that truly places a premium on low cost and speed, McDonalds is hard to beat, because it has been optimised around a clear market positioning.

However, if someone were to walk into a McDonald's and say, "I feel like having a curry today," the service provider would not reply "Sure. That will increase our revenues. Let me shut down the grill and make you one."

Instead, the reply (except, perhaps, in India) would be, "I'm sorry, but we are not designed to meet every possible need. Perhaps I can help you find somewhere nearby that can give you what you want?"

As companies keep discovering to their cost, it is certain business decay if you try to please all possible market segments. The broader the group of clients to which you try to appeal, or the wider the range of services you try to provide, the less customised your operation can be to each segment within that group.

If you never say "no," you will just be one more undifferentiated firm, trying to do a little bit of everything and, as Skinner pointed out, will almost certainly be superb at none of them.


Why It's Hard

As obvious as this all may seem, translating it into reality can be very difficult. The practical reality of most businesses is that they find it very difficult to say "no" to a revenue-generating opportunity.

As Dick Tyler, managing partner of UK law firm Cameron McKenna, says, "The hardest thing in the world for most professionals to do is to turn work away. It offends our desperate desire to be liked by everyone and plays to insecurity that afflicts even the best of us. The moment we aren't worked off our feet, we think we'll never work again."

The situation has been made worse by many firms' explicit (if misguided) efforts to transform themselves into "one-stop shopping" operations with extensive efforts at cross-selling additional services to clients and customers.

Too many firms have made growth and size their strategic priority, rather than differentiation. Instead of identifying and executing a clear market positioning, many companies and firms have consciously pursued a policy of "If you need it, we can do it!"

Many have learned the costs of doing this -- a lack of focus and reputation that, while it helps you get more business, may actively work to prevent you getting a reputation for being the place to come for the best business -- the most attractive work for the most attractive clients.

Another concept they taught me about at business school was "the wheel of retailing." Apparently it is a common syndrome that new retail stores often succeed by establishing a differentiated positioning in the marketplace, but are then continuously tempted, in the name of pursuing revenues, into selling an ever-widening range of things to a continually broadening audience.

Eventually, the store ends up looking like every other general store, and is outperformed by new upstarts who go back to the core and establish focused shops with clear, differentiated appeal (and start the cycle all over again).

Staying focused and true to a strategy is something that has always been, and will always be, hard to do.

The hunger for volume (and the use of managerial scorecards that emphasise it) has meant that many individuals and firms are often uncomfortable with (or even shocked by) the notion that, to achieve a distinctive strategy, they will need to turn away work that a major competitor might reasonably want to serve.

"Oh, we don't want to take it that far!" they say. "Our strategy is to emphasise certain things, not to exclude others. If a client opportunity comes along outside the strategic areas we have chosen, we'll serve that client. We're under too much fiscal pressure to turn away cash opportunities. Can't we just develop a clear and crisp value proposition and then let the clients decide if they want to pay for it?"

My answer is that (as I argued in my previous article "Strategy and the Fat Smoker") you can't get the benefits of a strategy that you don't implement, and half-measures are unlikely to work. Strategy is not about understanding something -- or planning to get around to it -- it's about having the courage to make it happen. You can't let other people, even clients, determine the pace at which you create your distinctiveness.


A Personal Experience

When I first launched my consulting business, I was terrified. For the first time in my life, I had signed an office lease, and had my first employee.

I had this dream (more a hope at that stage) that I could distinguish myself from the general mainstream of financial management consultants by focusing on a particular sector -- professional service firms.

However, one of the first phone calls I received was from a car manufacturer who was familiar with some of the work I had done while still a teacher in the more general area of customer service. How would I like, they asked, to provide training in retail customer service to their dealers?

You can see the problem. Did I want the cash? You bet! I was just starting out. But if I spent my time doing generic customer service training for car dealers, I wasn't going to make myself special as a consultant. I would be one more competent guy doing what any number of other people could do.

I had to make a choice. Did I believe in my own strategy and did I have the courage to spend my time making it a reality, or was I sufficiently insecure that I could be tempted away from my chosen strategy by the promise of cash?

I'm not saying the choice was easy, and I'm not saying that I was or am a better (or more noble) person than anyone because I turned the opportunity down and chose to pursue my differentiation strategy.

I am saying that facing such decisions is the very essence of what having a strategy is all about. If you don't have the courage, you will never achieve a differentiated strategy.

And, of course, courage is one of the scarcest commodities there is. That's why it's a significant source (perhaps the major or even sole source) of competitive advantage!


Excuses, Excuses

Even when people acknowledge all this, they still come up with many reasons why they think it is unwise (or even forbidden) to say "no."

Many people worry that it would be perceived as being unresponsive or tantamount to being a bad service provider if they were to decline to serve an existing client on a new need. They think that it would be taken amiss if they said, "We don't want to serve you in that additional area."

This, however, misses the point. What you say to the client is not "We don't want your additional work," but "We are not your best choice for that new need. We can do it if you insist, but you may be better served to go to a specialist who can focus on providing the particular client benefit you seek."

Done this way, you are likely to cement your relationship with that client, not hurt it, because you will have demonstrated your trustworthiness and your willingness to place the clients' interests ahead of your own short-term gain. If you really believe in the power of relationships, having a client that trusts you must be of greater economic value to you than having a group of clients who are always suspicious of your motives.

Thomas Davenport, author of Thinking for a Living, notes "I've seen a number of cases where turning down business actually helped the firm immediately. For example, when some top consulting firms turn down work because they do not think it can be done effectively without the involvement of the prospective clients' senior management, the client's middle managers will often redesign the assignment try to take it upstream to their top managers. So, by sticking to its guns, the providing firm gets more business of the kind that it prefers, and impresses the client with its strategic integrity."

Still many people are unconvinced. "Yes," they observe, "It may be more noble and a good way to earn trust, but doesn't it just allow a competitor to get his nose 'under the tent'? Once you let a competitor start serving your client, don't you run the risk of that competitor stealing your relationship? Shouldn't you work to keep your competitors out of dealing with your clients?"

The first answer to this is that, even if you tried to pull it off, it is actually impossible to keep your client away from all other providers. The typical corporation already uses multiple law firms, many consulting firms, many IT providers and numerous marketing communications agencies. The hope, in any of these professions (or any other), that you can keep everyone else away is delusional.

Secondly, the real-world truth is that you keep clients loyal to you by serving them superbly, earning their trust and making them want to have a relationship with you above all others. A person or firm would appear very insecure and not very impressive if they were seen to worry about the client talking to anyone else.

Strong, self-confident professional businesses who know who they are do not try to do everything for their clients. Ask the world's most profitable law firm (Wachtell, Lipton) to do a broad range of your legal work, and they will patiently explain that they should only be hired when you truly require the world's experts in their chosen field(s).

The same is true of top consulting firms like McKinsey. Almost certainly, in the course of their strategy work, they will uncover the need for say, training, or market research. Would they attempt to offer training and focus group services, merely to keep other management consulting firms away? Highly unlikely!

"Ah, yes," people say, "It's all very well to cite examples like that, but these are established, successful firms. They can afford to say 'no'. We can't."

There's a chicken and an egg problem here. If you can't afford to say 'no' until you are successful and distinguished, then you'll never be successful and distinguished.

Everyone has an excuse why they cannot make the hard choices, and why they need a special exemption. Small firms claim they should be excused because they are not yet established. Large firms, on the other hand, bemoan the fact that they have a big "factory" of people on the payroll that they have to keep busy.

Young people claim they cannot afford to take risks and be selective because they have student loans and are too junior to decline opportunities. Senior people point to their mortgage obligations, the need to pay the college fees for their kids and so on.

Everyone's got a reason why it's especially hard for them to be strategic and say no -- and most of them are excuses, not reasons. It reflects a lack of courage and a risk aversion.

David C. Baker, who specialises in advising marketing communications firms, puts it this way: "If you are any good at all, eventually you'll have more opportunities than you can handle. Not choosing carefully between those opportunities is far more likely to harm you than the occasional opportunity that slips by because you say 'no.'

"You need to say 'no' to save your energy for the opportunities that are worth pursuing. Entrepreneurs, especially, have a hard time not pursuing any opportunity for learning and stimulation, but the successful ones are really choosy. Don't let panic tempt you."


What Does Management Really Want?

Perhaps the single biggest problem in achieving the implementation of a strategy is the difficulty of ensuring that everyone in the organisation understands what the strategy is, and that top management really wants everyone else to follow it.

In the global meeting that I described at the beginning of this article, someone eventually asked, "How can the management of this firm ask me to achieve a distinctive market positioning while simultaneously pressuring me to meet budget numbers? Given a choice, and there is one, what do they really want me to do?"

If the strategy is to become real, then the answer from management must be, "We want both current cash and the benefits of sticking to a strategy. But if it ever becomes a choice, we want you to place execution of our strategy ahead of meeting the budget. Following this rule, and pulling off our strategy, we'll make more money, not less."

The CEO's message needs to be as unambiguous as Warren Buffet's description (to a U.S. Senate subcommittee) of his managerial philosophy: "Make an honest mistake and I will be understanding, but lose the reputation of the enterprise and I will be ruthless."

Needless to say, few top managers convince their people that this is what they truly want. As a result, strategies go unimplemented.

When helping companies develop new strategies, I frequently organise meetings with anonymous voting machines. After everyone has voted for the strategies they want to pursue, and that they want management to implement, I then ask the question, "How many of you think we will actually do this, will run the company this way, and actually will implement these strategies?"

In a remarkably high proportion of cases, even the most senior vice-presidents or partners indicate that they do not think the new strategies and policies will be implemented. If they are sceptical about the company's own ability to implement its own declared strategy, can you imagine how cynical the employees are?


Creating a New Religion

It is incredibly hard even for sincere leaders to get their colleagues and subordinates to believe that they have changed, and that they will manage to new standards.

People almost never believe this. They just don't accept that there has been "a conversion on the road to Damascus." They never believe there truly is a new religion in place. They always worry that their leaders will, when they are tested with a trade-off, go back to managing the way they did during the prior five, 10 or 15 years. Until they have hard evidence to the contrary, they don't think that management has the ability to say "no" to temptation.

When you think about it, this cynicism is to be expected. Why should people think the leopard has changed its spots? If those closest to the leaders (the rest of top management) often have a hard time believing that the leaders have truly changed their thinking, what hope is there for convincing the rest of the organisation?

Managers must work constantly to act as a countervailing force to powerful financial reporting systems, which almost inevitably fail to make a distinction between strategy and volume: revenues and profits that are obtained by acting in ways consistent with the strategy versus those that were obtained in ways that involve compromises of the standards implicit in the strategy.

The required changes fall into one of three categories: measures, behaviour and personnel.

First, it is necessary to create new scorecards -- built into the firm's regular reporting systems -- that can distinguish between on-strategy work and off-strategy work.

In one firm, as a piece of special analysis, it was discovered that 65 percent of their business came from only 100 of their total of 4,000 clients, and that most of the remainder were unprofitable.

The realisation soon dawned that such analyses are not very effective if they are only done periodically and in retrospect. Given the will, it was not too difficult to build this analysis into the firm's regular monitoring and managing approaches, making the firm's regular reviews of its results more "strategic."

Firms need to address the question, "How do we put in place early indicators that our strategy is being implemented and succeeding?" For example, any firm could and should examine and regularly report such questions as where it gets its business from, what percent of clients generate what percent of income, what percent of business in each year is from brand new clients and what percent is from clients (or types of work) that had been predesignated as targets.

As I discussed in "Measuring Your Marketing Success," there are also ways to monitor which revenue streams are "building your asset" (i.e., helping you strategically) and which ones are "milking your asset" (good for the bottom line but not moving you forward).

Next, a CEO or managing partner will need to ask what it is that he or she can do personally that will give dramatic evidence that top management is serious about adhering to the strategy in spite of short-term temptations.

Shawn Callahan of Anecdote, an Australian management consulting firm, points out that people will continue to be sceptical while the stories they hear about top management stay the same. It is necessary for top management to do something (not just say something) that is both sufficiently dramatic and sufficiently different from the way that management has behaved in the past, so that people in the organisation start to discuss the story and pass it on to others.

The challenge is figure out what the CEO (or others in top management) could do that would be dramatic and a break with the past, but that would also be seen as credible and not just window-dressing. The answer will depend on the specific company situation, but I often suggest that CEOs and managing partners ask their people the question directly: "What could I do that would convince you that I was serious about sticking to our strategy and enforcing the standards that flow from it?"

It is perhaps sad to report this, but since people are always sceptical that specific individuals have changed, the most dramatic evidence that things have changed is when new people are put in key positions of influence. As one of my clients said, "The only way to change people is to change people!"


The Wisdom of the Ancients

In The Wisdom of Confucius (translated by Lin Yutan London, 1958) there appears the following exchange:

Zigong asked Confucius "What would you say if all the people of a village like a person?" "That is not enough," replied Confucius.

"What would you say if all the people of the village dislike a person?" "That is not enough," replied Confucius.

"It is better when the good people of the village like him, and the bad people dislike him."

This ancient wisdom (Confucius died in 479 BC) summarises what we have said in this article. You cannot and should not try to please everyone. Make sure that the right people like you, and it will be expected that others will not. That's how the world works.

The Only Competitive Advantage in Professional Services

by Coert Visser 2006

from Managementsite, 2006


Let's proceed with a question about marketing. Many professionals don't seem to pay much attention to marketing. But you say marketing is of crucial importance for any professional. Why is that so?

RW: The better you are at marketing, the more control you have over your career. If you are really good at developing business, then you can work for only the clients you find interesting and can care about, and only on the type of work that you find fulfilling and challenging. The weaker you are at winning business, the more you are forced into accepting business from anyone who pays you, whether you respect them or not, and whether the work is enjoyable, developmental or meaningful to you. I don't ever want to be stuck in that situation. I don't think that having to work for anyone who pays because I am desperate for cash sounds like much fun!

People think that marketing is about getting more business. It's not. Marketing is about getting better business -- the work that engages your enthusiasm and allows you to serve clients you like. The better you are at marketing, the more you can afford to say no to things that do not help your career. Marketing is not something you do for your firm -- it's what you owe to yourself. If your readers want more detail on these points, I have written about them many times.

Alas, it is easier to get hired for things you already know how to do, so if you are not careful, you end up milking your existing skills instead of building them. You can have it all -- it is easier to get hired for things you care about by people you care for, and that way you are more likely to get premium fees, too! Your clients will treat you better and give you a better work experience if they think you care about more than just the money they give you. Recently, I wrote four articles which explore the themes of marketing as sincerity. I hope I have been consistent over the years!


I think you have. I like what you say about the essence of marketing. That it is not a matter of just getting more business and money but rather getting more of the right business. While we're on the subject of money, I'd like to focus a bit more on that. Writers like Alfie Kohn and Jeffrey Pfeffer have criticised the fact that many managers focus on financial incentives as the most important means to improve organisational and individual performance. This trend is more and more common, even in the not-for-profit sector. What role do you think money plays in improving individual and organisational performance?

RW: What Kohn and Pfeffer have to say is very important, and everyone should be aware of their work. Another important writer is Jon Katzenbach who recently wrote a book on the importance of pride in motivating people and getting things done. The trouble with financial incentives is not that they are weak tools -- the problem is that they are too powerful and distract attention away from any other factor or source of motivation. They are very blunt, unsophisticated tools that people rely on too much. If you say to someone "Do this and I will pay you" it always ends up coming across as "Don't do it for any inherent meaning, purpose or value, just do it for the money." And the minute people start doing things with no commitment other than to get paid, they do it less well, not better.

The trouble with financial incentives is not that they are weak tools -- the problem is that they are too powerful and distract attention away from any other factor or source of motivation.

The problem is compounded by the fact that it is impossible to include all possible outcomes in the incentive scheme. You end up being required to reward people if they achieve the things included in the incentive scheme, even if they have failed to do other important things that are essential for the organisation's success. An obvious and common example is having incentives for individual performance. Where these exist, people will always omit teamwork, but since you have promised an incentive, you have to pay them anyway. None of this means that you don't pay more to those who contribute the most. It just means that you must have a reward system which is based on qualitative judgments, not explicit quantitative incentives.

It is also important to note that reward systems ARE good at rewarding performance -- they are just not good at creating it. To help people achieve more, it is insufficient just to say "Get there and I will pay you." That assumes that the only barrier to performance is motivation. However, there are many other reasons people don't or cannot perform at a higher level. Maybe they don't know how. If that is the case, no amount of incentive will change things. As I tried to show in my article, you raise performance by managing people, not just by creating incentive schemes.


I think that is a great article. It is the one in which you talked about how, years ago, you had just started your final year at University of Southern Queensland as a student and felt you weren't really performing too well. You described how a senior professor walked by your room and talked with you informally for just a very short time and managed to really get you going in the right direction. Very impressive! What's the essence for you in what happened in that conversation?

RW: There were many lessons, but the key comes down to this: like a good parent, my senior professor was able to show both a disciplined commitment to standards like "Come on, you can do it" while simultaneously being on my side and actually helping me. This duality has often been recognised. The people who wrote the book back in the 1960s about The Managerial Grid called it having both a task focus and a people focus. The authors of Built to Last called it avoiding the tyranny of the either/or. My friend Peter Friedes wrote a book called The 2R Manager where the 2 R's stood for requiring and relating. It's all the same idea. The fact that it's a common thought does not make it easy to do. I used to think that I was getting the balance correct by being demanding on some days, and supportive on others, averaging out -- I hoped -- to a balanced approach. Of course, this is not the message. If you do it that way, all you end up with are schizophrenic people who never know how you are going to behave. The real art, which you have to learn with your kids as well as your employees, is how to be both demanding and supportive simultaneously. It's not that easy to learn if you are not a natural. It takes lots of practice.


Talking about being a natural ... a popular perspective in the field of human performance development is the strengths perspective. The people from Gallup for instance have argued and shown that focusing on strengths is critical for achieving career success. They say you have to identify your talents and complement them with skills and knowledge so that they become strengths. I understand you put the focus more on interest and passion, don't you?

RW: I like the Gallup material very much, and think they have made a significant contribution. To the extent that you are just comparing strengths and weaknesses, I think they are entirely correct that the focus should be on building on strengths, not on correcting weaknesses. However, they would be the first to say there are also other dimensions that determine career success.

My research -- and my own life experience -- suggests that if you were really to examine the difference between who succeeds and who only does okay, what you would find would not be a difference in abilities, strengths, IQ, interpersonal skills or any other kind of capability. Instead, my work suggests that the only competitive advantage is something variously described as energy, excitement, enthusiasm, engagement, passion, drive, discipline, determination or ambition. Those are not all the same thing, but I think they are all facets of the same glittering diamond -- a state of mind that says: "I'm going to try, and fail, and try again, and just get somewhere!"

If you accept that it is the lifelong willingness to keep trying that determines success, in spite of strengths or weaknesses, then it raises an interesting question. Are you just born with this frame of mind, or can good managers create it in others? I'm not completely sure of the whole answer, but I do know that bad managers can and do destroy enthusiasm, passion and excitement. I think the best managers can not only "get out of the way" but can also find a way to uncover and channel the enthusiasm that most people want to bring to their work. Finally, I think that good managers have to have the courage to ask employees or colleagues who do not feel passionate about the organisation's work to leave. There is nothing more certain to suppress energy and enthusiasm than being forced to work with others who do not show it. Because of all of this, management is not easy, but it is crucially important.


I guess this is linked to your point of view that management is mainly a matter of attitudes and principles, more so than a matter of knowledge, intelligence and experience. Why are attitudes and principles so important in your opinion?

RW: A key to my thinking is that whenever I am trying to think through what would work on other people, I always begin by asking "What would work on me?" In this situation, the question becomes "What kind of manager would have the most impact on me, and cause me to stretch, raise my game and perform at the highest levels?" My answer is that before I care about the manager's skills, I would want to know why he or she is trying to get me to do something.

If I believe he or she is trying to help me, then I will accept challenges, listen to input and, maybe, even accept some criticism. But first, I need to believe that the manager is on my side. If I believe that you, the manager, are not here to help me but are trying to get me to do more, or different things only to make you, the manager, look good, or to help the company, then I will listen a lot less, only grudgingly accept criticism, and will be unlikely to be excited. In spite of what many managers think, only a very few people will do things for the greater glory of the company or because I buy in to some institutional vision. It can happen, but it's not very common. So, above all else, managers must be able to convince those they manage that the manager has the right attitude -- that the manager is focused on helping the subordinate achieve more. Notice that this is not meant to be idealistic. The manager's goal is to get me to raise my game and perform more, so that the organisation can win and the manager can look good. There's nothing wrong with the manager having those goals, but that's not the reason I'm going to try hard.

The trick of managing is getting people to do things for themselves that turn out to help the organisation. And if I believe you motives are pure -- you are really trying to help -- I will forgive you some poor skills, some weak language or occasional wrong actions. When it comes to winning my co-operation, your attitudes as a manager matter more than your skills.


Many of our readers are interested in the topics of managing change and executing strategy successfully. These require buy-in from the employees. How do senior executives demonstrate leadership while still letting good initiatives bubble-up from the workforce?

RW: As I have written previously, you can choose to manage the WHAT, the WHY and the HOW -- what the organisation is trying to do, why it is a worthwhile thing to do, and how it can be done. The secret to effectiveness, I believe is that management needs to be very clear about the WHAT -- that means removing too many dreams, and setting do-able, achievable targets. If everyone is completely clear about what the organisation is trying to accomplish, then it is possible to delegate decisions and get hundreds or thousands of people to do the right thing as they do their work. If management has been vague -- or has exaggerated or misrepresented what it really is aiming for -- then what results is confusion. People need management to be clear, consistent and to practice what they preach -- otherwise they don't really know what they should be doing.

The second thing that management needs to be good at is providing a meaningful reason WHY the goals that have been set are worth striving for. Management must be convincing that there is a worthwhile purpose to what the organisation is trying to achieve. If people do not agree with the purpose, they will still come to work, but they will only act in "compliance" with the work rules -- what they must do. This is not enough. If the organisation is to excel at its purpose, people in the organisation must accept that there is a valid reason to struggle, to solve problems, to deal with difficulties, collaborate with others, and all the other little and big things that come up every day.

And, of course, make money for the shareholders is a valid reason, but might fail the test of being a source of great motivation for the thousands who work in the organisation. It's a valid goal, but it's not a very motivating purpose. If you want me to do the things that make the shareholders rich, give me a reason that *I* can believe in to do those things. Tell me what it means to me. Because of this, the most effective managers are those who actually have ideals and principles that other people also believe in and want to follow.

For example, if you say you believe there is a morally correct way to treat customers, and I believe that you believe it, it is more likely to "get me on the hook" than saying it will make the shareholders rich. It turns out, from research that I have done, that the managers who are seen by their people to believe in something -- to have an ideology -- actually make the most money. If a manager has been effective in managing the WHAT and the WHY, he or she does not have to be too specific on the HOW. The rest of the organisation can be trusted to solve problems, and you can tap into the creativity and strategic problem solving of everyone -- and make a lot of money this way!


I'd like to get back to the word strategy once more. Some cultures don't seem to value strategy as much as others, leaving them to react rather than "pro-act". What is the value of strategic thinking in your opinion?

RW: I am not a fan of Grand strategic thinking either for individuals or for organisations. Too frequently, this just results in identifying dreams and visions which change nothing. However, I do believe that every person and every company must and should do something each and every three months, to build for the future. If we do not invest in our future, we will fail to adapt as the world around us changes. So, on a regular basis, it is necessary to ask "what can I/we try next, as an experiment that will make things better and get us more of what we want?" Most innovation fails, but individuals and organisations that don't innovate die. The key is to keep trying something new, making small incremental investments as a regular part of the way you live. It's the difference between strategic thinking (about which I am sceptical) and regular strategic behaviours, which I support.


I like that way of putting it. As a final question ... what are the small incremental steps forward you are trying to accomplish yourself right now. Would you like to share that with our readers?

Very slowly, after 10 years of focusing exclusively on professional businesses, I am experimenting with expanding my scope to other kinds of companies and organisations. I was frightened before about doing this, because I didn't want to become just one more generalist consultant who did a little bit of everything.

But, I calculated that, at age 34, I can afford to broaden out a little. So, I have just done my first piece of work with a non-profit organisation in the social sector, and also some strategy work with a manufacturing company. Luckily for me, my thoughts and ideas seem to apply in those new areas, but I am going to proceed with caution. No over-night revolutions, just steady innovation and continual learning -- I hope!


Coert Visser is a consultant, coach and trainer using a positive change approach. This approach is focused on simply helping individuals, teams and organisations to make progress in the direction of their own choice. Coert wrote many articles and a few books.