Sunday, September 28, 2008

New Case Study Discussion feature at BusinessWeek.com

BusinessWeek.com has a newly launched "Managing Channel", which replaces its popular Careers Channel. Among the terrific new features are interactive case studies which feature a story, a column, two videos, a reader poll and an opportunity for visitors to engage in substantive discussion of a real-life business case.

The very first case study zeroes in on a controversial management decision made by Procter & Gamble CEO A.G. Lafley, who skipped over 78 general managers with more seniority in making a key staff appointment without even consulting the rest of his management team. Lafley says "there was almost a revolt" over his decision. The case study includes an analysis by Noel Tichy, the leadership maven and University of Michigan professor.

It's worth checking out!

Friday, September 26, 2008

How to be a Customer

In the latest online issue of Harvard Business School's Working Knowledge professor John Quelch argues that, as a customer, it is possible to get preferential (or at least better) service from your vendors, suppliers, etc, if you know the right approach.

He lists the following as the keys:

  1. Be Demanding
  2. Be Respectful
  3. Be Reliable
  4. Be Surprising (eg reward a job well done)
  5. Be Engaging.

You can join John's discussion, or we can start one here.

We've had discussions here before about what we providers seek in an ideal client, but would you agree with John's starting list? Do you agree that these are the keys to eliciting better reactions from providers?

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

Dynamos

In this video clip we're going to look at the issue of energy, excitement, and ambition in a different way and talk about the different states of drive that you and I might experience at different stages of our career.

Thursday, September 18, 2008

About Women

I'm still at the Australian Institute of Management Convention. A number of speakers have made a central point: that women are INHERENTLY better leaders than men, or at least are better at the type of leadership that the emerging society and economy requires: relationships, empathy, the long-term view. Again, and again, the point is being made here that numbers, logic, science are "masculine" approaches and are inadequate or insufficient for progress.

Most insistent on the issue has been Tom Peters. he basically said "You can disagree with me on many issues but not this one: I'm right and you're wrong." (To see Tom's arguments, go to his website www.tompeters.com and download his slides. He's very generous in making them freely available.)

Over dinner, I heard practicing businesspeople (and those in local governement) increasingly willing to comment on the ability and desirability of hiring females as opposed to males. According to what I was told, young males are less loyal and committed, harder to handle and are more demanding as employees.

Is it me, or are people increasingly willing to make generalisations about male/female differences? Isn't this dangerous territory? Or is it just reflecting statistical realities? Do you feel comfortable listening to (or participating in) discussions about why women are better/ different than men?

I don't. I'll listen and try to learn, but it feels like the opportunties for bias and gross exaggeration are boundless.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Outcomes and Behaviours

I have just listened to an interesting interview with David Morgan, CEO of Westpac -- Australia's oldest bank and oldest company. (I'm here in Sydney as part of a convention organised by the Australian Institute of Management.)

Among the interesting things he had to say was a description of how Westpac enforces its values. For each person, from the CEO on down to the lowest front-line person, each individual is evaluated according to two dimensions -- what they accomplished (their outcomes) and HOW they accomplished them (their behaviours.) The behaviours evaluated include "doing the right thing", integrity, apolitical behaviour, thinking of the best interests of the bank rather than just the individual's own operating unit, etc. According to David Morgan, the system which feeds directly into a person's remuneration, is a key mechanism for ensuring that the values are lived.

I've heard that GE also has a similar system.

Has anyone out there experienced such sytems (ie lived within an organisation which uses this approach)? How effective is it in ensuring compliance wit organisational values?

Friday, September 12, 2008

How Much Standardisation?

Here's what I hope will be an interesting question for many people. A correspondent of mine wrote in as follows:

***

I work for a firm of about 20 people (15 consultants.) We all work independently, the consultants rarely meeting up -- if we do, it's for training sake. We are sole practitioners at the client site, coaching and leading client teams. Our projects get little or no oversight, as long as the client is happy and we are getting results. We do have "standard methodology", a standard project roadmap, some standard analysis tools, and some standard training presentations and exercises that we use, or at least they are available to us.

Compliance to the standard methodology is low. The tools are typically used, but there is huge variation in the exact project sequencing/schedule and the training presentations. Many of us in the group were hired in from different companies and we have different backgrounds and we all bring something different to the table.

Most of us personalise and adapt the training material based on what and how we like to teach. I think some of the training material is either incomplete, inappropriate, or unprofessional. So, I spend time customising the slides, sharing some of them with co-workers in an informal way, but, again, nobody is really watching to see HOW I do my consulting work, just to see if I'm delivering results (which I do).

Recently, we had a very frustrating week-long offsite meeting as a team. There was a lot of contention and confusion about this idea of standard methodology, namely who defines it? How much standardisation is enough?

A team of four people volunteered to look at the issue of standard methodology -- but those of us who didn't volunteer (or weren't chosen) didn't realise how much power this group would have. Instead of looking at ALL of the variation and the ways some basic training presentations were crafted and delivered, they picked one version and made edits to it, basically ignoring the input that the rest of us would have given.

In our consulting, we preach that standardised work can't be dictated to people -- yet, we're doing the same thing within our group. Can we ever get 15 diverse people to perfectly 100% agree on what material should be presented and in what order? There are too many diverging opinions (and too much history of not being perfectly standardised) for us to all just suddenly get on board.

We're getting very inconsistent and schizophrenic "direction" from our leadership. On the one hand, they'll say "the standard is the bare minimum of content, you can add to it" and then later saying "you must all do the work exactly the same way." Is it enough to have a standard framework that we can all customise to our personal tastes and client needs? Or, do we have to be "consultant-bots" who follow a perfectly scripted program, for the sake of consistency?

I fully believe "nobody likes to be told what to do" and that it applies equally well to assembly workers, nurses, and consultants. If I am told to perfectly standardise on what I consider to be sub-par material, I'll most likely look for a new firm (or start my own). I understand the need to deliver a consistent experience to our clients, but how standard is standard enough from their standpoint? I can handle standardising to the level of "here's what you must accomplish in a 16-week project and here's what you should be doing each week, if all goes well." But dictating every single slide seems like overkill, like standardisation for the sake of standardisation. If we're all getting good results with slightly different methods, isn't that ok?

What are your thoughts? Is this a common problem in a consulting firm?

***

My first instinct is to share the view that no-one like to be dictated to on HOW to do things. In general, as you suggest, the key is to have very solid accountabiity for outcome effectiveness, and then let people do it their own way "on the day."

But let's think about this. Under what circumstances might you argue the opposite? If you're not involved and can look at it in a detached way, then you could observe that standardising the process is exactly what businesses have done for centuries to capture efficiency and get things done with lower cost workers. Does MacDonalds let each outlet decide how to do things? Should they? What about a steel mill?

Now, I'm not arguing that fits your situation. I merely observe that I know consulting operations whose entire business model is built around getting lower paid people to deliver very effective standard methodologies. You and I might not want to work there, but it's not inherently a dumb idea.

Thursday, September 11, 2008

In Memoriam

This is a day to remember many tragedies and losses, and resolve to carry on nonetheless. That's what's expected of us, and it's the best we can do.

Wednesday, September 10, 2008

Think of Work

A core proposition in my way of thinking about business development is that you will have more success if you're trying to market things that turn you on for clients that you are truly interested in. Now this is simple to say, but it appears that it is not the case with the way that many professionals actually come to market. Listen to the following presentation and reactions.

Saturday, September 6, 2008

Why Does Bad Management Thrive So Much?

One of the things that puzzles me and fascinates me is that, according to the economics and competitive strategy I was taught, companies that do things well, are efficient and achieve high standards should (in theory) drive out their competitors who are managing poorly, fail to use resources effectively, etc.

The source of all these reflections is an email I just received from a young professional describing how his firm operates. My question is: why hasn't this egregiously bad management been driven out competitively? How do firms like this stay in business?

Here's the story as it was relayed to me in my correspondent's email:

***

Over the last few weeks situations at my workplace have sent me down and interesting journey of thought. Specifically, I have noticed how distorted our perception can be in the accounting industry.

There was a particular engagement in my sector which was new to us this year. We had one staff member with less than a year experience, one supervisor who has been at our firm for less than 6 months, and a principal who has been with our firm for 3 years but has extensive public accounting and private industry experience. As the engagement went on it became very clear that work was not progressing at a satisfactory rate but nothing was adjusted to compensate for it.

Finally, last week, the young staff member stressed once again that he did not believe they would be able to finish the work on time. At this point the sugar hit the fan! The principal came down very hard on the staff and supervisor and stated she was "disappointed" in their inability to get the job done. For the rest of the week, the principal and another manager from our department stepped in and worked close to 20 hour days to complete the project. I should also mention that both the staff and supervisor had put in 60 hour weeks over the last 2 months attempting to meet the deadline.

I first became upset when the principal threw the staff member under the bus and failed to take any responsibility for the engagement herself. But what bothers me even more is that from the outside, the principal (and the additional manager who stepped in to help out) looks like she saved the day when in reality the engagement "failed" due to poor management throughout. Part of me realises that my youth may cause me to overlook many aspects of the situation but I also know that this has solidified in my mind the up-hill battle that many individuals in my generation will have in public accounting.

Unfortunately, this industry will continue to reward those who sacrifice their time, their family and their lives over those who find ways to manage effectively, and become more efficient. The end result is that current senior management will label my generation as lazy and arrogant (both are partially true). If you tell me that I can achieve success, as my superiors have, by working 3,000 hours a year I would see it as a failure. If I have to work as much as someone else did 20 years ago to accomplish the same results have we really progressed at all?

I always thought that a fun experiment would be to tell someone that they only had 45 hours this week to accomplish their work. I bet we would all be surprised by the efficiencies and innovation that would come out of it. The fact that this profession will permit, and even worse, reward those who work such ridiculous hours exposes a fundamental flaw in the collective thinking of the industry. After all, we are not teaching our young staff to find better, more effective ways to do anything. But rather, we are simply showing them how to put their career before their family and personal life. We do not encourage that people take risks, try something new, or go out on a limb. We take the easy, safe route ... we just work more. In the process we are rewarding many who are poor managers, poor developers and are stagnant in their own development.

Thank you for your time, I look forward to hearing your thoughts.

***

I'd like to hear everyone else's thoughts: How do firms that manage this way survive? Is it simple that EVERYONE is equally bad, so there's no penalty?

Thursday, September 4, 2008

The September Carnival of Trust

Carnival of trust logo

Welcome to the fourth Carnival of Trust, originally launched by Charles Green at Trust Matters.

My job was to choose the top 10 for this month. So, here are some interesting items that I think are worthy of your attention.

Trust in strategy, economics and politics logo

First, in the category of trust in society, the economy and politics, look at Marty Lederman's frightening discussion of The Rosetta Stone of the Detention/Interrogation Scandal, in which he explores the role trust plays in the interrogation of prisoners.

Next, Tiffany offers what she unabashedly calls a "political rant" about the recent Lead in the Children's toys events.

Annalee Hewitz explores issues of anonymity and trust in the use of Wikipedia.

Trust in sales and marketing logo

Alan Weis tells an interesting story about being approached by PR firms to be an expert for the media on the Minneapolis bridge collapse story -- and why he declined.

Then there is Rajesh Setty's advice in his ongoing series on "How to Distinguish Yourself" The latest in his advice series is Watch Who You Refer.

Trust in leadership and management logo

In The Secret Sauce for Virtual Teams, Anne Truitt Zelenka provides a stimulating discussion about how to make geographically dispersed teams function through the use of trust.

Also in the category of trust in managing, take a look at Bruce McEwen (who blogs under the name of Adam Smith, Esq.) who reports on a Harvard Business School Study of an advertising agency that tried to manage through "values", but found it harder than it first appears!

Rob Millard reports on a study in Harvard Magazine about the relationship between Trust and Betrayal in the Process of Strategy.

Trust in advising and influencing logo

Paul Pedrazzi, of Oracle, provides a stimulating explanation of "Why Social Networks Don't Work for Business."

Michelle Golden offers an interesting twist on client portability and trust. She discusses the provocative view that the fact that a member of the firm COULD walk away with one of the firm's clients is a mark of appropriate client intimacy!

Thanks to everyone who submitted blogs for consideration and for those looking for more about trust, the first, second and third carnivals should satisfy. If you'd like to be submit an article for consideration for the next carnival of trust you can do so here.

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

The Importance of Appearance

Back in February, I blogged about my experience being a juror. As part of the follow-on discussion, Penelope Trunk (who has a fabulous blog called "The Brazen Careerist") commented: "one thing I learned is that fat women don't have a lot of empathy and defendants usually try to strike those jurors."

Yesterday, Joseph Dunphy reacted by saying: "On behalf of many, I suspect, I'd just like to say WHAT? Did I really just read that? Unbelievable. That's just terrible."

I understand Joseph's initial reaction, but I don't think Penelope was advocating anything -- she was just sharing her real-world experience that appearance matters a great deal more than we like to admit openly.

For example, last week I was conducting a workshop for a global corporation that had concentrated a number of its in-house services into one "shared services" unit. One service line in particular received much higher client satisfaction ratings than the others. We discussed why, and focused on the traditional client service topics.

During one of the coffee breaks, one of the participants came up to me and said, "The real reason that unit does so well is that it explicitly sets out to hire attractive young women. No-one likes to admit it, but that makes a huge difference." (The unit was in a South American country, if that makes a difference to your reaction to the story.)

Of course it does. I know of more than one top-flight professional firm that takes appearance into account in its hiring of both males and females and gives its young people lessons in how to dress well and how to behave with sophistication.

Should appearance, youth and manners matter? Maybe not, but they do -- a lot. To pretend they do not is just unrealistic.

Yet in many countries this is called discrimination and is legally barred.

All of this raises some interesting questions:

Should more firms continue to include physical appearance in their hiring, even to the point of preferring some ages and genders?

Are we naive to believe they are not already doing that?

Are discrimination laws fighting a losing battle against human nature?

Should I get back on the treadmill and worry more about my clothing in order to enhance my career prospects?

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

Getting Hired by New Clients

In this video clip, we explore how you can win business from a non-client who is looking around and talking to many providers. So this is the situation that may be described as a beauty parade or a competitive bid or a request for proposal.

We analyse it by using a direct experience of my own.

Thursday, August 21, 2008

Warlords and Civil Society

I need some help from the historians and anthropologists among you.

In the history of mankind's evolution, civil society (social collaboration, governed by the rule of law) triumphed in most countries over the warlords (rule by those with aggressive individual force and the willingness to use it.)

But how and why? How did the feudal barons with their armies come to accept the rule of law? How did developed economies come to root out (most) self-serving corruption and establish trustworthy civil servants?

What lessons can we learn that apply within businesses? How do we "tame" the individual warlords (rainmakers) and get them to do things for the good of the firm?

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

Experts vs. Advisors

In the marketing of professional services, you can come across in one of two ways to the buyer. You are either interested in them, or you are interested in their cash. We will show why the former is the key to successful business marketing.

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

Making Mergers Work

A reader offers this anguished cry:

Given what is happening in my firm these days, I felt compelled to blurt out some observations and questions and see if they resonate with you, or whether your audience would care to comment.

I am part of a firm created in a merger with the assumption that the combined skills of the merged entities would lead to an integrated powerhouse. The idea was that some sort of combined/integrated methodology would emerge and we would operate as an integrated entity.

In the following few years, this is what has occurred:

There is not a single instance where the legacy firms have worked together on an integrated offering, delivered to a client. There have been a few cross-sells, but these have been matters of luck more than skill.

Each legacy firm operates as if the merger has not occurred. My group proceeds semi-autonomously, unable to see the value or need to link to the "other" side of the business. Their specialty rarely enters our discussions. And vice versa -- the delivery of their work rarely leads to a discussion with the client CEO about what we can do. We're like two separate islands.

The cultures of the merged firms could not be more different. One was loose and entrepreneurial, the other was tightly controlled and process driven. People from the latter firm seem to have taken over firm management, so we are drowning in process and layers of account management.

Everyone is unhappy. We are now on our 4th reorganisation.

Richard, I was wondering: How frequently do firm mergers fail? Why? If the original value proposition of a merger seems sound, then why does it still fail? If the merger is based upon integration and complementarities of offerings/skills, does it make more sense to simply ram a new integrated methodology down everyone's throats and announce this is the way the new form works, or take an organic approach and hope that a few smart people will make it work and let momentum take over? We tried the organic approach and it has not worked.

Richard, I send this to you not expecting a reply, not expecting you to post this on your site, but more trying to reach put to someone I trust "virtually" (you!) to unburden myself of the pain this merger has caused me and many others. Thanks for "listening."

******

MY reply is this: I first wrote about mergers in my articles.

The key points I made there were as follows:

" 'Alchemy' mergers are based on the expectation of synergy -- the hope that the firm will be able to create something new. However, firms will not do so merely by bringing these (different) specialists in-house (whether through merger or hiring). The key added-value (from the client's perspective) will be the ability to design, coordinate and integrate a variety of diverse specialists. This will place significant stress on firms, as well as challenge their abilities to manage a completely different beast than the one they are used to.

"Another way to think about this is to recognise that on complex transactions, clients need a 'prime contractor' who will take responsibility for the total job, including the management, coordination and integration of a variety of technical discipline specialists needed to take care of the various detailed issues (managerial, accounting, legal, financial, consulting, business strategy, and so on.) The question, then, is who credibly possesses the project management skills essential to be the prime contractor?

"Many firms have merged or acquired their way to bringing multiple specialists in-house. Few have convinced the market that they have created (and can manage) a seamless, integrated service."

So, for me, the answer to the core question posed by the reader is clear. Unless you have a clear formula for creating the new, truly integrated service, don't combine the firms. It's combined services that appeal to clients, not combined firms. And, of course, creating something truly new and valuable is incredibly hard unless it's pursued with passion by the people inside the firm who want to be part of something different. (Which doesn't seem to be the case here.)

It's not about "ramming a new methodology" down everybody's throats. That won't create the energetic innovation that will produce what clients want. A better approach is to form a special unit that dedicates itself solely to the integrated approach (being protected from short-term economic pressures while it does so), so that they can develop and market test the theoretical synergy. If it survives the market test (clients actually pay for it and like it) then you can roll it out.

But, as always, that takes patience. And one thing recently merged firms rarely have is patience. (The Fat Smoker Principle Strikes again: we don't want to incur short term discomfort to get where we want to be tomorrow.)

Friday, August 1, 2008

Friendship Skills and Strategy

My forthcoming book is an exploration of things we all claim to know, but few of us actually do. For example, many firms claim that what distinguishes their organisation is that their people are client centric and act like trusted advisors. However, few of these organisations, when they hire, have programs to select for people who have basic friendship attitudes and skills and few have systematic programs to help their people develop them.

As others have observed (for example, Pfeffer and Sutton in their book HARD FACTS, DANGEROUS HALF-TRUTHS & TOTAL NONSENSE) we should draw upon what we already know from relationships in our personal lives when it comes to understanding business relationships. People and firms often don't do this. It sometimes seems as if, when they come to work, people leave behind everything they have learned about interacting effectively with others.

If you have an active social circle and people like being with you, the odds are that you will have a significant advantage in learning the skills and habits of business development. If, on the other hand, you're a social recluse, you will find it more difficult to convince clients to see you as a trusted advisor they wish to work with.

The way most clients choose professionals is essentially identical to the way people choose their friends. They look for professionals who can (a) put them at ease, (b) make them feel comfortable sharing their fears and concerns, (c) inspire trust in their ability to oversee both the client and his transaction, and (d) prove their dependability.

Creating these feelings in others begins with having the correct attitude -- a sincere interest in others. However, the outward signs of this genuine caring are often conversational and interpersonal skills.

If you want to win a client's business, it's necessary to give the client the chance to talk to you, person to person, about their needs, wishes, and wants. The key is to make it easy and comfortable for the client to share his or her feelings and secrets. In short, if you really want to win a client's business, you must know how to have a conversation.

Imagine a dinner party conversation. What makes a good conversationalist in such a setting? He or she:

  • Has a fresh point of view, but does not try to thrust it upon everyone else
  • Speaks politely and respectfully
  • Tells good stories to illustrate key points
  • Is good at drawing other people's views out and drawing them into the conversation
  • Speaks intelligently on a variety of subjects, but is not afraid to admit areas of ignorance
  • Avoids trotting out well-worn arguments or clichés.
  • Listens with genuine interest
  • Is light-hearted in style, but always respectful of others' views

All of these conversational skills also apply to effective marketing and selling. You may remember to behave this way at a dinner party, but do your client meetings really meet these criteria? What about your seminars, speeches, articles, blogs, and websites?

Is the tone of your client interactions friendly, inviting the client to chat, to think about ideas and to encourage both sides to get to know each other as people?

Suppose you want to be good at building romance: getting another person to work with you to build a mutually beneficial, mutually supportive relationship. What characteristics would make you good at this? Most of us have discovered that whether it is love, friendship, or work, people respond best when they believe that you are (among other things) considerate, supportive, understanding, and thoughtful.

It's worth pausing and asking yourself right now: do people think I am considerate, supportive, understanding and thoughtful? Do my friends and acquaintances? Do those I work with? Do those I manage? Do those I serve? If the answer to any of these questions is "no," then it's worth asking yourself, "Why not? What's the problem?"

The answer is likely to be some variant of the fat smoker syndrome. You know what's good for you, but it takes attention to a lot of detail today to get the reputation that's going to benefit you in the future.

A reputation for being supportive, for instance, must be earned through social habits. And to be seen as considerate, you have to be able to remember information that people share about their lives, proving that you listened and paid attention. It also helps to follow up with skillfully phrased questions about what you were told last time you met. The idea is demonstrate concern, not intrusiveness, with a question like, "How did it work out with that guy you met?"

To be viewed by other people as supportive also takes thought and careful attention to language. It is important to remember that friends don't judge each other. They don't evaluate. They don't point out each other's weaknesses. Suppose that your friend has a child who is badly behaved. You don't say, "Your kid is a little horror!" or "You're raising that kid incorrectly," even though both statements may be true. Instead, a friend could say something like, "Have you ever thought about doing or saying such and such to little Ashley?"

Having the ability to respond with the right phrase in real time takes practice, as do all social skills.

As individuals, or as organisations, it is possible to set out to develop friendship skills. However, like all aspects of the fat smoker syndrome, it requires a concerted effort to invest today in building skills (and relationships) that will pay off tomorrow. Unless they are already naturals, relatively few individuals -- and even fewer organisations -- have the self-discipline to stick with the program. That's why it's a successful strategy for those who do.

Do you know of firms that make a competitive advantage out of all this by selecting for and training these attitudes and skills? Can it be done?

Wednesday, July 30, 2008

Marketing To Existing Clients

One of the biggest ways that professionals and professional firms can improve their marketing effectiveness is to think through and make sure that they are actually putting their marketing efforts in places which yield the highest return.

This is actually not commonly the case. Most firms say that they believe that marketing to existing clients is the best source of new revenue. But when you add up all of the non-billable hours that are spent on marketing you often get surprised that a very high majority of it is diverted to chasing new clients.

In this clip, we examine all of the places that marketing efforts can go. We make some very clear recommendations about where the priorities are.

Blawgworld 2007

For you lawyers out there (and those who consult to them) there is a new resource released today: BlawgWorld 2007 -- a collection of 77 thought-provoking essays from 77 of the most influential law-related blogs ("blawgs").

Handpicked by each respective blogger, these essays provide a window into their blawgs, making it easy to figure out which ones merit your ongoing attention.

You can download the 300 page document here.

You can quickly find essays of interest in BlawgWorld 2007 by using an interactive table of contents. From any page, click on the Blawgs navigation tab. From there, two more clicks will take you to any essay.

Wednesday, July 23, 2008

Rules of Relationships

We all say we want relationships and we want to be good at romance, but we have not all thought through the actions and behaviours that are necessary to create those things. In this video clip, we begin to explore the necessary skills.

Sunday, July 20, 2008

Governement Operations as Professional Service Organisations

Here's a reader question:

I work for a government department that has just re-organised into 30 unwieldy 30 directorates (on the recommendation of a famous consulting firm.)

I have been asked to develop an operating model that might help senior management plan for the deployment of the professional human resource at their disposal.

Our working assumption is that we have something to learn from the PSF model (as set out broadly in your articles) but our project is veering towards a model based on time recording (a sort of "billable time" analogue) relating individuals' efforts to one or other of the broad strategic objectives that our management board has designated as a priority.

I'd be interested to know whether you believe the material in your articles is, in principle, adaptable for a government department where the drivers are in many ways very different. Actual profitability is not one, for example, but cost effectiveness and customer experience certainly are.

Other differences are that we have a much more static career structure where promotion and performance pay are often less important than pride, respect and "public service" as individual motivators.

Nor do we really have the types of leaders that seem to be the prerequisite for the working of your model. By and large they are not inspirational or dynamic strategic leaders, but are, more often than not, managers because they happen to have been in the department a while or have reached a certain level of seniority.

Hence, I'm sceptical about the notion that we can solve our problem of improving our effectiveness by developing another administrative layer of resource management. (I've tried unsuccessfully quoting chunks to them of your article on how managers really add value.)

****

Richard replies: I have always had difficulty with the notion that there is such a thing as one unique "PSF model," if that is taken to mean one clear set of policies, practices, processes, structures and attitudes.

Yes, I did try to offer some generalisations and insights that I hoped (and have proven to be) broadly applicable, but there is no one recipe that fits all situations.

I think the closest parallel I've seen to the government situation is the running of in-house service departments inside large for-profit corporations. They face similar issues that there is a more limited career path, they are often not profit-driven, and their mission is often less clear. If I were you, looking for comparable situations, I'd look at companies that have in-house legal departments, real estate or property departments, shared-service accounting departments, etc.

Using the for-profit model will, I think, be completely misleading. Even in the for-profit sector, some of the underlying assumptions that the traditional model was built on (and are described in my book) are proving to be untrue in the modern world.

Take, for example, a topic of promotion opportunities. In the traditional model I described, it was assumed that the vast majority of people hired at junior levels would want to become "partners", and would be willing to work very hard toward that as a primary goal. As a counterpart, it was assumed that the organisation wanted a high percentage to become partners, because what the organisation provided to its market was the fully rounded, fully developed professional.

You point out that this is not necessarily the case in government: not everyone has the dynamism to want to move up, and top management doesn't necessarily want them to.

Here's my point: that's actually the direction that many private practice firms are going in: Firms are promoting a smaller and smaller percentage of people to partners, because they can show more "profits per partner" by keeping partner numbers small. For these and many other cultural reasons, fewer and fewer younger people feel that it is worthwhile or sensible to compete in the "tournament" to become partner.

I would agree with two other points you make. The solution is absolutely not about structures (reorganising) or systems (time-keeping.) You get better efficiency, quality, morale and everything else by having managers in place who now how to manage. Without them, the rest is truly irrelevant.