Monday, June 4, 2001

Practice What You Preach and HR Professionals

by David Creelman 2001

Appeared on HR.com, June 4, 2001

Richard Wood is much admired for his work on professional firms. He recently wrote a new article, Practice What You Preach, which gives research-validated answers on what drives profitability.


First, tell me a little bit about the research that you did. What did you want to accomplish?

RW: I've had over 5 years of experience, and I counsel an approach that involves focusing on how you treat your staff. Every single time I advise a client they will say something like "It all sounds very logical, but who's doing it? What evidence do we have that it works?"

In the past I've always had to rely on anecdotes. I knew individual firms that were doing things particularly well, but anecdotes only take you so far when you are trying to be convincing.

I've always thought that it would be wonderful to get solid data to test some simple propositions that I have been advocating for many years. I had the good fortune to have a major global conglomerate as a client. This conglomerate owned a large number of different businesses, each of which had a large number of separate offices. It was a wonderful opportunity to collect some data on employee attitudes and financial performance. Then we can ask a very basic question: "Is it true that employee attitudes are correlated in a measurable way with financial performance?"

To my obvious pleasure the answer comes across very clearly: yes.


Is this research really solid, solid at the level full-time academics would demand?

RW: Yes, I think it's solid. I used to be an academic years ago, and have a degree in business, so I'm supposed to know how to do this properly. I think it is defensible as academic-level research, although the article is not presented as an academic study. It's an article for your average line manager, but is based on scholarly, defensible data.


The businesses you studied were professional service firms, right?

RW: Yes, although what also attracted me is that this particular conglomerate owns public relations agencies, advertising agencies, direct mail, yellow pages and other sorts of marketing communications businesses. There was a wide diversity of businesses; it's not restricted to one form of professional service firm. Some of the businesses offer high-level consulting, but others are doing direct mail and are staffed almost entirely with minimum-wage people, and it's mostly a "get the stuff out the door" production type of business.

Another element that made it interesting is that every one of the businesses is part of a publicly held corporation. There's always been this rather interesting question, "Are professional firms different because they are private partnerships?" My article is called Practice What You Preach, because in my years of consulting I've learned that most people know what to do. The basic lessons of good management are not very sophisticated, but it takes a degree of courage to live up to them and not to succumb to short-term temptation.

For example, you may know that it is wise to keep your people briefed on what is going on, but on any given day it can be horribly tempting to ignore that in order to chase a new client.

When I point to examples of people who do have the courage to live up to these practices, people say, "My goodness, are they in public companies? Because when you are in a public company, I am told there's a lot more short-term pressure."

What made this study so delightful was that, within the 139 offices studied, I found quite a large number of managers who were able to manage with their eye on the long term, even though they were in a publicly held company subject to quarterly financial reporting.


It's interesting when you think about how an article impacts practice. It's not so much that you are finding things that will surprise people as that you are creating a way of building people's courage so that they will do what they may in their hearts know is right.

RW: That's correct. I've used this metaphor throughout my career, and I hope I'm not now overusing it, but I talk about a fat smoker. It's a humourous metaphor but it's real, and the truth is that people don't need one more speech on the benefits of getting thin or giving up smoking. Similarly, in business most people have heard the sermons about motivating your people and looking after your clients. We've all heard the sermons. We know what we should do. If I go to my doctor and ask how to lose weight, he'll tell me to eat less and exercise more. Similarly, the advice I give is not necessarily very innovative. The basic advice I give is like eat less, exercise more; that is, do the basics. The reason that business people have such trouble is the same reason all of us, as human beings, have such trouble. It's self-discipline.

The largest part of consulting, and this is very relevant to HR professionals helping within a business, is not getting people to be innovative; it's giving people the courage to do what they should be doing anyway. That's really where the change management added value lies.

To tie this back to where we started, it is very, very encouraging to have a live example of somebody who's actually doing these sorts of things. In the article, I include nine case studies, not because the case studies are different one from another, but merely to show nine real human beings actually living up to their standards -- and, even more, that it does produce higher financial returns.


Charles O'Reilly said the same thing when I asked him why he wrote Hidden Value in a case-study format. His answer was that managers want to see a real-life case study in enough detail that they can draw some of their own lessons.

RW: I think that's right. We like to look at someone and say that if he or she could do it, maybe I can too.


Take us to some of your specific findings.

RW: One of the analyses shows that if your staff rate highly on nine aspects of employee attitude, then we can predict over one-half of the financial performance of the business, even if you don't know what business the company is in, or what country it is in, or what size.

The nine items are as follows:

  1. Client satisfaction is a top priority at our firm.
  2. We have no room for those who put their personal agendas ahead of the interests of the clients or the office.
  3. Those who contribute the most to the overall success of the office are the most highly rewarded.
  4. Management gets the best work out of everybody in the office.
  5. Around here you are required, not just encouraged, to learn and develop new skills.
  6. We invest a significant amount of time in the things that will pay off in the future.
  7. People within our office always treat others with respect.
  8. The quality of supervision on client projects is uniformly high.

The quality of the professionals in our office is as high as can be expected.

Now if you pause for a moment on the question "Is client satisfaction is a top priority around here?" you realise it's a very old sentence. That's not a new thought. What is new is that we're not asking, "Does management preach this?" The evidence says that where the employees believe it is true, then you make more money. If the employees do not believe this, then you will make less money. That's a substantive finding because it turns out that among the 139 offices studied there was enough variation that in some of the offices the employees were saying, "Darn right this is us," and other employees in other offices were going, "Yeah, yeah, yeah, heard that before."

A second result is that if the employees agree with the sentence "We have no room for those who put their personal agenda ahead of the clients or the office," the business will make more money. Many, many people have advocated that for years, but this finding shows that it's not good enough just to have a general "we are team players around here" feeling. In fact, I included that milder version of the question in the survey and it turned out not to predict financial performance at all. That's a significant lesson -- "sort of kind of" being something doesn't make you money. What makes you money are people who can turn around and say, "Darn right! If you are individualistic, we have no room for you in our company."


We've talked about this a bit before. What really matters is that the company has a very clear stand on something that people truly believe in.

RW: Again, this should not be a surprise. It is nothing more than having a clear strategy, knowing exactly how you plan to compete and what virtues and strengths you plan to bring to the market.

All of the logic is saying that if you actually live up to your belief, then you can make money at it. But if you are only living up to it some of the time, it's unlikely that you will. For example, there's a role for a high-class restaurant that uses the freshest ingredients and so forth. Now as long as it sticks to that view, there's a market niche for that restaurant, just as there is a niche for McDonalds, which is fast and cheap. The question is, could either of those two businesses succeed if they only lived up to their goals some of the time? It takes a certain level of courage to stick to your theory of business and to resist the temptation to be expedient. To return to the personal matter again, here I can say, "Oh well, one cigarette wouldn't hurt," and the next thing you know, I'm not a nonsmoker at all. If you want to get the benefits of being a nonsmoker, you've got to stick to it.


In your article, when you talk about a theory of the business, you show a causal map of how enthusiasm is causally linked to coaching, which is linked to employee satisfaction and so on, all the way to financial performance. This looks very much like the strategy map that Bob Kaplan and Dave Norton are promoting.

RW: Yes, although the diagram actually is closest to the work of Heskett, Schlesinger and Sasser in their book The Service Profit Chain. They did a good job in explaining that there is an order to things, and that first you must energise your employees to achieve high standards. If you do that well, they deliver high-quality services and products to your marketplace. If you deliver high-quality services and products to your marketplace, you make money. So you can see there is a logical flow of work.

Now prior to my article, this was presented as a logical theory. I've been able to prove statistically that this causal sequence is true.


Those people who went to school at the same time that I did would have learned that statistics can give correlations, but you are talking about causation.

RW: A lot has happened since you and I went to school. I got a bachelor's degree from the University of Southern Queensland in business, but that was 10 years ago! Back then, they beat into our heads that correlation is not causality. However, and in the article I cite the precise references, in the last 20 years statisticians have developed techniques that do allow you to make statements about causality.


I've spoken a lot about the balanced scorecard, and I know that Mark Huselid would be very excited to see your data, because you've created a validated strategy map for professional service firms, and that map is the basis for a balanced scorecard.

RW: Yes. And to me, the article is encouraging because, with one or two mild exceptions, the lessons that come out of both the statistical data and the case studies are indeed familiar lessons. This article is not revolutionary. It's meant to be completely consistent with what the balanced scorecard and Jeff Pfeffer have done, as well as the lessons Collins and Porras deliver in Built to Last.

This research has actually provided evidence that reaffirms the sorts of lessons advocated by the people we all admire.


There were other findings that I found interesting. One is that, when it comes to culture, the office outweighs the firm.

RW: Yes, this is a major finding.

Before we get to that, the first finding is that the difference between those who are succeeding superbly and those who are doing okay is not that they are doing innovative things, it's not clever strategies and it's not advanced human resource activities. They are enforcing certain basic standards.

For example, one of the standards is "Management gets the best work out of everybody." The real secret of success is good execution on familiar themes such as this.

What comes out is that success is almost entirely dependent upon the character and behaviour of the individual local manager. In other words, whether or not things get enforced is not a matter of corporate policies, it's whether or not the local manager has this interpersonal ability to energise, enthuse and excite those who report to him or her.


For HR people, that's an important finding to keep at the front of their minds.

RW: I may be speaking with insufficient evidence here, but when I've talked to HR people, I have found that they are not very involved in selecting managers. My article is saying that rather than spending large amounts of time and money developing strategies, the real point of difference is that we need to get better at selecting managers.

HR needs to be developing selection processes and methods of evaluating managers. My experience is that many people in HR spend 99 percent of their time on things for employees in general and less than 1 percent of their time selecting and keeping accountable the people who occupy managerial roles.


That's a profound comment right there, and I see how it can reframe where you think HR can achieve leverage.

RW: This article is unequivocal in its findings. If you really want to make a difference to employee satisfaction and financial performance, not to one or the other but to both, then you focus your attention on the managers.


These studies are on professional service firms. To what extent do lessons about professional service firms serve as a model for organisations like Kodak or Cisco?

RW: All the trends in our economy point towards traditional companies facing the same issues that professional service firms have had to live with for a long while -- for example, the increasing importance of the knowledge worker and the mobility of professional staff. It has always been true that professional staff move around from firm to firm.

A third point is that professional firms have always lived with the idea that, even if you had positional power, e.g., you were a practice head or office head, you managed more by interpersonal influence than relying on formal authority.

All of those things are increasingly relevant to managers in business generally.


It would probably make sense for any firm to take a close look at well-managed professional service firms to see what lessons they can pull out of that for their own environment.

RW: I don't want to grant to the professions any special status. We are all working stiffs. The central issue is how crucial the employee's input is to your business success. If I'm running a paper mill, the honest truth is that the employee's motivation helps a little, but what's going to happen in a paper mill really is going to come from the machines and the technocratic decisions on scheduling, changeovers and things like that. The lessons are really important for any business where the real value add lies in the people and less in the machines.


Is there anything that you would like to add that we haven't covered?

RW: The biggest surprise for me in the article was that the sentence, "People treat each other with respect around here" turned out to be one of the nine profit predictors. I'm delighted with the results because it matches my values, but it didn't get in there because of my values. I was actually surprised that it emerged because it's not true that in many businesses people treat each other with respect. So for me, to say that it actually is measurably a profit contributor was one of the most fascinating findings.


David Creelman is a knowledge manager at HR.com.

He has ten years of experience working for major international consultancies both in North America and Asia. He is a regular speaker at HR conferences and has published many articles on management issues. Prior to working in HR, David worked in finance and IT. He has a MBA and a Hons B.Sc. in biochemistry and chemistry.

Friday, June 1, 2001

How Clients Choose

The single most important talent in selling professional services is the ability to understand the purchasing process (not the sales process) from a client's perspective. The better a professional can learn to think like a client, the easier it will be to do and say the correct things to get hired.

Fortunately, this is not difficult. Most professionals have themselves been through the process of retaining other professionals: lawyers retain accountants, actuaries hire consultants and public relations counsellors, like the rest of us, need tax advice. Every professional can deepen their understanding of what's really going on in the purchase process by drawing on their own experiences as a client.

Professionals traditionally view their practice development task as divided into two stages: marketing (generating the lead) and selling (converting a lead into a sale). From the buyer's perspective, these two stages are experienced as qualification and selection processes.

First, I (the client) try to reduce the large number of possible firms and professionals that might be considered down to the set of those that I judge to be qualified. In this qualification stage, I consider these elements: "Who have you worked for?" "What are your capabilities?" "What depth of personnel do you have?" "How good are your references?"

Except in the most unusual situations, where the problem is so complex and high risk that there is only one viable candidate, even the most thorough due diligence (examination of available facts and references, interviewing of candidates, etc.) usually ends with more than one firm or individual that is technically qualified to handle my problem. Typically, after exhausting my abilities as a client to make technical distinctions, I am still left with a choice of reputable firms with good references, all eminently capable of solving my problem.

This leads to an important conclusion: Unless their skills are truly unique and unmatched by any competitor, professionals are never hired because of their technical capabilities. Excellent capabilities are essential to get you into the final set to be considered, but other qualities get you hired.

Once I have decided which firms I will consider in the final set, my focus of inquiry shifts significantly. I am no longer asking, "Can you do it?" but rather, "Do I want to work with you?" I am no longer interested in the institutional characteristics of your firm; instead, I'm now trying to form a judgment about you. By the fact that you are sitting here talking to me, you can assume that you have successfully marketed your firm. Now the time has come to sell yourself.


What It Feels Like to Be a Buyer

Buying professional services is rarely a comfortable experience. Among the unpleasant emotions frequently felt are the following:

First, I feel that I'm taking a personal risk. By hiring anyone, I am putting my affairs, or my company's affairs, in the hands of someone else, and I'm giving up some degree of control. This is my area of responsibility, and even though intellectually I may know I need outside expertise, emotionally it is not comfortable to put my affairs in the hands of others. Even if the matter is a relatively routine one, I need to be convinced (beyond protestations of good intentions) that my problem will receive prompt and serious attention.

I'm feeling insecure. Since I find it hard to detect which of you is the genius and who is just good, I'm going to have to commit myself without feeling totally confident about my decision. What is more, I don't yet know if I've got a simple problem or a complex one; that's why I need you, the specialist, to help me. But I'm not sure that I can trust you to be honest; after all, it's in your interest to convince me that my problem is complex. Professionals are always making mountains out of molehills. Nothing is ever easy.

I'm sceptical. I've been burned before by these kinds of people. I get a lot of promises. How do I know whose promise I should buy?

I'm concerned that you either can't or won't take the time to understand what makes my situation special. Will you be one of those typical professionals who are hard to get hold of, who are patronising, who leave the client out of the loop, who befuddle the client with jargon, who don't explain what they're doing or why, who..., who..., who...? In short, will you deal with me in the way that I want to be dealt with?

To a degree, I am also exposed. Whoever I hire I'm going to have to reveal some proprietary secrets to, not all of which are flattering. I'm also a little threatened. You will be working on things for which I am responsible (marketing consultants are hired by the vice president of marketing, lawyers by the general counsel, actuaries by the benefits manager). By the very fact that you are suggesting improvements or changes, there is the risk that you will uncover things that I haven't been doing right up till now. Are you going to be my ally or my enemy?

What all this reveals is that from among the set of qualified candidates I am looking for the one I can trust. The act of hiring a professional is, by very definition, an act of faith. I must, inevitably, believe a promise. In selecting a professional I am not just buying a service, I am entering into a relationship. Your selling task is to earn my trust and confidence -- with an emphasis on the word "earn."


What a Buyer Looks For

How am I to determine with which candidate I want to have a relationship? Certainly the answer is not contained in the promises you make. Talk is cheap. Someone who tells me, "Trust me; we'll show a special interest in you," is not likely to win my confidence simply by that assertion.

Inevitably, even if I view myself as a sophisticated buyer, I am forced to rely on clues obtained through the interview process in order to guess at what kind of person you are. My impressions and perceptions are created by small actions that are meaningful for their symbolism, for what they reveal. How you behave during the interview (or proposal process) will be taken as a proxy for how you will deal with me after I retain you. Unlike the process of qualification, which is predominantly rational, logical and based on facts, the selection stage is mostly intuitive, personal and based on impressions.

The first thing that will catch my attention is your preparation. There is nothing more off-putting than someone who begins the meeting by asking me some basic facts about my company or situation that they could have found out in advance. It not only reveals laziness but it makes me feel like just another "cold call" -- you don't have any special interest in me; you're on a fishing expedition, trying to drum up some revenue.

On the other hand, if someone says to me, "I noticed from your annual report that you recently opened a new plant in XXX. What has that meant for your department?" they will catch my attention. It may not be intellectually challenging to read my annual report, but it shows that you do your homework. It tells me something about you.

This point can be taken further because preparation is your opportunity to demonstrate initiative. Why not contact my industry association and gather some information about my company's public data compared to that of my competitors? It will help you ask me more substantive questions and will demonstrate your willingness to earn my business. If you want to bring along some printed material, I will be a lot more impressed by something that has clearly been put together for me rather than a pre-printed brochure. At least that shows a little thought and consideration.

Professionals who are over-eager to impress and thereby spend the whole meeting talking about their accomplishments, what their firm has done and why they are qualified to help me come across as insensitive to me, to my company and to my situation. It sounds like what it is: a standard spiel, reflecting no special interest in me. I do not want to hear about you and your firm -- I want to talk about me and my situation. The only way to influence me is to find out what I want and show me how to get it. I hate to be sold, but I may be willing to buy if you can show me that my company and I have some problems to solve or some opportunities to capture.

Getting me to acknowledge that there is an opportunity or a problem won't necessarily be easy because I'm suspicious of your motives. First you must make me feel comfortable, perhaps by asking me what's going well. Give me some new information. Tell me what my competitors are up to. Tell me what you've been doing for other companies like mine. Find a way to be helpful to me.

Give me an education. Tell me about alternate ways that common problems of my industry might be dealt with. Help me understand the advantages and disadvantages of some of the things I have been reading about. Ask me how I am doing things now, and use that as an opportunity to help me understand some options I may have for doing things differently. Tell me something I don't already know. If I walk away from the meeting saying, "That was interesting; I hadn't thought of that," you've won. I may or may not hire you today, but I'll certainly want to talk to you again. Don't be afraid to float high-risk ideas early on ("just an idea"). Demonstrate your creativity.

I discount all your assertions about your expertise until you give me some evidence to back them up. For example, don't tell me about your experience in my industry (or on a particular topic). Instead, illustrate it by asking questions that reveal your knowledge of key industry terminology, facts and figures or latest events. That way I'll draw my own conclusions (which I'm going to do anyway) about how well you understand my business and my issues.

While I want you to know my industry, don't patronise me by trying to tell me what's going on in my business. Instead of saying, "Here are the three most important things happening in your industry," say, "Our experience suggests that these are the three most important things. Do you agree?" If I agree with you, fine. If I disagree, we can have a conversation.

To avoid coming across as arrogant, patronising and pompous (a common experiences with professionals) turn your assertions into questions. By doing so, you convert possible signs of assertiveness into evidence that you'll respect my opinions, involve me in the thinking process and be sensitive to the need for a congenial relationship. Your manner of speech -- how you choose to phrase your sentences -- tells me something about how you deal with clients. Make our meeting a conversation. Don't talk all the time, and similarly, don't grill me.

Show a sympathetic understanding of my role in my company. Understand who I report to, how I'm measured, what my budgets are. By asking me about these things, I'll believe you are treating me as a person, not just a purchasing agent.

This doesn't mean that I want you to wine and dine me or try to win my business by becoming my friend. It does mean that I want you to be sensitive to the fact that your prospective client (me) is a person, not a corporate entity.

Don't start telling me how you can solve my problems until I have acknowledged that there's a problem or an opportunity here. Simply asserting to me that I have problems or opportunities isn't enough. If you say it, I can and will doubt you. If I say it, it's true.

The key talent in good selling is being good at getting me, the client, to reveal my problems, needs, wants and concerns. If I'm talking, telling you about my company and my needs, you're ahead; if you're talking, you're losing. Professionals talk too much. Ask good questions and listen.

As you try to get me talking about my problems, demonstrate your sensitivity. I do not respond well to someone who asks me right up front, "What are your problems?" That's too assertive and you haven't yet earned the right to an answer. Similarly, don't ask, "What's not going well?" I'm not going to answer that. But I might answer, "What don't you have time for?" I can answer that without feeling uncomfortable.

While I am unlikely to tell you my problems, I may be willing to acknowledge problems you already know about. For example, ask me why we do things the way we do, why we haven't tried certain options. Instead of asking, "What problems do you have with that way of doing things?" say, "Some of our other clients who do things the way you do have had to contend with the following issues as a result. What have you done to deal with those consequences?" This question gives you an opportunity to show that you are familiar with my type of situation, and it doesn't confront or challenge me.

If I do begin to show interest in a given issue, your next task is to convince me (or get me to convince myself) that the issue is big enough to bother with. Remember, I don't like working with professionals and will only do so when I have to. So I'll only proceed if I'm convinced that the benefit is big enough and certain enough (two separate issues) to justify the expense, discomfort and disruption of using you. Before I want to hear how you'll solve my problem, you need to get me to agree that it's worth solving.

Your most productive tactic is to ask me, "How valuable would it be if...?" and complete the sentence by describing some future state of affairs that you can get me to. Help me picture in my mind the benefits I will receive by reaching that state of affairs. If you get me excited about the possible benefits (not by asserting them, but by getting me to admit that they would be desirable), I will then want to know more about how you can get me there. If I don't acknowledge the benefit, nothing else you say will be of any interest to me.

If I'm still with you, still interested in (maybe) proceeding, I may ask you how you would go about handling my affairs. Don't rush to give me a singular, concrete answer as to "your firm's approach." It may be one that I'm not interested in. For example, maybe I want the "permanent fix" -- the version of the assignment that deals with the issue once and for all. Or perhaps I might want the "quick fix" -- the version that shows results as soon as possible.

Perhaps I will be more interested in proceeding if your approach will incur minimum disruption to my ongoing operations or will reduce the extent of involvement and effort required by me and my people.

The key is to give me options, help me understand their advantages and disadvantages, and let me choose. If you present me with "your firm's approach," it strikes me as standardised. By educating me regarding alternative ways to proceed, I get value from the discussion. By letting me choose, I am also left with the sense that you're the type of professional who will respect my judgment and involve me.

Recognise that it's unlikely that I'm going to say "yes" or "no" in front of you. I'm going to consult before I make a decision. So don't pressure me. Don't try any "closing techniques" on me. Give me reasons and reasoning I can use when I consult with my superiors and colleagues.

Instead of reaching for a sale at every meeting, make your objective that of making progress in our relationship. Maybe I'll agree to meet one of your specialist partners, consent to provide additional information to you or provide access to one of my other executives. Perhaps I'll participate in one of your seminars or agree to an additional, more focused meeting. Any one of these should be taken as a success. If you try to rush me, I'll take it as a sign that you're more interested in making a sale than in helping me.

I may ask you to submit a proposal, but never forget that because my ultimate decision is based on who I trust, the sale will be made during the face-to-face time we spend together. The vast majority of professional projects are awarded at the pre-proposal stage. The formal proposal and presentation merely confirm (or destroy) a decision already made. If you can't afford to spend time in up-front contact, don't bother writing the proposal.

Here's what I want if I ask you to make a presentation. Sit down, distribute your materials in advance and we'll go through them together. Don't lower the lights, put up your slides, stand up and walk me through your canned speech. It makes me feel that I'm being lectured to. If I want to ask about something, don't say, "We'll get to that." It makes me feel that you're inflexible.

If I interrupt you, deal with my question. I want to see how you handle yourself when I ask a question, not judge how practiced you are at your standard spiel. Most of you do rehearse your presentations, but you rehearse the wrong things. I'm not looking for how smoothly you can get through your practiced presentation. That's not what will influence my decision. Rather, I give great weight to how flustered you get when I ask hard questions. Flunk that test and I'm not sure you're the one I want to trust. What you should be rehearsing are your responses to my questions.

I want you to prove that you can listen by picking up on my comments, by adapting in real time, by replying to what I've just said. Involve me. Ask what I think. I know that someone's listening to me when they show the ability to depart from their prepared scripts and base their subsequent comments on what I've just said. If you don't have the talent to depart from your script when I throw a curve ball (and I'm going to), then why should I believe in your abilities?

When I challenge you with an objection, hear it out and don't interrupt. Don't tell me I shouldn't be concerned about that: I've just told you that I am concerned. Acknowledge what I've said as a valid concern. I'll let you rephrase and soften it, but make sure you check for my acceptance of your rephrasing. Then give me an answer, and ask me whether I accept your answer. Don't try to "survive the moment" by waffling and moving on. You may get out of an uncomfortable moment, but I'm going to be left with the feeling that you didn't answer my question -- and that means I won't trust you.

I'll be impressed if you've clearly anticipated my issues and thought of that objection or concern beforehand -- it shows me that you've taken the time to see things from my perspective. So predict my objections and practice your responses as part of your preparation -- on such things sales are won or lost.


Summary

There is an old joke about doctors that says they "get fascinated with the disease, but couldn't care less about the patient." Unfortunately, this attitude (and behaviour) is all too prevalent in a wide array of professions. Too many professionals get overly focused on technical matters and lose sight of the essential relationship nature of professional transactions. This doesn't mean that technical skill is irrelevant -- of course, it is critical. But having technical skills is only a necessary condition for success, not a sufficient one.

Above all, what I, the client, am looking for is that rare professional who has both technical skill and a sincere desire to be helpful, to work with both me and my problem. The key is empathy -- the ability to enter my world and see it through my eyes.

Tuesday, May 1, 2001

Are you ready for Practice Group Leaders?

One of the most common requests I receive is to run a training program to help practice managers (who lead offices, discipline groups or industry practices) become more effective. Although the subject is one I care about passionately, I frequently decline to get involved.

This is because all too often the conditions necessary for effective implementation of practice management are missing. The way many firms are run ensures that effective practice management is close to impossible.

The problem that most practice leaders have is not primarily a lack of training. Rather, they are asked to fulfill a poorly specified role, with unclear objectives and responsibilities and with ambiguous authority. What is more, they are often selected for the role on the basis of skills and accomplishments that have nothing to do with the tasks they face.

In a wide spectrum of professions, professionals are loosely grouped into practices, departments or operating units, and the role of the practice head is primarily administrative, not managerial. They are expected to monitor short-term financials such as utilisation, billing discipline and receivables, but have little or no authority to supervise the activities of other (senior) professionals in the group.

Senior professionals jealously guard their autonomy to use their own time (billable or non-billable) as they see fit, and cede no authority to anyone on such things as how they will staff their own jobs or what practice development activities they will conduct.

There is no expectation (and certainly no requirement) that group members will act collectively and make joint decisions (with mutual responsibility to each other) on such things as practice development, development of junior staff, or building tools and templates of benefit to everyone in the group.

Since in this traditional model the practice head's freedom to act is severely circumscribed, it is also typical that the practice head is given no extra time to fulfill the group leadership function. They are expected to be as chargeable as any other senior professional in the group, to have the same responsibilities in revenue generation and are appraised based on their personal accomplishments as a professional rather than their success as a group leader.

This implied rejection of management by so many professional firms is based on a resistance to one or both of two common caricatures that many professionals associate with the word "management." Either it is viewed as an administrative burden (adding no value) and best left to "bean counters," or else it is viewed as a heavy-handed, corporate-style bossiness, with the practice manager playing cop, over-seer or (as I once described it) the "nun with the ruler."

Professionals are quite correct to reject these caricatures. However, what they often fail to consider is a third alternative: the practice head as coach of the team. (I shall use the term "practice coach" henceforth in this article to distinguish what I am discussing from the traditional "administrator" role.)

This approach has a number of implications, the first being that the group is prepared to accept that it is a team with common purposes and mutual obligations, not just an administrative unit.

Second, the practice coach system implies that the coach must be chosen for his or her skills in coaching (rather than excellence in business getting or technical expertise) and be willing to focus efforts on helping the team succeed rather than focussing primarily on his or her own personal success.


Why Have Groups?

The transition from practice leader as administrator to practice leader as coach requires a cultural revolution -- a small change for some firms but a major one for others. However, there is more than a little evidence that most, if not all, professional firms will have to go through this cultural revolution if they have not done so already.

The historical model of many professions, which places an almost exclusive emphasis on individual initiative, individual performance metrics and individual performance-based rewards, cannot create all the capabilities needed to succeed in today's marketplace. Many of today's clients (particularly big, attractive ones) actively seek out firms that have well-coordinated practice teams so that they can get the benefit of depth from their service providers and not be excessively dependent on a single individual professional.

Similarly, in today's tough competition for talent, a superior ability to attract, develop and retain professionals (senior and junior) is a key economic and competitive issue. Loosely organised individuals, accountable only for their own performance, are less likely to succeed in this area than would a well-managed team engaging in collective activities with collective responsibilities.

A well-coached, coordinated team would be able to achieve any (or all) of the following possible benefits:

  1. More effective practice development efforts through pooling and coordination of individual efforts
  2. Better utilisation and development of junior professionals through collective decisions on staffing of client work, allocation of resources and mentoring
  3. Collective development of tools, templates, databases and other practice aids to benefit everyone
  4. More rapid and effective dissemination of expertise and skills among the group
  5. Better client service through greater ability to put the right people on the right job
  6. Better market image through development of a collective reputation, not just the sum of individual reputations
  7. Comfort of "belonging" to a small group rather than being "lost" as one member of a very large group of professionals (something that applies to the successful retention of both senior and junior professionals)
  8. Informal coaching on a "one-on-one" basis acting as a source of help for personal growth rather than relying on firmwide, annual, bureaucratic performance appraisals
  9. Improved profitability from focussing as a group on ways to enhance billing rates and leverage
  10. Critical mass of time and resources created to develop innovative service offerings, which no individual could afford to do alone

The essential first step in capturing these benefits is that the members of the group must decide whether they are truly prepared to act as a team and not as a loosely affiliated group of independent practitioners. They must make an informed, conscious decision to give up a few degrees of autonomy in exchange for the benefits listed above.

To make this a really informed decision, there must be a clearly articulated policy statement as to why practice groups are important and what specific benefits (perhaps selected from the list given above) the group expects to obtain from acting as a coordinated team. It is surprising to learn how many firms across all professions still have not thought this through.

A firm does not need to seek all the benefits listed above from its groups, and there are many other benefits not described here. However, I hope the message is clear: To obtain the benefits of operating as a coordinated group, everyone, including the group's professionals, firm management and practice coach needs to have a clear, unambiguous understanding of what practice groups are seeking to accomplish. They all have roles to play in making the practice group work, and they must all be part of the decision to establish the "rules of engagement."

In some firms there is a "general understanding" of the group's purpose, but this is insufficient. All too often practice groups meet and sit around asking, "What are we supposed to be doing at this meeting? Why are we here?" This is, of course, a disastrous waste of everybody's time. The goals and specific target benefits of each practice group must be discussed, resolved and written down.

There is no requirement that each and every practice group in a firm selects the same set of objectives, since different groups may be at different stages of development and have different priorities. However, each group's objectives must be clear.


Clear Enunciation of the Practice Coach Role

No team can succeed without a leader. Not only must the goals of the practice group be written down and agreed on, but so must the roles, responsibilities, accountabilities and performance measures for the practice coach. It is remarkable how infrequently this is done.

Naturally, the precise role of the practice coach will derive directly from the objectives chosen for the group. However, there are certain key choices that must be made in any circumstance. For example, is the practice coach expected to do any or all of the following?

  1. Spend time with individual professionals (senior or junior), serving as coach to help them develop themselves and their practice
  2. Be knowledgeable about the development of junior professionals and intervene (delicately) to "suggest" reassignments between projects in order to build skills and advance their careers
  3. Be in touch with clients of other professionals in the group to help the professional to grow the relationship, to monitor client satisfaction and to act as a "conscience" so everyone can excel at client satisfaction
  4. Monitor the profitability of assignments conducted by members of the group and discuss the results with them
  5. Devise methodologies to capture and share knowledge acquired while serving clients both within the group and across the firm
  6. Spend time recruiting and interviewing potential new staff (junior and senior)
  7. Spend time following up and actively helping members of the group execute their planned activities
  8. Initiate and run regular meetings of practice group members to collectively plan the group's activities and initiatives for the coming quarter
  9. Conduct performance appraisals of other (senior) professionals in the team for purposes of compensation
  10. Conduct counselling sessions with professionals on the basis of these performance appraisals

A practice coach does not have to do all the items on this list. There are many versions of practice coaching. However, only by precisely specifying which items are the responsibility of the practice coach can a firm then proceed to empower the practice coach and, equally important, define the rights and responsibilities that team members owe to the group and to each other.

Then, and only then, will it be possible to address the following key questions:

  1. What key skills are needed for the role as we have defined it?
  2. How much time will it take to perform the role we have defined?
  3. Which benefits should we expect to see, given the role definition and the time allowed?
  4. What powers or authority will the coach require to perform this role?
  5. How can we measure the success of the practice coach?
  6. On what basis should we consider rewarding the practice coach for these activities?
  7. What training, if any, is needed to perform the role as we have defined it?

Since so many professional firms do not have a history of "activist" practice coaches, it is essential that the precise answers to these questions (summarised in a written statement of the practice coach's role, responsibilities, accountabilities and authority) be discussed between the practice coach and firm management and also be widely disseminated and discussed with the team members.

Practice coaches cannot and must not attempt to impose their own view of their role on others; this will doom them to failure. Professionals must grant permission to be coached, and this can only be done if the role and its limits are agreed on in advance.

Naturally, the same role definition does not have to be imposed firm-wide. Different groups may choose different versions of practice coaching, at least initially. This is understandable and acceptable.

However, there probably will be a core set of responsibilities (or a minimum set of practice group activities) that the firm has a right to expect of all groups and all team leaders.


Valuing Non-billable Time

The next essential component of the practice coach revolution is that firms must credibly convey to their professionals that activities conducted during non-billable time are valued, monitored and considered an essential part of their performance appraisal.

Much of what practice groups do, and what practice coaches try to get their team members to do, involves investment of non-billable time in activities that build the future of the practice. Obvious examples include various kinds of marketing activities, development of tools, conducting training programs and so on.

Unfortunately, what happens in too many firms is this: The team meets and lays out a wonderful plan for marketing, training and tool development. Then the practice coach comes round a few weeks later and says, "Hey, Fred. How's that article going that you promised to write?" And Fred replies, "Well, I've got some more billable work to do, so I'm too busy to write it. Billable work trumps everything else, right? At least that's what the compensation committee believes, and I've got to protect myself. Sorry, coach!"

So the article never gets written, all the other team members reason the same way and the planning meeting might just as well have never happened. They might just as well not be a group. They might just as well not have a practice coach.

As I have written elsewhere, the point here is not about working more hours, since non-billable time is already being spent by every professional. The point is that the essence of having practice groups is the willingness of individuals to contribute (at least a portion of) their non-billable time to the group effort and their agreement to be held strictly accountable to the group for what is promised. You don't have to promise a lot, but what you promise you must do.

Note that the obligation and accountability are not primarily to the practice coach or to firm management. Your obligation is to keep your promises to your team. The role of the practice coach (and firm management) is to be the conscience: monitoring and helping people keep their promises.

Among the best groups there is recognition that if each individual commits to investing roughly equal amounts of non-billable time, then no member is doing more than the others or is left feeling that they are being taken advantage of. A skilled coach ensures that there is a minimum of "assigning" tasks to people, relying as much as possible on people volunteering for tasks they are enthusiastic about.

It is also at times necessary for the coach to manage down the size or scope of a task that someone wants to take on. Since it is important to establish the principle that you must keep your promises, the coach should never accept an undertaking on the basis of "try to get this done." As the character Yoda said in the film The Empire Strikes Back, "Do, or do not. There is no try!"


Practice Coaches Chosen for Their Attitude

The next requirement to make practice teams work is that the practice coaches must be selected for their attitude, not their accomplishments.

The job of a practice coach is to help his or her colleagues, the team, win. Accordingly, the most important attribute of a successful practice coach is a willingness to focus primarily on helping other people with their professional practices and secondarily to focus on the success of their own practice.

However, most professionals have been asked to spend their whole working lives focusing on their own success, and the transition to helping others is a difficult one for many to make. There are issues of both attitude (willingness to focus on others) and skill (ability to influence others without being domineering). Skills can be taught; attitudes are harder to change.

Given historical approaches to practice leadership, it is not unusual for a firm to have very few people already skilled as coaches since the firm has never before asked people to play this role. This is not necessarily a problem. If someone wants to learn, you can teach them anything. The real issue is whether the firm has enough people willing to accept the role and learn the skills. If the attitude is favourable, there is no problem because the skills can be acquired.

Traditionally, practice coaches were chosen for their accomplishments, but this is often disastrous. A person may be very successful at business development but have no ability to help others learn how to do it. Similarly, someone may be very energetic and dynamic but have few skills in bringing out energy and dynamism in others. Accordingly, a firm's best practitioners or best business developers could make the worst practice coaches.

As a result of this historical (and sometimes political) reality, some firms have found it necessary to appoint two people to lead a practice. One (perhaps called the "practice chair") is the luminary, someone well known in the market-place, whose primary focus is representing the group to the market-place. This person bears no coaching responsibilities but is backed up by the "real" practice coach who does the co-ordinating and counselling and effectively runs the practice.


Time to Do the Job

Probably the single biggest source of failure in practice group coaching is the failure to give the practice coach the time to do the job. In many firms, practice coaches are expected to be as fully chargeable as anyone else in the practice.

As a result, they continue to view their own individual practice as job number one and their coaching responsibilities as a secondary, lesser responsibility that they carry out when time allows. Not surprisingly, since most professionals live busy work lives, something always has to give and that "something" is almost always their practice coach responsibilities.

As one practice coach said, "I'm doing this job on faith -- the faith that at the end of the year someone is going to remember all the time I have put into doing this job and the faith that I'm not going to get screwed at compensation time because I don't have the numbers I would have had if I'd practiced full time."

The real problem here is not the practice coaches, but firm management. When asked if management is prepared to give assurances to the practice coaches that if they spend time on the role and do it well they won't be penalised for any drop-off in billable hours or revenue generation, too many firm management groups reply (publicly and privately) that while they buy the concept of practice group leadership, they are not prepared to take any risks with the firm's economics. They will give no assurances to practice coaches that any drop in the leader's production won't be taken as adverse.

In a previous article ("How Practice Leaders Add Value"), I showed how easy it is to prove that the firm would make more money from having well-managed groups than from realising the incremental billable hours of the practice coach. Accordingly, best practice is to align the incentives for the practice coach with the best interests of the firm.

This is simply done. You tell practice coaches that they are measured and appraised by how well their group has done, with their own personal statistics being deemed irrelevant. They are still expected to practice and generate revenues (as much as they like) but personal accomplishments no longer count in their appraisal. Only improving the group's success represents a fulfillment of the role.

If they can help the group to succeed while still carrying a full book of business so much the better. But if they cannot do both, then it is clear which job is their number one priority -- the group!

For a variety of reasons, this simple solution is not yet possible at many firms since there is a profound mistrust of any partner who is not carrying his or her "full load," something that is always defined in terms of production (because production is the only valued activity in these firms).

Such firms will need to experiment with interim solutions such as reducing the target production levels (billable hours) of the practice coach below the level required of other partners in order to free up the required time to coach. Without doing this, all other efforts to create functioning practice teams will fail.

However, even this step alone is insufficient. The firm needs to be credible in the eyes of each practice coach in that his or her performance appraisal will give significant weight to performance as a coach. This is necessary not only to keep the coach's eye on the ball but to be credible to all other partners that the coach is not getting a "free ride" through reduced production hours.

The reluctance to allow any one practice coach to reduce his or her production hours by too great a sum usually implies introducing a practice coaching system that has a larger number of coaches, each spending a small amount of time with a small team. This has the merit that you are more likely to get group teamwork and co-operation started in smaller groups (of five to ten partners, for example).

Larger practice groups can and do succeed, but they almost always require significant practice coaching time. A good case can be made that because coaching skills are scarce, the better long-term solution is to have fewer people playing the coach role, each spending more personal time guiding larger groups. However, few firms have the courage to begin with this step.


Input to Compensation Decisions

One final element is necessary to get a practice group coaching system off the ground. Practice coaches must have a formal role in providing input to the firm's performance appraisal and compensation system.

The irreducible core of a practice coach's activities is getting the team to plan its activities and then to follow up with each team member to ensure that agreed-on activities are indeed executed. Hopefully, the coach will rely primarily on personal charm, interpersonal influence and inspirational charisma to ensure that all team members pull their weight.

However, it would be naïve to believe that the practice coach will not occasionally have to deal with severe degrees of non-compliance such as refusing to show up for group meetings or failure to deliver on promises made to the team.

What, then, should the practice coach do? The best solution is to require each coach to provide formal input to the firm's performance appraisal and compensation system. The coach does not determine compensation and is not the sole source of performance appraisal. However, he or she does have the opportunity to comment on how well each team member has contributed to the collective effort.


Conclusion

It is fascinating to observe the extremes of philosophy that exist with respect to practice groups and practice group coaching. In many firms, practice group coaching is well entrenched and has been so for years, if not decades. In other firms, even those in the same profession, the very concept of practice group coaching challenges deeply held beliefs.

Based on my observation of professional firms around the world, there is no doubt in my mind that the firms with team-based, well-coached practice groups are increasingly able to use co-ordinated, collective efforts to win clients and staff from the unco-ordinated, individualistic firms.

Practice group coaching is undeniably powerful, but it is equally a radical change of mindset for many firms. Done properly, it can bring not only greater economic success but also change the culture of a firm, enhancing collegiality and mutual support.

However, these benefits will not be brought about by dabbling. If partners don't want to be coached, if firm management doesn't want to make the formal changes it requires and if practice coaches would rather practice than coach, then you'll be wasting your time.

As one firm's chairman said, "What you're saying is that there's no point training someone for a role that no one wants them to perform, one that they themselves don't want to do and one for which there is no reward." Exactly right!

CPAs and Practice What You Preach

by Jean Marie Caragher 2001

from Capstone Marketing, 2001

Richard Wood's thoughts and ideas in Capstone Marketing's 2000 interview sparked a lot of discussion and debate about accounting and legal marketing. He's back to talk about the findings in his latest article to be published in our June edition.


Do you think most CPA firms and law firms practice what they preach?

RW: Certainly they do not. Over the past 20 years I have seen quite a few, and most firms' strategies and mission statements are entirely sensible. They know what they should be doing, but if you actually test the proposition of asking whether they are willing to be held accountable for the things they advocate, then you get a lot of resistance. For example, everyone would say we should be committed to developing our people. But most firms would furiously fight you in introducing any system that actually measured how a partner was doing on that and made that partner accountable for it. It's, "Yes, I believe in it. I'll try, but don't hold me to it."


I mentioned the idea of upward evaluations to a firm recently and they were not excited about it.

RW: People go after the mechanism and say it is flawed. In fact, the fight is not about what the right mechanism is. The fight is about, "Are we willing to be held accountable for the things we advocate?" It's as simple as that.


What would it take for CPA firm and law firm partners to be willing to be held accountable? Is it leadership?

RW: A good leader is absolutely central to that. Let me summarise the main lessons of the article. The wonderful lesson is that the difference between the people who are making out like bandits financially (those who are really successful) and those who are doing OK is not anything new, dramatic, sexy or exciting. The difference is that they are actually doing stuff that we have all known for years.

For example, one of the things that turns out to predict profits very accurately is whether or not people in the office agree with the statement, "We have no room for those who put their personal agenda ahead of the clients or the office." In other words, teamwork wins. But notice how strongly that is phrased. The data says that if your employees agree with "We are sorta kinda team players," that is not in any way predictive of profits because being sorta kinda something doesn't make you much money. You get the benefits of that which you actually do, not that which you aspire to.

Therefore, I have data that reaffirms the simple-minded proposition that firms that are enforcing teamwork are, in fact, making more money because it is true that teamwork wins. The lesson is a hard one as well. The good news is that it is obvious. The bad news is there's no reward for sorta kinda being something.


So there would need to be a group of partners or people in a firm who say, "This is what we are going to be." Those that aren't in the same boat either need to join the group or leave.

RW: Exactly right. The big difference is that it doesn't start with the leader. It starts with, "Do we have a group of people who are sufficiently ambitious or energetic that they are actually willing to aim for and work for the rewards of excellence?" That's not a trivial statement because if you are earning a pretty decent income by being competent then it's an open question of how much energy you have left after you have achieved competence.


Many firm partners tell me that they are doing as much work as they can handle and their people are busy and they have a pretty good life. Why should they do any more?

RW: They shouldn't if they don't want to. They just shouldn't pretend. How to win is obvious. That's the good news of the article. The question that remains is whether people are willing to live with the discipline. I'm not a believer in dictatorships, a leader telling other people what to do. I don't think you parachute in a charismatic, inspiring religious figure. The article proves that you do need a leader who is willing to enforce the rules that the partners agree to and who doesn't compromise, who isn't wishy-washy, and who isn't expedient.

My research demonstrates that where excellence occurs, it is very much a property of the local office or, in the case of accounting firms or law firms, maybe the practice group. It has got almost nothing to do with the managing partner or the worldwide CEO. It's down to, "Do you have managers that can manage?" A great manager is able to create energy, excitement, enthusiasm, ambition, passion, drive and commitment.


Tell me what you think about CPA firms or law firms hiring non-CPAs or non-lawyers to lead or manage them.

RW: Quite simply, it all turns on that one question of who is able to influence these people. If, for example, lawyers would accept influence from a non-lawyer, then there is no logical reason why that would not work. The reality in most countries is that no matter how skilled the person, lawyers would not accept influence from a non-lawyer. The person would be doomed to failure no matter how skilled he or she was.


Then it's not so much about the managing partner as it is about managers at the local, small-group level.

RW: Yes, because the goal is to create the energy. We all need help living up to standards and raising the bar on ourselves. A good coach is crucial to keeping the team disciplined. The case studies demonstrate that these people do not tolerate non-compliance with agreed-upon standards. I'm not saying that the leader establishes the standards. The partners must say what they want to go for and how they will do it, and which disciplines they are prepared to accept in order to aim for the excellence that they want a return on. Then you need a system that, in real words, says, "If you are not in compliance, we will give help." If the help doesn't work, you are gone.

It also means that some people say, "That is not what I want. I am out of here." That is entirely fair. You can't have one office where, in essence, it's a matter of individual choice and some are trying to go for excellence and some are saying "I'll be competent". Unless the group comes to some agreement on the game it wishes to play, then it cannot achieve the things that produce the rewards.


There are fewer students entering the accounting profession, and they leave public accounting firms quicker. Given these circumstances, how can CPA firms be as choosy or intolerant regarding the quality of their professionals?

RW: There is a loop here. The reason they need to recruit so many is that they lose so many. If the firms ever solve the problem of making the work environment one where people wanted to stay, they would have the power to be a lot more selective. The first solution to the recruiting problem is to work on retention. It's nothing magical. It's all old stuff. The message is, "Start doing it, you buggers."

It's nothing more than supervising people on their work. Make sure people are getting a decent mix of work experiences so that they are challenged. Make sure the people ahead of you are energised and turned on. It's very hard to energise junior people when the senior people are ho-hum about their work.


Who is responsible for lifelong learning? The individual? The firm? A combination?

RW: It's primarily the responsibility of the individual in the sense that "if you don't work on learning, you don't fit around here, and you're out." Now, the firm has to help. If you have an employee who is standing there, taking no initiative, saying "Develop me, develop me," actually, it's not a bad sign. You know you have the wrong person. Here is the message: We all need help. Richard Wood needs help. If you just leave it to me and say, "See you at the end of the year," it gets real hard after meeting my billable quota to say, "I also have to write an article or start my next book as well."

Sustaining that drive is very hard if you have to do it alone. This is about all of us. It's not about them, the stupid lawyers or accountants. These are the basic rules of what it takes to make a lot of money. They are the things that apply to all of us. A lot of individuals in firms want forgiveness. They want to not do the work and have some other way of succeeding. The bad news is that there is no other way.


Why don't CPA firms and law firms pay more attention to client satisfaction?

RW: I think there is a perverse syndrome that takes place in many firms, which is that the client is viewed as the enemy. It's us against them. The client is a person to be seduced or conquered, then negotiated furiously with all during the relationship and watched like a hawk in case they don't pay the bill. We've set up an adversarial mentality because clients, in many ways, are resented.

If you happen to work with clients that you don't view as the enemy and view them as people you like and are trying to help, it's actually a relationship, and everything will work better. You will have a more fun work life, they'll quibble less over fees and they'll tell their friends. If your starting point is us versus them, then client feedback is viewed as data from the enemy.


Then they need to change their mindset from the beginning.

RW: I think it's a fundamental mindset change of how they view clients if you want to make a lot of money. Most people view what they do as tolerable work for tolerable clients. If that's how you view it, then you don't want feedback from your clients! They don't view their clients as relationship partners; they view the clients as people they have seduced.


How can CPA firms and law firms achieve excellent results when they operate with a billable-hour mentality?

RW: There is nothing wrong with billable hours. What's wrong is saying that billable hours are the exclusive measure of success. If you are working on something that can be delegated, and you do delegate it, then everybody wins as long as you are willing to live through the transition. Yet in the short term everybody loses. In order to get through the transition, staff needs to be trained; you must take non-billable time to teach staff how to do it.

Therefore, the only reason I'm going to live through the transition takes us right back to the beginning of our conversation, which is that I'm only going to do it if I have a dream, have passion, have somewhere I want to get to and I want that with passion. If everyone took the sort of time-frame decisions that accounting firms and law firms do, nobody would go to college! Why would you give up four years of income to go study?

The only way to get to the next level in a firm or as an individual is that you've got to have a clear sense of where you want to get to. I have to want that future goal with a passion, and I've got to have the courage to believe my own strategy. The problem inside many accounting and law firms is not a lack of intelligence; it's excessive short-term thinking and a lack of guts. Do you have the guts to go to four years of university and bet that four years of university will give you a better life? Do you have the guts to start delegating? Do you have the guts to ask your clients if you're any better? You will never do any of that unless you have a dream that you passionately want.


What is the most important thing we can learn from this article?

RW: First, you get the benefit from that which you do -- not that which you aspire to. You've got to do it. The bad news is that, in business, there is very little reward for being kinda sorta good at something. The other very big lesson is that the people I met, these are not unique people in the intellectual sense. Some of these people were in very low-fee businesses. These are good, sensible, ordinary human beings. What they were capable of achieving when they were turned on was astounding! Second, a great manager who knows what he or she is doing can get incredible performance out of ordinary people.

It's not that the current managers of accounting firms or law firms are doing it badly. I don't think many of them see it as their job at all. Many of the people in managerial roles, particularly at the practice group level, don't see energising those around them as their job. They see it as their role to be a financial administrator, the group's best marketer and the intellectual luminary of the group. The issue is not that they know what they should be doing and are doing it poorly. What I see is that we've got managers in place who don't even know what they should be doing.

Sunday, April 1, 2001

Meeting Goals

Done well, retreats and other partner meetings can be powerful tools to influence the success of a professional practice. Certainly, given the cost and time involved, they need to have a noticeable impact if they are to be justified. Alas, this is not always so.

One of the problems is that while management committees spend a great deal of time discussing agendas for the meeting, they rarely are precise about the meeting's goals. In too many cases, firms have not articulated what they want to have happen as a result of the retreat.

Firms should not even consider the agenda until they can give a clear and unequivocal answer to the questions, "What changes do we want to occur as a result of the meeting?" and "How will we know if it is a success or not?"

It is remarkable how often ready answers to these questions are not forthcoming. Firms know they want to have a meeting -- they're just not sure why.


Some Choices

Some of the most important choices that must be resolved are as follows: First, do we want to have a meeting that is broad or focused in the choice of topics? Do we want to cover many topics lightly or a few in depth? Either is doable, but with obvious trade-offs.

Second, having chosen topics, do we want to discuss what you, the individual, can and should be doing or what we, the firm, are going to do? (For example, discussion of marketing could either be sharing what each person has learned about what works for them personally or it could be a discussion of new firm policies and approaches in this area.)

Third, the firm must decide whether the goal of the meeting is to generate ideas or build consensus. One definition of a successful meeting is that many ideas surfaced and each person got something to take away, but each person may also have benefited from different ideas.

Alternatively, the real goal of the meeting may be set at achieving a greater degree of consistency of opinion or support for specific ideas. As before, either is an acceptable definition of success for the meeting and either is achievable. But you have to know which one you are aiming for.

A fourth choice is what benefit you want to provide to the participants: understanding and insight or practical suggestions. One way to serve an individual on a given topic is to help them look at an issue in a new way and have them walk away saying, "I've never thought about it like that before. Maybe I need to do some things differently -- let me think about it!"

Alternatively, understanding may be an insufficient goal (or perhaps everyone already understands the issue), and the real measure of success is to help people not with the "why" and "what" of new ideas but with the specifics of "how." Either can be done but each one uses meeting time very differently, depending on the objective.

Firms might also consider whether they wish the meeting to be the beginning or the end of a process. If the beginning, how are the topics to be introduced? What process will be followed after the meeting to further develop the exploration?

If the goal is for the meeting to bring issues to closure, how will the determination be made that such closure has been reached?


The Importance of Discussion

Part of the difficulty is that firms try to accomplish too much. Many firms construct an agenda covering numerous topics, with many different speakers organised according to a disciplined, military-like schedule. This approach has the virtue of covering a wide range of subjects but without the opportunity for much discussion or closure. It is not clear what such meetings accomplish.

They force the majority of partners to sit on their hands and listen to a long sequence of presentations -- hardly a device for bringing about any change. A retreat, in my view, is a time for partner discussion, not for (impatient) listening.

Too many partner meetings are filled with "information transfer" -- a series of presenters updating the assembled multitude on the latest facts and figures or the status of last year's initiatives. While there usually is a need for information transfer, a series of talking heads (often with lowered lights and 35 mm slides) is guaranteed to waste time and put everyone to sleep.

Instead, firms should find some way to get the information transfer over with quickly and early. Put the materials in the conference package (or better yet, circulate them in advance) and proceed straight to the discussion period for the topic.

A better approach is to focus the meeting around the goal of building consensus for action on specific ideas or initiatives. Note that there is (or should be) a clear distinction between building consensus and decision making. Partner meetings are perfect vehicles for exploring issues (in depth), but en masse decision making is rarely wise.

The best device for ensuring that this distinction is observed is to make clear precisely who will have responsibility for "running with the ball" once the retreat is over. Too many partner meetings have terrific discussions, with many an emerging consensus on a number of good ideas, and then -- nothing happens. Everyone goes back to their practice and nothing ever changes.


One Success Model

Here's one way it can work. The management committee of the firm should decide on what issues it would like to hear the views of the partners. (Hopefully there is something that fits this category!) A separate "retreat committee" might serve the role of proposing topics that management should listen to the partners on, but they'd better check that management is truly willing to listen. I've attended too many retreats where a retreat committee chose topics that the management committee had no intention of doing anything about, and everyone ended up frustrated.

Management's job at the meeting is to shut up and listen. It is not very productive for management to spend much time at a partner meeting on exhortation, inspiration and sharing its views of the firm's strengths and weaknesses. (I have no moral objection here -- I've just never seen it accomplish anything.)

Management already has many opportunities during the year to communicate with the partners about its views and its sense of priorities. A partner meeting is one of the few occasions for the rest of the partners to be heard both by management and other partners.

At the end of the meeting, management's job is to stand up and say, "We've listened to you all weekend, and here are the highlights of what we've heard you say. We now make you a promise that we will go away and deliberate, and we'll come back to you with a concrete action plan. We will undertake to put a specific proposal in front of you within X weeks."

Of course, to pull this off requires preparation, which many firms neglect. I am constantly surprised at retreats where issues are put up for discussion with little or no collection of special information on that issue. Vigorous, fact-free discussions then result. A well-run retreat, in my view, should have special data collected so that the discussion is based on an external reality, not just on previously held biases.

For example, if the topic is marketing or client service, has anyone polled or interviewed clients about the firm's strengths and weaknesses? If the topic is associate development, has anyone polled the associates on what they think we do well and what we do poorly? If the topic is strategy, have the partners been polled (in advance and anonymously) on their sense of priorities and which initiatives have their highest interest?

If the topic is profitability, has any special in-depth analysis been done on precisely where the profits are coming from, which kinds of matters we make money on and which kinds we don't? Partner meeting discussions are too often incestuous: all about what we think about ourselves. It's a simple enough question, yet a frequently neglected one -- if we want the partners to debate an issue, what facts can we put on the table that will enhance the debate?


An Example: Client Panels

A perfect example is provided by client panels. These are so powerful that I am tempted to recommend that they be an essential component of every all-partner meeting. Invite four, five or six good, existing clients of the firm and ask them to address these questions: What do we have to do to deserve and earn more of your business and to obtain unbeatable referrals from you? What should we be doing more of, what less of? Tell us how you buy, and what we can do that is likely to make us attractive to you?

Done at the beginning of a partner meeting, such panels enrich the subsequent discussion immensely, whether that discussion is to be about foreign offices, training, technology or marketing. The fact is that retreats and other partner meetings must be grounded in a market-place reality, and there's no better way to get that information than straight from the horse's mouth.

And, of course, the mere presence of the clients sends an important signal to all partners about the need to test the firm's policies and intentions against the clients' desires. To say, "Oh, yes, we did a client panel a few years back," is insufficient. Listening to the market is an ongoing activity, and I contend that a retreat is the ideal forum to conduct one.


Ensuring Discussion

If the essence of a good retreat is discussion, how do you ensure that a good discussion is held? Some firms deal with the problem of large groups by using "breakout" sessions, dividing the partners into a number of smaller, parallel discussion groups. I have become sceptical about whether breakouts are a productive use of time.

The problem is that if a small group is to tackle an issue of any substance (and it is clearly a waste of time if they do not) then they must be given at least 90 minutes for their deliberations and at least 30 to 45 minutes to report their conclusions. Nothing will have been accomplished if a small group has a discussion but the rest of the partners and management don't get to hear what they concluded.

If there are (as is typical) more than four breakout groups, it can consume a large amount of time just in reporting -- and even that does not allow for the other partners to comment on or react to what the small group had to say. The partnership, in my view, will be better served by staying together and discussing issues together. If the goal of the retreat is to convince, persuade and build consensus, what is important is that everyone participates in the reasoning process, not just the conclusions. Reporting small group conclusions is insufficient for the purpose.

If the group stays together, this can mean a large meeting. How do you handle this? Appointing a facilitator (whether one of the partners or an outsider) is an obvious choice. A good facilitator should be able to "manage" a discussion with up to 100 people and sometimes more. The facilitator's job is to craft the subject matter for specific sessions, run the discussions and "moderate" the debate.

One virtue of a "neutral" outsider is that such a person can often play the St. Sebastian role of being the target for all the arrows, floating provocative ideas and challenging cherished (if hidden) beliefs the firm has about itself. If an outsider is running the discussion, the sessions are less likely to get out of control, particularly if the facilitator has a fund of stories and experiences about what other firms are doing that can be slotted in as quick lecturettes, thus commanding the floor and preventing unproductive discussions from continuing.


Voting Machines

In the last few years, technology has immensely improved the ability to run discussions with large groups. At many recent retreats, I have used a system of voting (or "audience response") machines. They work like this: Each participant has a keypad with buttons marked 1 to 10 and a Yes/No button. At any time during the meeting, with or without pre-planning, the group can be polled as to their feelings about an issue or a proposed action.

They can be invited to agree or disagree with various propositions, vote on a rank ordering of priorities, estimate various percentages (for example, on the use of their time), indicate whether they support or oppose the last speaker and any other types of questions. The results show up immediately on a screen visible to all. If someone feels the question was poorly phrased, then within a matter of seconds the poll can be taken again.

The first virtue of this system is that everyone is involved in expressing their views, not just the handful of people who choose to speak up. At the typical retreat, firm leaders always try to judge the "sense of the meeting," but I have learned that this is uniformly unreliable.

I have been in many meetings where three speakers in a row pointed out the flaws in an idea, leaving a strong sense that the idea was being rejected by the partnership, only to discover that when invited to vote anonymously through the machines more than 90 percent of the partners supported the idea, though they did not wish to speak up.

Second, all views expressed with these machines are anonymous, which is no trivial matter. I long ago learned that what people will say openly and in public at a partner meeting is not always what they really believe. Anonymous voting uncovers what the partners truly believe and not what they feel stampeded into voting for.

Some firm leaders are a little nervous about this, asking, "But what if everyone votes against my proposal? Do I really want that rejection to be so open?" My answer is that if the partners don't buy the idea, management is better off knowing this so it can get to work persuading, convincing, discussing and cajoling -- in other words, leading. Professional firms are (usually) partnerships, and leaders must persuade, not tell.

The third virtue of voting machines is that they make the discussions so much more productive, and that leads to a wise use of time. I have attended many meetings where an hour or more was spent discussing an issue on which everyone already agreed. A simple vote would have enabled the discussion leader to say, "OK, that's a done deal. Let's move on!"

If a vote is taken that shows the group is divided, then it is easy to list the pros and cons and then take the vote again 15 minutes later. If after 30 minutes of discussion the vote remains the same, it is clear that the discussion is changing no one's mind, and it's time to change course.

Finally, it should be noted that voting machines allow demographic information to be inputted, so that while still preserving individual anonymity, it is possible once a vote is taken to say, "Let's see how the responses differ for younger partners versus older partners or how partners in different offices responded." Subgroup averages like these can then be shown instantaneously on the screen.

It is necessary to restress that these machines are not intended to turn the meeting into a vehicle for decision making -- the votes are positioned as a vehicle for taking a "preliminary sense of the meeting." In such a role, this technology will enhance the value of any retreat.

Finally, what about outsiders in roles other than pure facilitation? If you do want to use an outsider, you must first decide whether you want your outsider to function as a speaker or as a consultant. Speakers will convey their own information but will not be able to address the specific circumstances of your firm -- as in, "What does that mean for us?"

It is wise to organise an explicit discussion session immediately following a speaker's remarks to discuss implications, otherwise the speaker's ideas might disappear into the ether. Effectively, a speaker is primarily entertainment; he or she is rarely part of the change process.

The consultant route implies that you will prepare your outside consultant by sharing a great deal of information about the firm -- financials, past strategic plans, client surveys and internal management memos. In addition, it is probably wise for the management committee to meet with the consultant prior to the retreat. If management disagrees with what the consultant believes, you're better off finding that out in advance and resolving any conflicts.

The management and consultant should share a mutual goal -- helping the firm to improve -- and this deserves more than a little scheming. If, as I have argued, a retreat is aimed at making something different occur in the practice, then both management and consultant must understand what it is that the firm wants to improve and precisely how the retreat can be used to make that happen. With the right planning and the right approach, retreats truly are an effective management tool.

Thursday, March 1, 2001

Garbage Can Decision Making

I have attended a number of partnership retreats held by professional service firms wherein the partners attempt to wrestle with some important choice, such as compensation system design, the issue of non-equity partners or forms of governance.

What is striking about these discussions is how disorganised they are and how far-reaching the debate usually becomes. Partners rarely speak to the topic at hand and frequently use the forum to air old grievances, wrestle with issues not on the agenda and waste time repeating points already made.

The conversation swings back and forth between issues of some importance and trivial matters of administrative detail. What's more, there appears to be an inverse relationship between the importance of the topic and the amount of time devoted to it.

As a partner in one law firm pointed out to me, "These retreats are just like our normal partnership meetings. We spend hours arguing about the decoration of offices and then open a branch office because it seems 'right.' Everyone has to have their say, no one sticks to the point and we always end up talking about the same major issues, which never get resolved."

This form of decision making is not restricted to professional service firms. It is, for example, also typical of many university faculty meetings I have attended. It occurs most frequently in organisations that attempt to run themselves on democratic, consensus-building principles. In a book entitled Leadership and Ambiguity, Cohen and March identify a type of organisation they term as "organised anarchy." Many of the ideas discussed here derive from their work. These organisations, they argue, have the following characteristics:

  • An ambiguity of goals, with inconsistent and ill-defined preferences and a multiplicity of objectives: Because of this ambiguity, few issues can be resolved by appealing to unequivocal and mutually shared (or prioritised) goals.
  • An unclear technology: Activities such as teaching, lawyering, consulting and other forms of professional service have ambiguous processes. While there are some regularities of procedure, the activities to be performed remain an "art," learned by experience, trial and error, imitation and inventions born of necessity.
  • Fluid participation: The members of the organisation differ in the degree of time and effort they devote to its concerns. Sometimes a partner will focus solely on his or her own work, leaving organisational decision making to others; at other times, they may be exceedingly concerned with organisational matters and want to be involved. The degree of participation is not specified by an organisational chart, but by the issues addressed, the choices to be made, timing and temperament.
  • Most issues most of the time have low significance for most of the people: The decisions made often secure only partial and erratic attention from the participants, and a major share of the attention devoted to a particular issue is tied less to its content than its symbolic significance and its impact on group esteem.
  • As a consequence of this (previous point), there is high inertia: It takes a great deal of force and energy to get anything changed. There is a tendency to continue with the policies, procedures and patterns of the past.
  • Finally, there is a weak information base: The data necessary for informed decision making is not commonly collected (perhaps because of the unclear technology) and not well disseminated (because of the fluidity of participation).

How do decisions get made in an organised anarchy? Michael Cohen, James March and Johan Olsen, in an article published in Administrative Science Quarterly, called it "garbage can" decision making.

In a garbage can process, there are a large number of unresolved issues or problems: "What do we reward around here? Who has status? What clients should we serve? How can we market ourselves better?"

There also exists a related but quite separate stream of choices to be made: "Should we open a branch office? Should we hire a new lateral partner?"

Third, there is a set of stock "solutions" constantly in the air: "Let's get a computer! Let's departmentalise! Let's hire a more high-powered business manager!"

Finally, there are the participants who are involved to varying degrees with particular problems, solutions and choices.

All four of these elements -- problems, choices, solutions and participants -- are intertwined. There is not (in a garbage can environment) a "clean" decision-making process with circumscribed issues to be decided by a well-defined set of participants with clear, independent choices. Instead, it's all jumbled up.

Cohen, March and Olsen discovered some major properties of such situations:

  • Few problems or issues are dealt with by direct resolution. They are avoided, suppressed or disposed of as a secondary consequence of choice made on some other issue.
  • The more issues there are on the table, the more likely individual problems will not get solved or will take longer to resolve.
  • Although nominally considering different choices at different times, the decision makers keep encountering the same issues again and again.
  • Given the complexities of interrelationships between decisions, issues, actions and people, it matters a good deal in what order issues and choices are confronted.
  • Big choices are much less likely to resolve problems than unimportant choices because big choices are frequently dealt with by compromise.

In such an environment as this, how does one manage? Fortunately, Cohen and March do offer some practical advice. After a semi-apology for the Machiavellian nature of their proposals, they offer the following guidelines for success in leadership in a garbage can environment:

(1) Spend time. A person, they assert, who is willing to spend time on decision-making activities by exploring issues, choices and solutions lays claim to more tolerant consideration of the problems he or she considers important and becomes a major information source in an information-poor world. Influence is obtained by doing the work, serving on the committee, having more facts than others and freeing others from having to worry about management issues.

(2) Persist. In a garbage can world, few issues are resolved once and for all. If a proposal has been rejected today, it may be accepted tomorrow. Decisions are made as a result of a series of episodes involving different people in different settings, and they may be unmade or modified by subsequent episodes.

(3) Exchange status for substance. Cohen and March note that in the universities they studied (as in the professional service firms I have studied), "governance is simultaneously a system for making decisions and a system for certifying status. Participation is an end in itself, not just a means." They suggest that some substantial elements of the governance of universities (and, I would argue, of professional service firms) can best be understood in the light of the hypothesis that "most people are most of the time less concerned with the contents of a decision than they are with eliciting an acknowledgment of their importance within the community." Accordingly, to get things done, exchange status for substance -- a simple rule, but a powerful one.

(4) Facilitate opposition participation. Since in garbage can situations most people do not participate much or very frequently, and since such organisations are generally information weak, many participants' expectations about what can and cannot be achieved, internally or externally, have a tendency to drift away from reality. Accordingly, "educating the opposition" is an important task. Involving them in decision-making committees will tend to correct this situation.

(5) Overload the system. Within an organised anarchy, Cohen and March note, it is a mistake to become absolutely committed to any one project since there are innumerable ways in which the processes will confound the cleverest behaviour with respect to a single proposal, however imaginative or subjectively important. What such organisations cannot do is cope with large numbers of projects. Someone with the habit of producing many proposals, without absolute commitment to any one, may lose any one of them but cannot be stopped on everything.

(6) Provide garbage cans. Since garbage can situations are ones where any choice or decision can provide the opportunity to raise any number of unresolved problems or issues, it is pointless to try to react by attempting to enforce rules of relevance, which are generally somewhat arbitrary. Instead, Cohen and March suggest providing "garbage can topics" to draw the attention of those who wish to raise the extraneous issue and divert these issues away from the topic at hand. The first item on a meeting agenda is suggested as a perfect garbage can.

(7) Manage unobtrusively. As is obvious by now, direct confrontation is unlikely to succeed in a garbage can process. The energy and forces at work in the organisation cannot be suppressed, but they can be redirected to different purposes. Minor actions can produce major effects, although these effects are not perceived by the organisation when the "unimportant" choice to take a minor action is made. Cohen and March point out that the major instruments of unobtrusive management are bureaucratic. For example, if you want to get an organisation used to departments, don't attempt to enforce a formal change. Instead, try changing the format of the accounting reports so that results for different groups are separated out. In time, the groupings will come to be seen as natural. No war will be launched over the format of reports, but the attitudes of the players will be subtly changed. Once this is accomplished the burden of overcoming inertia will be placed on the opposition.

(8) Interpret history. Since most events in organised anarchies are complex and vague, they are subject to various interpretations. (Why did we lose that client? Why are profits down?) He who gets to interpret history gets to influence the future. According to Cohen and March, minutes should be written long enough after the event so as to legitimise the reality of forgetfulness. If you try to write history (in other words, provide the meaning) too soon, opposition will arise, but after a suitable period of time, the "official" history is accepted. By being in command of the written history, the basis can be laid for subsequent independent action in the name of collective action.

The best professional service manager I ever met proceeded in the following way: He never brought an issue to an open forum until he had visited each partner on a one-on-one basis. He listened to their position, reasoned with them in private and framed his proposals for partnership meetings only when this process was completed.

Each person felt consulted and involved, as if he or she had participated in the decision-making process. But the chairman controlled the agenda at meetings and dealt with objections in private. Only when he had discovered what would "sell" did he raise a topic in open debate. Votes on his issues were always unanimous, and issues were not rehashed in public.

There is an art to building consensus. Garbage can situations need leaders who know how to make the organisation work for them rather against them.

As I review the advice Cohen and March provide to leaders of garbage can organisations, I am struck by the analogies between the behaviour they recommend and that exhibited by an astute politician.

It is almost as if they are summarising the tactics a parliamentarian uses in winning support for a bill on Capital Hill. He or she too will win "ownership" of an issue by investing time on behalf of others, persisting, exchanging status for substance (that is, offering co-authorship of a bill), co-opting powerful opponents early on and managing unobtrusively until ready to "go public."

Consensus-based "democracies" are political arenas, whether they are law firms or national assemblies, and the secrets to getting things accomplished are the same. Garbage can leaders in the law could usefully study political biographies (such as Robert Caro's work on Lyndon Johnson), not only for amusement but for sound managerial advice.